Bachelorette 10: Edit-Storyline - *SPOILERS* - should we bother? Oooohhhh... why not?

I commented on the video a while back. It is still inconclusive to me. Yes, he mentions Josh. Yes, he mentions meeting her family. Yes, Reality Steve is glowing like a peacock.

On the other hand... since Daddy crashed the mansion on night one, we can't be 100% certain only the top two see her parents. We do NOT hear the questions being asked on the phone and do not know if every "he" is Josh and every "she" is Andi. It is also odd that we get two separate videos with no continuous flow, we rarely see his face, we have to question why he is not with a handler (although maybe they don't bother anymore with them when the guys leave)... the list goes on.

Yet... like the Brooks spoiler last year that was confirmed by three others besides Steve, I guess you could still use it as "evidence". In past seasons, lists were drawn up with each contestant with The Spoiler being used to support one of the contestants. Hope I don't sound nitpicky here.

... and it is not like I am against Josh being F1 either.

I hear you. Lots of questions.
I would personally LOVE to see a huge twist this season just for the 'fun' of it but I am also not opposed to the idea that Andi found true love with Josh. Seems to be a nice enough dude.

So you are suggesting that possibly, all of the final 3 guys had a 'meet the parents' session with Andi's parents?
That,

With the airplane video spoiler though, it can only be one of two things IMO:
1. Legitimately Nick being taped unawares (if this is the case, he is F2 of either 2 or 3 final men standing- which by a huge stretch might be Chris as F1- since Nick only mentions Josh in the context of his now rejection)
2. Grand foiler scheme. (if this is the case, would he participate if he was not F1??)

We aren't 100% certain Josh "won" anything. We just know he won't say s**t like Nick does on an airplane and will "do whatever she wants"... and "she" could easily be Andi... or Amy... or Cassie... the lady who interviewed each as a potential lead for next Bachelor... or Josh's Mom (you should see the hilarious thread at abc.com about her).

BUT... let's suppose Nick does claim Josh "won". We even have these possibilities:
a.) Josh boomeranged after his elimination like Jillian's Reid and crashed the FRC... and was still "in the vicinity" waiting to see her when Nick got dumped
b.) Chris either left or was eliminated and boomeranged back after she axed both Nick and Josh
c.) Nick himself is the boomerang-er and "disagreed" with her not accepting him back

OK... maybe c is a bit far-fetched. Yet there are sssssooooooo many possibilities that it will drive us bonkers going through them. I am operating this season like one of those Budweiser Clydesdales with my blinders on. Got too exhausted with all of the "media" and "spoilage" in past seasons and sticking mostly to the show and just the occasional interviews and such.

My opinion of the video in a nut-shell: it is "maybe" evidence. Once Josh is declared the winner, it will be "solid" evidence. *chuckle chuckle*

What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

nd4reality wrote:What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

Alex 2.0 ? (on FS Alex told Trista he would pick her)  :halo: 

nd4reality wrote:What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

Or his handler had assured him that she was going to pick him. Isn't that what some contestants from past seasons have said is what happens?

^ I believe Nick said "it really seemed at the last moment that she changed her mind." It could be just as simple as he felt they had a solid connection throughout and he felt that she changed her mind. I always think back to Lindsay Yenter who was also F2. She was shocked she wasn't Sean's F1.

murasaki1393 wrote:

nd4reality wrote:What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

Alex 2.0 ? (on FS Alex told Trista he would pick her)  :halo: 

Ashley F accused Sean of lying to her as well. Nick now follows Ashley on socmed. One of those something or nothing things.

nd4reality wrote:What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

I think that's just his rational for her decision.

atem wrote:

nd4reality wrote:What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

I think that's just his rational for her decision.

Very likely.

^ yup, the key words in what he said was "it seemed like she changed her mind"

SLA44 wrote:

nd4reality wrote:What was curious to me was him saying she "changed her mind".

Did she tell him 100% at some point that she was going to choose him ?

Or his handler had assured him that she was going to pick him.  Isn't that what some contestants from past seasons have said is what happens?

Yep! I think Ben Flajnik also hinted at this when he was rejected and it was clear all along Ashley would choose JP.  The producers gets the F2 all worked up for more drama in final episode