Re: The Final One (F1) - Bachelorette 9 - Spoilers - Thread #3

by nd4reality Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:29 pm

atem wrote:
nd4reality wrote:
albean99 wrote:
nd4reality wrote:
atem wrote:NO, it doesn't make sense! Why would Desiree say she wants to go home, etc then?

Seems like you are just trying to fit anything to fit her rejecting Brooks. If that's the case, he's at the MTA.

This could have happened after the F3 RC ?
It is perfectly within possibility that she let him go rather than he rejected her.

It is but I'm not seeing it. Do you see him coming back if she rejects him?

Either way if the spoiler is correct - he has to 'come back'. Reid did it. And Ed did it on the opposite side of the spectrum.

Then Desiree would have just cut Brooks at the F3 RC. That makes NO SENSE to keep him further.

If she felt strongly about something she could have had reservations in even doing an FD date with him right ?

Des said in many interviews that if she thought that someone was not right for her or if she was not right for that person - she let them go. I think it is perfectly viable to think that in this scenario.

Listen atem, I'm just putting things out there from what I have seen. I know as much as the next person but am not prone to visualizing Des riding off into the sunset with the spoiled f1 like others just because.

by BarbB222 Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:31 pm

ND4, for the record, I love your challenging reasoning. Makes for good conversation and analysis while we wait for further SC proof.

by atem Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:31 pm

Oh, brother. I haven't been saying any such thing myself. You sound no different than the people thinking Brooks is Final 1.

by Guest Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:32 pm

atem wrote:
nd4reality wrote:
sophienette wrote:
nd4reality wrote:Oh and 2 seasons to keep in mind while mulling over all this.....

1. Ali with frank leaving at the last minute
2. Jillian with taking Ed back

Ali leaving and Jake trying to get her back...

And 1 episode later she wanted to come back and he said no thanks.

Then why is Chris Harrison asking her what she wants to do next?

She said she wants to go home right after rejecting Brooks?

Why not? Just because she lets him go doesn't mean she can't be unhappy about it. It would be against her heart and what she wants, but maybe she feels it's best, or fears it's best.

by SueSt Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:33 pm

BarbB222 wrote:ND4, for the record, I love your challenging reasoning. Makes for good conversation and analysis while we wait for further SC proof.

Ditto!

by Guest Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:34 pm

If you love him let him go. If he comes back to you he's yours.

by ImeldaMarcos Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:37 pm

canyon - personally, if I love him he is not getting away...but yeah, maybe for Des who knows.

by Guest Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:38 pm

ImeldaMarcos wrote:canyon - personally, if I love him he is not getting away...but yeah, maybe for Des who knows.

I know. It'd take a woman with a lot of confidence to do that. Or, maybe just a woman who doesn't know what she's letting go, or does it out of pure emotion.

by mrsbatonmom Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:41 pm

Have we done a poll lately regarding who everyone thinks is Final 1? I would love to know how everyone is thinking at this point in the season.

by atem Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:44 pm

Great, one says I'm bent on Brooks is final 1 and another saying I'm bent on Brooks not being final 1.

I think it's Chris S. that's Final 1. The edit is building up to it and we actually have screencaps being at the FRC. He's not crying in the limo.

There aren't any caps supporting Brooks has a MTP.

by BarbB222 Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:47 pm

canyonvue wrote:
ImeldaMarcos wrote:canyon - personally, if I love him he is not getting away...but yeah, maybe for Des who knows.

I know. It'd take a woman with a lot of confidence to do that. Or, maybe just a woman who doesn't know what she's letting go, or does it out of pure emotion.

I'm not putting them in the same category but, look at Prince William and Kate. They dated, he seemed non-committal, they separated and Kate goes on with her life although she laments Will. When he sees her with other guys, he realizes he really doesn't want to let her go and they reconnect and the rest is history. In a perfect world girl and boy fall in love the end. But sometimes love takes a different route. Doesn't make it less meaningful. If in the end BOTH parties feel they need each other, they can mend and align what was their mistake and be happily together later.

by Guest Mon Jul 15, 2013 4:48 pm

atem wrote:Great, one says I'm bent on Brooks is final 1 and another saying I'm bent on Brooks not being final 1.

I think it's Chris S. that's Final 1. The edit is building up to it and we actually have screencaps being at the FRC. He's not crying in the limo.

There aren't any caps supporting Brooks has a MTP.

You are certainly taking some flack today! :(

I'm still Brooks as F1, but I am hanging on by a thread. There is just so much evidence stacking up against him.

by Sponsored content