Re: The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #3

[stuckinsc]

No offense to anyone, but I think if you are a Nick as F1 fan you saw her more excited with Nick, if you are a Josh as F1 fan you saw her over the top with Josh.

I am neither, I just want the guys happy. I saw her happy for both ILYs but not over the top like I saw Ash with JP for either ILY.

I don't mean it as an insult, but I do think the fangirl glasses help us interpret things one way or another. I haven't cared this little who the lead picks since Ben, then I felt he should pick no one since I liked Kacie B, but after her HTD knew that would be a disaster. I felt about Nikki last season the way most of you feel about your F1 pick now. I will say that even with that, I watched JPG thinking he didn't really make his decision until the night before.

[nutty1]

No offense to anyone, but I think if you are a Nick as F1 fan you saw her more excited with Nick, if you are a Josh as F1 fan you saw her over the top with Josh.

I am neither, I just want the guys happy.  I saw her happy for both ILYs but not over the top like I saw Ash with JP for either ILY.

I don't mean it as an insult, but I do think the fangirl glasses help us interpret things one way or another.  I haven't cared this little who the lead picks since Ben, then I felt he should pick no one since I liked Kacie B, but after her HTD knew that would be a disaster.  I felt about Nikki last season the way most of you feel about your F1 pick now.  I will say that even with that, I watched JPG thinking he didn't really make his decision until the night before.

I totally agree, and I am not afraid to admit it. During Des's season, I saw NO potential for her and Chris, but his fans did.

Truthfully, she was into both Nick and Josh during the FD's, and who we see her more into is purely subjective.

[bleuberry]

I can really say that I see something great with both guys. I'm team Nick, until a date with Josh, and then I'm team Josh. Until I see her with Nick again

I like both, but I do see that lifestyle wise it is no secret that she fits in with Josh's the most.

[stuckinsc]

I can really say that I see something great with both guys.  I'm team Nick, until a date with Josh, and then I'm team Josh. Until I see her with Nick again

I like both, but I do see that lifestyle wise it is no secret that she fits in with Josh's the most.

I can totally agree that it would be much easier to pick Josh and stay in Atlanta. Chicago would be a huge difference. The best experiences in my life were when I decided to take that huge chance, so I kind of hope she takes the chance.

[Tiggerlgh]

I can really say that I see something great with both guys.  I'm team Nick, until a date with Josh, and then I'm team Josh. Until I see her with Nick again

I like both, but I do see that lifestyle wise it is no secret that she fits in with Josh's the most.

This describes how I am as well overall. And I agree She will fit in great with Josh s family

[nikikass]

Well, I see her with either, there is no clear consensus on the "winner"

If that vid was not out. I would not have a clue which one she picked.

WHen she is with Josh its Josh. When she is with Nick its Nick.

WHoever had their last chance date that is who is F1. Woudn't surprise me if she had to ask them to pick a number between 1-10. (hee hee)

[Guest]

is there a list for the nick clues somewhere?

yes, Gabriele.
check MVMom's list on page 7 of Nick's fan thread.

thanks sue   

[Cecilia]

I can really say that I see something great with both guys.  I'm team Nick, until a date with Josh, and then I'm team Josh. Until I see her with Nick again

I like both, but I do see that lifestyle wise it is no secret that she fits in with Josh's the most.

I can totally agree that it would be much easier to pick Josh and stay in Atlanta.  Chicago would be a huge difference.  The best experiences in my life were when I decided to take that huge chance, so I kind of hope she takes the chance.

I think Nick would have moved for her. I think she was torn between wanting to date someone different vs the one she would usually go for. And then she picked her usual type. I think it is that simple. I do think that Josh may be a better fit for Andi in that I don't think Nick would fit well with a self-described "bratty diva."   We haven't seen her show that side to Nick, but Nick alluded to it in the video when describing her as "stubborn." Which sounds a lot nicer than "bratty diva." But you love who you love so maybe Nick was aware of this side to her and still embraced it. Like every season (except Ben's now!) we will never know the full story.

[Bet2Win]

I don't have a favorite. I felt she was subdued with both Nick and Josh during the FD's. She told them both that she was happy they were there. She told them both she was happy to hear the ILY's.

But, realistically, she only feels it for one of them; otherwise there's no way she would get engaged if she feels it for both of them. One is for real (bubble real), the other is for show.

[Kashathediva]

I never care who they pick, unless they decide to start paying my bills or start taking care of my day to day trial and tribulations. Until then, I'll leave it to my higher and remember this is just a tv show.

[nutty1]

I never care who they pick, unless they decide to start paying my bills or start taking care of my day to day trial and tribulations.  Until then, I'll leave it to my higher and remember this is just a tv show.

That's a great mindset. I get so caught up in it, but after the show, I always lose interest in them anyway, LOL!

[stuckinsc]

I never care who they pick, unless they decide to start paying my bills or start taking care of my day to day trial and tribulations.  Until then, I'll leave it to my higher and remember this is just a tv show.

That's a great mindset. I get so caught up in it, but after the show, I always lose interest in them anyway, LOL!

Agreed! I enjoy the process and making fun of it with others!

[Sponsored content]