Josh Murray - BIP - Famously Single - Season 3 - *Sleuthing - Spoilers*

ED wrote:

babs wrote:Is Josh Christian or Jewish?

Christian.

Thank you. Someone I was talking to thought he was Jewish since Andi is Jewish and thought that might be the reason she picked him. I thought I remember him posting Bible verses or some reference to the Bible.

His mom was Jewish so technically the kids were born Jewish also, but they all converted a few years ago. Another incompatibility with Andi: was the plan that she'd sit at home while everyone went to church on Sunday mornings? Idiots. Hopefully he and Amanda are much more compatible in all areas.

Very well said Seabear!

At first glance Andi's book makes Josh out to look like an awful boyfriend/fiance, but if you really pay attention (I both read and listened to her audio book), you see a man that is faithful & loving. People get lost in her play on words and her anger and resentment in the last few months, but she admits their first four months together were bliss, and those were spent NOT in front of the camera. They had an open, honest relationship and all was going well. Like seabear said, all went downhill with the lie and public humiliation.

Josh said he learned a ton from that relationship. Let's hope he puts it to good use and doesn't make the same mistakes with Amanda. I really want to see this work out for both of their dakes (and of course the girls!).

so if Amanda does not sleep with Nick and then proceed to not tell Josh we should be golden.j

whit90 wrote:

Fingersandtoes wrote:There are now 4 people we've read on this thread saying that Josh has been rude and obnoxious to them. They didn't call him a monster, and it doesn't mean he is one. But personally, if I was getting into a relationship with a guy, and heard from multiple people that (especially when drunk) a guy is a jerk, there would be warning bells ringing in my head. Especially if I had kids, that'd be a double alarm. Jmo.

Just curious who are the four people that have meet Josh in real life that have said he was rude and obnoxious?
In no way I am discredited what you say but I have read all the post and to me there was only one. Jolena has said that she meet him in a bar and was very kind and sweet and did not get drunk. JMO

Andi, Janner (Jade), Molly and the poster's (sorry, I forgot their name) friend. I wouldn't go discounting their experiences just because there are positive ones too. Jmo.

Whelp. In this case, the best we can do is hope for the best. For the sake of the little people.

Here is what I know.  All people all flawed....perfection does not exist. In choosing a life partner...those that work the best are the ones with strong foundations based in trust, respect, faithfulness and love.  What helps the longevity of a relationship is picking a person who accentuates your strengths and motivates you to be the best version of yourself. I hope Josh and Amanda have found that in each other. Like all couples from this Franchise...time will tell.

JMO

nd4reality wrote:so if Amanda does not sleep with Nick and then proceed to not tell Josh we should be golden.j

What's really, really sad is Amanda could have. I mean it's possible because she was there in the beginning and so was Nick and then Josh showed up. Is there an after show where Josh could call her out? I don't think this happened AT ALL it's just sad that it is possible.

casjacknick wrote:

nd4reality wrote:so if Amanda does not sleep with Nick and then proceed to not tell Josh we should be golden.j

What's really, really sad is Amanda could have. I mean it's possible because she was there in the beginning and so was Nick and then Josh showed up. Is there an after show where Josh could call her out? I don't think this happened AT ALL it's just sad that it is possible.

Too funny!




There is no sleeping "with" in the first few episodes till the overnights. Unless of course it is on camera. Oh wait that happened already so one participant of this scenario has it down pat.

nd4reality wrote:

casjacknick wrote:

nd4reality wrote:so if Amanda does not sleep with Nick and then proceed to not tell Josh we should be golden.j

What's really, really sad is Amanda could have. I mean it's possible because she was there in the beginning and so was Nick and then Josh showed up. Is there an after show where Josh could call her out? I don't think this happened AT ALL it's just sad that it is possible.

Too funny!




There is no sleeping "with" in the first few episodes till the overnights. Unless of course it is on camera. Oh wait that happened already so one participant of this scenario has it down pat.

Rules don't apply in BIP. Tanner and Jade were almost living together from what I read.

It would be too amazing if tptb were able to pull this off again. Give those peeps an Emmy!!

Omg one can only HOPE Nick1 and Amanda did the nasty epi 1! Hopefully we can recreate "fiancé stuff" at the Live Finale After Paradise! Please, oh please!

I kid. My conscience is kicking in and I'm starting to feel badly for the little girls. Haha