Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 8 - HTDs - Jul 07/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

^ Technically, if she did pick him, they did essentially get three days. The FRC was the 9th and he arrived home in the afternoon on the 12th. Even though there are wrap parties on the 9th, they still would have been together as a couple if she did pick him and then for half a day on the 12th. Andi started media rounds basically the next day. There wasn't much room to go with. Regardless, Nick came home the 11th and Josh came home on the 12th.

GuardianAngel wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

BTW, Josh only came home less than a day after Nick, so therefore, is he really home later????

Well what would you call it?  The same day?  See perfect example , I guess I could have said not on the same flight...

If I may respectfully respond my opinion on Auntie's point, it's not three or four days which is the norm for the lead and F1.

Well if I may respectfully respond. here it is again anything with Josh is dismissed or swept away....... When you have Nick's return before Josh's no matter what the time frame is he still returned after Nick that imo is significant as a clue to something whether Josh is F1 or not...... And for me this is a perfect example of how lightly or trivial any info that is pertaining to Josh, I am not a sleuther but I have been around spoilers sites for years, it just seem like any information would be given weight for any of the contestant whether you like them or not...

jen689 wrote:

Rosepetal wrote: May 12th also is the day Andi resurfaced on twitter and started retweeting things.

We were discussing when Andi resurfaced on social media in the Nick Contestant thread yesterday.  She favored a tweet on May 9th.  Josh posted a tweet on May 10th and Nick favored a tweet on May 10th.

I did forget about Josh tweeting about his little bother being drafted. I didn't look to see if Andi favored anything back then so my mistake.

Andi favorited the tweet on May 10th, Josh sent out a tweet on the 10th and Nick favorited a tweet on the 11th.

luvlady345 wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

BTW, Josh only came home less than a day after Nick, so therefore, is he really home later????

Well what would you call it?  The same day?  See perfect example , I guess I could have said not on the same flight...

If I may respectfully respond my opinion on Auntie's point, it's not three or four days which is the norm for the lead and F1.

Well if I may respectfully respond. here it is again anything with Josh is dismissed or swept away....... When you have Nick's return before Josh's no matter what the time frame is he still returned after Nick that imo is significant as a clue to something whether Josh is F1 or not...... And for me this is a perfect example of how lightly or trivial any info that is pertaining to Josh,  I am not a sleuther but I have been around spoilers sites for years, it just seem like any information would be given weight for any of the contestant whether you like them or not...  

Nothing is being swept away. It's a another opinion is all that it is. Being a sleuther, every detail is examined. FRC May 9th which is in the evening, Josh returning in the USA the afternoon of the 12th, is not three days. Evening of May 9th to evening of May 10th is 1 day, May 10th to evening of May 11th is 2 days, May 12th is a travel day. The point is, they got ripped off if he's the F1 compared to other F1's and the lead. We all know Nick returned later, that's not the point.

I along with anyone else will continue to speculate and sleuth and discuss without worrying about insert panties in a knott smilies here for the rest of the season and future seasons.

relaxing wrote:

nutty1 wrote:At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

Marcus and Chris are my favs and the only evidence of F1  I've seen is for Josh.  Everything else is speculation and conjecture from my point of view. Just an opinion.

All we had in Des's season on Chris was speculation and conjecture. Chris posted a pic on instagram of himself sitting on the pig in Seattle with #piggyback. That was one of the best clues we got, so you just never know what matters and what doesn't. If I don't agree that a tweet or whatever is a clue, I don't see how that matters?    We can all have our own perspective. I'm always hopeful that RS will be foiled again, but sadly the odds seem against it this time.

grace8136 wrote:
All we had in Des's season on Chris was speculation and conjecture. Chris posted a pic on instagram of himself sitting on the pig in Seattle with #piggyback. That was one of the best clues we got, so you just never know what matters and what doesn't. If I don't agree that a tweet or whatever is a clue, I don't see how that matters?    We can all have our own perspective. I'm always hopeful that RS will be foiled again, but sadly the odds seem against it this time.

I'm stealing that for my tag line, is that ok?

GuardianAngel wrote:

grace8136 wrote:
All we had in Des's season on Chris was speculation and conjecture. Chris posted a pic on instagram of himself sitting on the pig in Seattle with #piggyback. That was one of the best clues we got, so you just never know what matters and what doesn't. If I don't agree that a tweet or whatever is a clue, I don't see how that matters?    We can all have our own perspective. I'm always hopeful that RS will be foiled again, but sadly the odds seem against it this time.

I'm stealing that for my tag line, is that ok?

Would it be valuable to have a look at the first pic each posted on IG and first tweet following the FRC date to see if it could be a clue? A side by side comparison?

GuardianAngel wrote:

grace8136 wrote:
All we had in Des's season on Chris was speculation and conjecture. Chris posted a pic on instagram of himself sitting on the pig in Seattle with #piggyback. That was one of the best clues we got, so you just never know what matters and what doesn't. If I don't agree that a tweet or whatever is a clue, I don't see how that matters?    We can all have our own perspective. I'm always hopeful that RS will be foiled again, but sadly the odds seem against it this time.

I'm stealing that for my tag line, is that ok?

  of course!

GuardianAngel wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

If I may respectfully respond my opinion on Auntie's point, it's not three or four days which is the norm for the lead and F1.

Well if I may respectfully respond. here it is again anything with Josh is dismissed or swept away....... When you have Nick's return before Josh's no matter what the time frame is he still returned after Nick that imo is significant as a clue to something whether Josh is F1 or not...... And for me this is a perfect example of how lightly or trivial any info that is pertaining to Josh,  I am not a sleuther but I have been around spoilers sites for years, it just seem like any information would be given weight for any of the contestant whether you like them or not...  

Nothing is being swept away. It's a another opinion is all that it is. Being a sleuther, every detail is examined. FRC May 9th which is in the evening, Josh returning in the USA the afternoon of the 12th, is not three days. Evening of May 9th to evening of May 10th is 1 day, May 10th to evening of May 11th is 2 days, May 12th is a travel day. The point is, they got ripped off if he's the F1 compared to other F1's and the lead. We all know Nick returned later, that's not the point.

I along with anyone else will continue to speculate and sleuth and discuss without worrying about insert panties in a knott smilies here for the rest of the season and future seasons.

Nah, I am not missing the point and really it doesn't matter to me....

^^ Yeah, I'm not really understanding why it's such a big deal that they got less time than other couples. I thought it had been stated definitively that production was delayed for a few days because of Eric's funeral. So, if the FRC was originally supposed to be on May 7th, then Andi and her F1 (let's say, oh, Josh) would have had from the 7th to the 12th. Voila -- five days together, which is more in line with what the other couples had. So sure, maybe they got ripped off, but what are you gonna do? They had to make accommodations for the funeral, and unfortunately the extra time had to be pulled from those last days in the DR. Seems pretty straightforward.

Eagle Eye wrote:^^ Yeah, I'm not really understanding why it's such a big deal that they got less time than other couples. I thought it had been stated definitively that production was delayed for a few days because of Eric's funeral. So, if the FRC was originally supposed to be on May 7th, then Andi and her F1 (let's say, oh, Josh) would have had from the 7th to the 12th. Voila -- five days together, which is more in line with what the other couples had. So sure, maybe they got ripped off, but what are you gonna do? They had to make accommodations for the funeral, and unfortunately the extra time had to be pulled from those last days in the DR. Seems pretty straightforward.

some here are saying if they did in fact spend ~5 days in cancun it was partly to make up for the lack of time post-FRC in the DR. that is plausible to me.