Re: The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #3

[sbolduc]

For me it would be insincere if the idea was not his own or he stole an idea from someone else. Aka Jef quoting someone else's wedding vows when he told Emily he loves her.

In this situation the story was completely about their, Andi and Nicks relationship not to take away from the fact that he spent the time drawing all those pictures and wrote all the pages which could only relate to their situation. Same initial concept but still requiring the same amount of thought, time and effort to make that book.

Insincere to me would be someone else coming up with the idea and him getting them to do it. To me it would be the time he put into the actual book that would show how much he cared. It's like saying someone writing you a poem is insincere because they did not come up with the "idea" of someone writing someone else a poem. JMHO

[isittrue]

For me it would be insincere if the idea was not his own or he stole an idea from someone else. Aka Jef quoting someone else's wedding vows when he told Emily he loves her.

In this situation the story was completely about their, Andi and Nicks relationship not to take away from the fact that he spent the time drawing all those pictures and wrote all the pages which could only relate to their situation. Same initial concept but still requiring the same amount of thought, time and effort to make that book.

Insincere to me would be someone else coming up with the idea and him getting them to do it. To me it would be the time he put into the actual book that would show how much he cared. It's like saying someone writing you a poem is insincere because they did not come up with the "idea" of someone writing someone else a poem. JMHO

ITA! Thank you for expressing exactly what I was thinking!

[pander3575]

For me it would be insincere if the idea was not his own or he stole an idea from someone else. Aka Jef quoting someone else's wedding vows when he told Emily he loves her.

In this situation the story was completely about their, Andi and Nicks relationship not to take away from the fact that he spent the time drawing all those pictures and wrote all the pages which could only relate to their situation. Same initial concept but still requiring the same amount of thought, time and effort to make that book.

Insincere to me would be someone else coming up with the idea and him getting them to do it. To me it would be the time he put into the actual book that would show how much he cared. It's like saying someone writing you a poem is insincere because they did not come up with the "idea" of someone writing someone else a poem. JMHO

Oh Jason and Molly's podcast she thought he stole it from her because that's what she did for Jason.   

[umngirl]

I wouldn't say reusing the idea is insincere. I just think it's lame to reuse it. Be original dude.

[rosesrREd]

This is his ABC bio. Was there more to it? I wonder why no one noticed that change until now.

Sophie's site

ABC

Bachelor Bio

What is your ideal mate's personality like?
Someone who is truly confident in herself and expects a lot but gives as much. Someone who wants to bring out the best in me.

What is the most romantic present you have ever received and why?
100 reasons why they love me.  It was genius!

What's your biggest date fear?

I don't really have one, but going on a date with someone who ended up having a boyfriend and running into him would suck.

If you could do/have any job in the world, what would it be and why?
It would be awesome to know how to sing and be some sort of performer; to feed off other's people's energy is intense. The feeling they must feel would be cool. Too bad I can't sing.

The bios aren't put up until a week or so before the show starts airing, so it's not inconceivable that the storybook he is talking about is the one he wrote for Andi? Also, didn't Catherine mention something about "riding an elephant in Thailand" on her ABC bio?

[umngirl]

This is his ABC bio. Was there more to it? I wonder why no one noticed that change until now.

Sophie's site

ABC

Bachelor Bio

What is your ideal mate's personality like?
Someone who is truly confident in herself and expects a lot but gives as much. Someone who wants to bring out the best in me.

What is the most romantic present you have ever received and why?
100 reasons why they love me.  It was genius!

What's your biggest date fear?

I don't really have one, but going on a date with someone who ended up having a boyfriend and running into him would suck.

If you could do/have any job in the world, what would it be and why?
It would be awesome to know how to sing and be some sort of performer; to feed off other's people's energy is intense. The feeling they must feel would be cool. Too bad I can't sing.

The bios aren't put up until a week or so before the show starts airing, so it's not inconceivable that the storybook he is talking about is the one he wrote for Andi?  Also, didn't Catherine mention something about "riding an elephant in Thailand" on her ABC bio?

She did mention it as one of her bucket list items. Since the show, she has mentioned the other bucket list items when talking about future travel so I don't think that was an addition after the show.

The girls bios were also released before the season finished filming, they were out in September in fact.

[isittrue]

I assume that the profiles are released after filming is completed so I don't know if we have any idea what was put in the bios to fit what happens during filming IMO.

[sbolduc]

I wouldn't say reusing the idea is insincere. I just think it's lame to reuse it. Be original dude.

I agree with this not insincere but would've better to come up something original. Although I would rather him re-use his own idea than copy someone else ie. Molly

[bilolo]

Are you ready to know who the final 1 is or you already know it ?

[sdmom]

Means he is insincere .. It it's really true I pity him

I respectfully disagree.

[stuckinsc]

Zak drew Des pictures of their journey and gave them to her at the F5. Des then turned around and did the same thing for Chris and gave it to him at his HTD. I think a good idea is sweet. To each their own.

[Kashathediva]

This is his ABC bio. Was there more to it? I wonder why no one noticed that change until now.

Sophie's site

ABC

Bachelor Bio

What is your ideal mate's personality like?
Someone who is truly confident in herself and expects a lot but gives as much. Someone who wants to bring out the best in me.

What is the most romantic present you have ever received and why?
100 reasons why they love me.  It was genius!

What's your biggest date fear?

I don't really have one, but going on a date with someone who ended up having a boyfriend and running into him would suck.

If you could do/have any job in the world, what would it be and why?
It would be awesome to know how to sing and be some sort of performer; to feed off other's people's energy is intense. The feeling they must feel would be cool. Too bad I can't sing.

The bios aren't put up until a week or so before the show starts airing, so it's not inconceivable that the storybook he is talking about is the one he wrote for Andi?  Also, didn't Catherine mention something about "riding an elephant in Thailand" on her ABC bio?

Yep. Emily did something similar Brad's season.

[Sponsored content]