Re: The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #2

[Cecilia]

The thing I wonder about is IF Steve hadn't incorrectly spoiled Brooks early on, would the footage of the show have been so slanted towards her picking him?

I think there was a lot you couldn't hide. I mean, look at her breakdown when he left....the girl was gaga over him.

That still perplexes me....

Brooks was F1 in her mind, but not in his. Since it wasn't mutual it wasn't right. She realized she had been overlooking Chris and he was clearly the better choice. They are totally going to get married IMO. He is not uber jealous after that terrible edit they gave their evolving relationship and that is a good sign.

I want to see the date with Josh to see more about him. He seems like a total meathead. Not sure if they can edit that out.

[KK4]

LOL I chose to skip that one totally. It was the only one I skipped.

It's the only one I didn't watch.

[KK4]

The thing I wonder about is IF Steve hadn't incorrectly spoiled Brooks early on, would the footage of the show have been so slanted towards her picking him?

I think there was a lot you couldn't hide. I mean, look at her breakdown when he left....the girl was gaga over him.

That still perplexes me....

Brooks was F1 in her mind, but not in his.  Since it wasn't mutual it wasn't right.  She realized she had been overlooking Chris and he was clearly the better choice.  They are totally going to get married IMO.  He is not uber jealous after that terrible edit they gave their evolving relationship and that is a good sign.

I want to see the date with Josh to see more about him.  He seems like a total meathead.  Not sure if they can edit that out.

That, and he just reminds me of Jeremy from Deanna's season.

[SLA44]

LOL I chose to skip that one totally. It was the only one I skipped.

It's the only one I didn't watch.

Same here.

[stuckinsc]

The thing I wonder about is IF Steve hadn't incorrectly spoiled Brooks early on, would the footage of the show have been so slanted towards her picking him?

I think there was a lot you couldn't hide. I mean, look at her breakdown when he left....the girl was gaga over him.

That still perplexes me....

Brooks was F1 in her mind, but not in his.  Since it wasn't mutual it wasn't right.  She realized she had been overlooking Chris and he was clearly the better choice.  They are totally going to get married IMO.  He is not uber jealous after that terrible edit they gave their evolving relationship and that is a good sign.

I want to see the date with Josh to see more about him.  He seems like a total meathead.  Not sure if they can edit that out.

Totally agree that Brooks was F1 in her mind, but her body was so comfortable with Chris is was like even her own body was saying, this is the right guy for you, not that one.

I love me some Josh, I can see how some see meathead, I see confident man. But then again, I love his family and think it is very sweet that he went to UGA to be with Aaron and help little brother through that challenging time. I feel like there is a lot more to him than they are showing us on tv.

[Piper61]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh. Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris. She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught. I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some. He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.

[docnash14]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh.  Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris.  She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught.  I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.  

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some.  He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.  

Yes, confident but also willing to be vulnerable (e.g. admitting his nervousness). I also noticed that he was sitting next to Dylan when it was announced that Dylan was getting the next 1-1. Although Josh admittedly was hoping for more time with Andi himself, he seemed genuinely excited for Dylan when he offered his congratulations to him.

[stuckinsc]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh.  Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris.  She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught.  I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.  

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some.  He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.  

Yes, confident but also willing to be vulnerable (e.g. admitting his nervousness).  I also noticed that he was sitting next to Dylan when it was announced that Dylan was getting the next 1-1.  Although Josh admittedly was hoping for more time with Andi himself, he seemed genuinely excited for Dylan when he offered his congratulations to him.

Except for calling out Andrew on getting a girls phone number, which actually reminds me of Chris and Drew with James last season, has Josh been anything but nice to the other guys?  I remember Patrick even agreeing when Patrick pointed out why wasn't this brought up right away and Josh told him he was bringing it up to Andrew as soon as he found out.

He was joking around with them during the basketball game and has seemed to be pretty nice to the others on all the group dates too.  I actually laugh because at this point Jef was calling himself the king of the group date and Josh is like him in that they both went on group dates every week.

[Piper61]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh.  Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris.  She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught.  I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.  

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some.  He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.  

Yes, confident but also willing to be vulnerable (e.g. admitting his nervousness).  I also noticed that he was sitting next to Dylan when it was announced that Dylan was getting the next 1-1.  Although Josh admittedly was hoping for more time with Andi himself, he seemed genuinely excited for Dylan when he offered his congratulations to him.

   I noticed that with Dylan as well.

[docnash14]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh.  Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris.  She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught.  I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.  

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some.  He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.  

Yes, confident but also willing to be vulnerable (e.g. admitting his nervousness).  I also noticed that he was sitting next to Dylan when it was announced that Dylan was getting the next 1-1.  Although Josh admittedly was hoping for more time with Andi himself, he seemed genuinely excited for Dylan when he offered his congratulations to him.

Except for calling out Andrew on getting a girls phone number, which actually reminds me of Chris and Drew with James last season, has Josh been anything but nice to the other guys?  I remember Patrick even agreeing when Patrick pointed out why wasn't this brought up right away and Josh told him he was bringing it up to Andrew as soon as he found out.

He was joking around with them during the basketball game and has seemed to be pretty nice to the others on all the group dates too.  I actually laugh because at this point Jef was calling himself the king of the group date and Josh is like him in that they both went on group dates every week.

Actually, I was thinking about that. One of the benefits of not getting a 1-1 early on is that it increases the likelihood of spending at least some time with Andi every week - in contrast to guys like Chris, JJ and Dylan who sat one week out and had only the cocktail party before the RC to interact with Andi.

[Piper61]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh.  Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris.  She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught.  I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.  

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some.  He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.  

Yes, confident but also willing to be vulnerable (e.g. admitting his nervousness).  I also noticed that he was sitting next to Dylan when it was announced that Dylan was getting the next 1-1.  Although Josh admittedly was hoping for more time with Andi himself, he seemed genuinely excited for Dylan when he offered his congratulations to him.

Except for calling out Andrew on getting a girls phone number, which actually reminds me of Chris and Drew with James last season, has Josh been anything but nice to the other guys?  I remember Patrick even agreeing when Patrick pointed out why wasn't this brought up right away and Josh told him he was bringing it up to Andrew as soon as he found out.

He was joking around with them during the basketball game and has seemed to be pretty nice to the others on all the group dates too.  I actually laugh because at this point Jef was calling himself the king of the group date and Josh is like him in that they both went on group dates every week.

Nope, I think he has been nice. And even with Andrew upon initial discussion, he was wanting to give Andrew the chance to talk about it from his own perspective.

[docnash14]

^^^I totally agree as well on both Brooks and Josh.  Brooks made it easy on Des by leaving before getting to a final 2 between him and Chris.  She was wrecked when he left, but she went forward and didn't let everything be for naught.  I am very glad to see how truly happy the are together.  

I don't think Josh is a meathead either, but then again, I am not totally sure what that means for some.  He is confident but it seems he's worked hard for his accomplishments and growing up in that loving, supporting family has to be the root cause of his confidence.  

Yes, confident but also willing to be vulnerable (e.g. admitting his nervousness).  I also noticed that he was sitting next to Dylan when it was announced that Dylan was getting the next 1-1.  Although Josh admittedly was hoping for more time with Andi himself, he seemed genuinely excited for Dylan when he offered his congratulations to him.

Except for calling out Andrew on getting a girls phone number, which actually reminds me of Chris and Drew with James last season, has Josh been anything but nice to the other guys?  I remember Patrick even agreeing when Patrick pointed out why wasn't this brought up right away and Josh told him he was bringing it up to Andrew as soon as he found out.


He was joking around with them during the basketball game and has seemed to be pretty nice to the others on all the group dates too.  I actually laugh because at this point Jef was calling himself the king of the group date and Josh is like him in that they both went on group dates every week.

Nope, I think he has been nice.  And even with Andrew upon initial discussion, he was wanting to give Andrew the chance to talk about it from his own perspective.  

And, as I mentioned elsewhere, apparently it's all good between them now as Andrew is following Josh. As you probably noticed, Josh is following very few people affiliated with the show, although he is following JJ and Nick S.

[Sponsored content]