Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 8 - HTDs - Jul 07/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

Judiful wrote:

Piper61 wrote:

soccermom333 wrote:




    Okay, this is why I need to read all the way through a page before I post!!!  I just said this.  LOL  

 :cutesmile!:   We are reading the same book, on the same page, at the same time!

        This is really a lot of fun .Everybody sees people places , and things in their own unique ways, but it's always cool to be on the same page with people . I think the bickering between Andi and Josh is kind of cute...making up will be the most adorable . The edits made it seem worse than it was IMO .. I can't imagine her with anybody but him ..  I love them together       

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

rosesrREd wrote:


I agree Aunties_Love, we do NOT KNOW.   I realize that Josh is the spoiled F1, but we all know RS has been wrong before.  It just seems as if anyone mentions clues that may indicate Nick or anyone else is the F1, they quickly get dismissed, however, the clues that Josh is F1 are rock solid.  As, we know Fleiss has outsmarted RS before, and it can happen again.

I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

rosesrREd wrote:


I agree Aunties_Love, we do NOT KNOW.   I realize that Josh is the spoiled F1, but we all know RS has been wrong before.  It just seems as if anyone mentions clues that may indicate Nick or anyone else is the F1, they quickly get dismissed, however, the clues that Josh is F1 are rock solid.  As, we know Fleiss has outsmarted RS before, and it can happen again.

I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

Aunties_Love wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:
I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

Because there is way too much and some of it really iffy.  Way more than with any other season and therefore it makes it unbelievable.

BTW, Josh only came home less than a day after Nick, so therefore, is he really home later????

rosesrREd wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:
I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

I don't dislike Josh, and if he is the F1, then great.  However, I don't understand how many posters can be so "definite" about it.

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

BTW, Josh only came home less than a day after Nick, so therefore, is he really home later????

Well what would you call it?  The same day?  See perfect example , I guess I could have said not on the same flight...

Alanna wrote:The snapchat thing is really nail in the coffin to me. It's confirmed by Josh himself to be his username and he was snap chatting someone named AndiDorfman. Either he has some weird kink about this witch that just broke his heart and it's a game he was playing with a friend or something, or yeah, it was Andi.

Rosepetal wrote: May 12th also is the day Andi resurfaced on twitter and started retweeting things.

Aunties_Love wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:
I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

Because there is way too much and some of it really iffy.  Way more than with any other season and therefore it makes it unbelievable.

BTW, Josh only came home less than a day after Nick, so therefore, is he really home later????