Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 8 - HTDs - Jul 07/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

Kashathediva wrote:Either I am a damn good sleuther picking out all your favs flaves or I am psychic. Take your pick!  :halo:

sophienette wrote:I have a HUGE problem...

I couldnt choose between Salty caramel,  Red velvet, cookies and cream and butter pecan...   

SueSt wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

Piper61 wrote:Most everything that people post is based upon their perception about things  as subjective as what was posted.  It is an opinion that each person forms, and in this case, Andi kind of prompted that perception/opinion when she saw Josh out of the limo and stated later "Nailed it, pegged it, dame" which I think confirms she found him to be physically hot.

Maybe, but saying it like she says it every episode(which she doesn't)someone can look at it like words are being put into her mouth.  Just think that there are other things that maybe should be looked at as equally or more important than looks.  For example, they don't really talk about much...we aren't getting to know who Josh is other than the Jock who she isn't liking in him.  I think that in the end, it is her decision and that is that.  Can you see how there really isn't much substance in their conversations??

yes, I definitely can.  She says things like why should I trust you... and he says, because I'm telling you to trust me.  I find him very vapid, defensive and over-confident; the plastic prince.  In comparison (and sorry to keep harping on him) her conversation with Nick are, to me, very real and filled with lots of details.  He explains himself fully using specific details, owning up to his own mistakes and insecurities and sharing a very vulnerable side with Andi; swoon-worthy.  

Aunties_Love wrote:

missjayne wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:
Whoa, I don't think Chris is the problem.  He's just standing up for himself and NOT being the disturber.

okay well perhaps he's a victim of editing as well...I mean why else are he and Nick still friends.

Editing does play a big part.  For most of the season, Chris said nothing.  He was said to of not existed.  Then in two epis where we hear from him, he's now called a disturber....sheesh, the poor guy can't win.

Kashathediva wrote:Ooooh fun time:
Marquel: cookies and cream
JJ: Pistachio
Nick: Salty caramel
Chris: butter pecan
Marcus: banana swirl
Josh: red velvet cake
Dylan: rocky road
Brian: mint choc chip

beader wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:Ooooh fun time:
Marquel: cookies and cream
JJ: Pistachio
Nick: Salty caramel
Chris: butter pecan
Marcus: banana swirl
Josh: red velvet cake
Dylan: rocky road
Brian: mint choc chip

I certainly don't want a bottle of fake food coloring in my dessert!  But I'd take any of the others.

Well I will gladly take the fake food coloring everyday of the week and twice on sundays!!!!    

nannymargie wrote:

beader wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:Ooooh fun time:
Marquel: cookies and cream
JJ: Pistachio
Nick: Salty caramel
Chris: butter pecan
Marcus: banana swirl
Josh: red velvet cake
Dylan: rocky road
Brian: mint choc chip

I certainly don't want a bottle of fake food coloring in my dessert!  But I'd take any of the others.

Well I will gladly take the fake food coloring everyday of the week and twice on sundays!!!!    

Aunties_Love wrote:

nannymargie wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:
Holy Moly, guess I am thinking that Josh is far from the hottest, sexiest guy......sheesh,

If Josh is not your cup of tea or type that is totally fine.  He happens to be a Hot cup of tea for a lot of us.  For me Nick does nothing for me, like they say he's  to vanilla.

That's fine, but in the end, I think you are trying to put words in Andi's mouth regarding how she'd be a dummy to let that guy go.   Seriously, this is Andi's choice.  Again, I think that some will be seriously surprised here if Andi doesn't choose Josh.

Judiful wrote:

SueSt wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:
Maybe, but saying it like she says it every episode(which she doesn't)someone can look at it like words are being put into her mouth.  Just think that there are other things that maybe should be looked at as equally or more important than looks.  For example, they don't really talk about much...we aren't getting to know who Josh is other than the Jock who she isn't liking in him.  I think that in the end, it is her decision and that is that.  Can you see how there really isn't much substance in their conversations??

yes, I definitely can.  She says things like why should I trust you... and he says, because I'm telling you to trust me.  I find him very vapid, defensive and over-confident; the plastic prince.  In comparison (and sorry to keep harping on him) her conversation with Nick are, to me, very real and filled with lots of details.  He explains himself fully using specific details, owning up to his own mistakes and insecurities and sharing a very vulnerable side with Andi; swoon-worthy.  

     The bottom line is we are only exposed to the  heavily edited portions to the conversations allowed by TPTB..It would be cool to be a fly on the wall. There is no way all Andi and Josh talked about all day long and late into the evening was those infamous trust issues .....That's JMO  From the little we have seen...I would guess they are playful, flirty and lots of fun together..and I think it        was game over after their first kiss !!  

b wrote:

Judiful wrote:

SueSt wrote:
yes, I definitely can.  She says things like why should I trust you... and he says, because I'm telling you to trust me.  I find him very vapid, defensive and over-confident; the plastic prince.  In comparison (and sorry to keep harping on him) her conversation with Nick are, to me, very real and filled with lots of details.  He explains himself fully using specific details, owning up to his own mistakes and insecurities and sharing a very vulnerable side with Andi; swoon-worthy.  

     The bottom line is we are only exposed to the  heavily edited portions to the conversations allowed by TPTB..It would be cool to be a fly on the wall. There is no way all Andi and Josh talked about all day long and late into the evening was those infamous trust issues .....That's JMO  From the little we have seen...I would guess they are playful, flirty and lots of fun together..and I think it        was game over after their first kiss !!  

    Enjoyed reading this.  I bolded my thoughts as well.  Are they just trying to show Josh as the physical edit and Nick as the emotional/mental one?  If so, they've succeeded w Josh (lots of chemistry between them), but I think her relationship w Nick has been shown to emotional/intellectual and physical.  If spoilers are true, I hope Josh is a better communicator than they have shown, otherwise, I don't see them lasting b/c Andi (the edited version anyway) certainly needs that.