Re: The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #3

[MiaHawk]

All I can see from my little twig on this tree, is that at this point, if a picture is posted of Nick helping a blind man cross the street, it would be taken as him wanting to get the good feeling that comes from doing a good deed and called selfish. SMH

^^^ This.
Do you think Josh ever gave flowers to a girl?
Do you think Chris ever picnicked in a field with a girl?
Do you think Marcus ever stripped down to his skivvies with a girl?
Of course they did. They are on this show to meet and date a girl. Not re-invent the wheel.
Nuff said.

[sdmom]

All I can see from my little twig on this tree, is that at this point, if a picture is posted of Nick helping a blind man cross the street, it would be taken as him wanting to get the good feeling that comes from doing a good deed and called selfish. SMH

^^^ This.  
Do you think Josh ever gave flowers to a girl?  
Do you think Chris ever picnicked in a field with a girl?
Do you think Marcus ever stripped down to his skivvies with a girl?
Of course they did. They are on this show to meet and date a girl.  Not re-invent the wheel.
Nuff said.

This makes me laugh. Thanks for posting.

[MrsDayLewis]

Nick's storybook is one of the sweetest gifts ever on the show. He put thought, time and effort into it and he's a pretty good artist to boot!

[Beagle]

So did Josh give Andi a gift on their fantasy date?

[rosesrREd]

All I can see from my little twig on this tree, is that at this point, if a picture is posted of Nick helping a blind man cross the street, it would be taken as him wanting to get the good feeling that comes from doing a good deed and called selfish. SMH

^^^ This.  
Do you think Josh ever gave flowers to a girl?  
Do you think Chris ever picnicked in a field with a girl?
Do you think Marcus ever stripped down to his skivvies with a girl?
Of course they did. They are on this show to meet and date a girl.  Not re-invent the wheel.
Nuff said.

  

[pander3575]

So did Josh give Andi a gift on their fantasy date?

Maybe Nick needed more help telling Andi he loved her than Josh. Plus who knows what Josh may or may not gave Andi as a gift in the FS.   

[Linds911]

So did Josh give Andi a gift on their fantasy date?

He wrote her a poem, which was shown in the deleted scenes during MTA. His gift for the LCD is a baseball card w/ stats about Andi/their relationship.

[beader]

So are we to believe that Josh has never made a baseball card for anyone before?

[bilolo]

So did Josh give Andi a gift on their fantasy date?

I think Andi did give Josh a gift by maybe telling him he's the one (like Josh going being uncertain about the other relationships she has with others to being 100% sure that he's gonna marry her etc.).

[Piper61]

So are we to believe that Josh has never made a baseball card for anyone before?

   What did his bio say?

[sdmom]

So did Josh give Andi a gift on their fantasy date?

He wrote her a poem, which was shown in the deleted scenes during MTA. His gift for the LCD is a baseball card w/ stats about Andi/their relationship.

Josh is a sweet guy, but writing a poem, this has been done before, does this mean lack of creativity or sincerity? I think many people will disagree.
IMO, as long as they put into time, efforts and do it from their heart, that's sweet and romantic. It's the thoughts, not the gifts themselves, that truly matter.
Andi is very lucky to have Josh and Nick as her final 2.

[stuckinsc]

So did Josh give Andi a gift on their fantasy date?

I think Andi did give Josh a gift by maybe telling him he's the one (like Josh going being uncertain about the other relationships she has with others to being 100% sure that he's gonna marry her etc.).

This actually makes it worse to me. I understand that need to MTP, but if she was so gone over Josh already, then why go all the way through with LCD with Nick? I understand they have a game to play, I guess I had hoped that maybe TPTB did have a heart after Ben's rejection and let the F2 go early. She let Chris go before the evening of FD, so why not let Nick go at the evening portion of LCD if she has already told Josh he is it?

[Sponsored content]