Josh Murray - BIP - Famously Single - Season 3 - *Sleuthing - Spoilers*

SeekAny wrote:Let's not sell him short Alanna, he loves to admit he's "picky." That's like the classic non weakness weakness answer on a job interview! 

And dude, you're not picky, you get engaged on every TV show possible.

I think when he says he's picky is just a line he uses. He got engaged the first time after 10 weeks of knowing someone. Then the second time he gets engaged again after knowing for 2/3 weeks. All on camera no less.

Let's not forget he wanted to join JoJo 's season too. So, so picky this one.

Lennoxcolinrolland wrote:

Eviebloom wrote:

StacyNor wrote:
If I remember correctly. Molly never got a Neil's ring because she was a second choice. On their anniversary or something like that, Jason and Neil surprised Molly by getting her a Neil Lane ring. Molly posted it on Instagram and Josh had a something to say about it how it looked like Andi 's ring.

Is that rude to say the rings looked similar?  That means the guys have similar taste in picking out rings.  Josh obviously liked the ring when he picked it out.  It might have just been a comment or a compliment.  

It wasn't a compliment, as Molly appeared to be offended and angry afterward.
IMO.

I remember the incident being discussed here. 
I do not recall it reflecting well on Josh and it appeared rude. IMO
I do remember the discussion being those that fanned him thinking nothing wrong with it, and again imo. 
Most human beings, no matter how saintly we might be, have on occasion behaved less than saintly especially when under the influence. I do not see Josh as an exception. Certainly does not make him satan, but human.

I remember that also. I thought it was a weird thing to say esp after your engagement failed. Awkward.

I think it would be smart to reign in the public persona/power couple thing and take things slow. He's been there, done that.

bleuberry wrote:Let's not forget he wanted to join JoJo 's season too. So, so picky this one.

How amazing if this had happened, he'd been let go early and then still appeared on BIP and gotten engaged to Amanda?  tptb really screwed the pooch not letting him on imo.

Fingersandtoes wrote:There are now 4 people we've read on this thread saying that Josh has been rude and obnoxious to them. They didn't call him a monster, and it doesn't mean he is one. But personally, if I was getting into a relationship with a guy, and heard from multiple people that (especially when drunk) a guy is a jerk, there would be warning bells ringing in my head. Especially if I had kids, that'd be a double alarm. Jmo.

Just curious who are the four people that have meet Josh in real life that have said he was rude and obnoxious?
In no way I am discredited what you say but I have read all the post and to me there was only one. Jolena has said that she meet him in a bar and was very kind and sweet and did not get drunk. JMO

No offense but Jade and Tanner would not be people I trust, they seem like they'd throw anyone under the bus for five minutes of attention. JMO.

I think Molly got that style ring because it's similar to her original ring - just on a grander Neil Lane blingy level. So, it's obviously a style (very common style, my engagment ring is also similar style) that Molly favors. I just looked through the comments on Molly's pic. Not only did Josh comment, but so did Kelly Travis that it looked like Andi's. Tacky AF, guys. Molly responded back a few times that hers is rose gold, Andi's was not, so different rings. You could tell Molly was not amused at the implications.

Is Josh Christian or Jewish?

I get the this is the Josh thread but really it is Amanda that has to deal with her / their decisions. she could not have been clueless about him Going into this being part of the bachelor family. 

Personally Im still holding out for a love story and no engagement.

babs wrote:Is Josh Christian or Jewish?

Christian.

I think Josh has the potential to be the best version of himself in a relationship with a woman who he trusts, loves and can be devoted to...and those feelings are reciprocated. From what I have seen Josh wants to be a protector, friend and lover. With a woman who is strong but sweet like Amanda is and obviously has a capacity for love and devotion as is evidenced by her daughters...maybe Jam has what it takes.  I see Josh and Amanda having similar life goals.  I hope things work out for them.

IMO Josh/Andi were Toxic together.  They were a disaster from the start.  No relationship that starts on Lies and includes public humiliation is ever going to be healthy or last.  As evidenced by her book... Andi is still in the toxic mode.  It appears Josh has moved on to much better things.

JMO