Re: The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #2

[thirteen]

June 11 is when the lady tweeted Josh was on her flight to Cancun.  June 14 is when Andi tweeted the OFF spray can.  June 16 is when the picture was tweeted of Josh at the airport seated in Johnny Rockets.

Nick posted an instagram photo on June 13th saying he was back in town.  Not sure about Chris  

Another poster, momoftrips, verified that Nick was sighted on SM until June 8, so it's reasonable to assume he was out of town 6/8-6/13 (or 6/12).
Nick also wears a black bracelet which first showed up on that infamous plane video, and now appears in every single one of his IG/tweeter pictures. Some of us speculated it's possibly from DR.  If so, why does he wear it now if he got his heart broken in DR?
Hmmm, so my wild guess for today is, KASHA, I support your theory : Andi is dating both of them!! She's with Nick 6/8-6/12, with Josh 6/12- 6/16. She gave Josh the yellow bracelet in Brussels, the black one to Nick in DR. (Since we are all speculating, why not?)

I really don't think she is dating both. Why? Because they both (Nick and Josh) had said that they dislike seeing her with other men. Why will you put up with that after the show? I'm 99% sure that neither Josh or Nick will follow through with it even if that is the only way to be with her. JMO

[jcrbil]

Nick posted an instagram photo on June 13th saying he was back in town.  Not sure about Chris  

Another poster, momoftrips, verified that Nick was sighted on SM until June 8, so it's reasonable to assume he was out of town 6/8-6/13 (or 6/12).
Nick also wears a black bracelet which first showed up on that infamous plane video, and now appears in every single one of his IG/tweeter pictures. Some of us speculated it's possibly from DR.  If so, why does he wear it now if he got his heart broken in DR?
Hmmm, so my wild guess for today is, KASHA, I support your theory : Andi is dating both of them!! She's with Nick 6/8-6/12, with Josh 6/12- 6/16. She gave Josh the yellow bracelet in Brussels, the black one to Nick in DR. (Since we are all speculating, why not?)

I really don't think she is dating both. Why? Because they both (Nick and Josh) had said that they dislike seeing her with other men. Why will you put up with that after the show? I'm 99% sure that neither Josh or Nick will follow through with it even if that is the only way to be with her. JMO

I agree that she's not dating both. They would both have said no thank you, IMO.

[sdmom]

Back in 2005, Bachelor 5, Charlie O'Connell chose to date 2 women in real life before making his decision on a live FRC. I actually like the idea, because it will give them some time in real life, without camera around, no fancy dates but doing normal stuff. I remember the f2 said she was not "blindsided" because Charlie just called her less and less. Charlie didn't propose, even he and Sarah B eventually broke up, but they were together for a few years. I consider them one of the more successful couples from the franchise.
Anyway, I was just throwing out an idea. Nothing serious.

[stuckinsc]

Charlie's was one of my favorite seasons. He refused too many fancy dates and rose ceremonies. He wanted to do things that he would do with the women in real life and for them to show him the real person they were. Charlie also specifically said in advance he wasn't having sex with any of the women in the FS, since to him it wasn't a good idea.

I thought he would be a complete knucklehead and ended up loving him. I thought I would love Travis the doctor and he bored me to tears. One of the reasons I always try to give the season a try.

I wish more would try to date both of the F2, but I don't think TPTB would allow that again, just like they wanted to tar and feather JPG for not proposing or giving them at least an ILY. You have to play the game.

[atem]

I couldn't stand Charlie and didn't bother watching his season.

[stuckinsc]

I couldn't stand Charlie and didn't bother watching his season.

Atem, I didn't expect to like him and was so pleasantly surprised. You might not like it, but it was much better than I expected.

[atem]

I couldn't stand Charlie and didn't bother watching his season.

Atem, I didn't expect to like him and was so pleasantly surprised.  You might not like it, but it was much better than I expected.

He didn't date both women.  He dated one and strung the other along until the ATFR to dump her on 'live' tv.

Most of the leads suck on this show.  That's why the show focuses on the fake drama created from the Nicks and Courtneys of the world.

[nutty1]

I loved Charlie's season. It was so entertaining!! And he and Sarah dated for years.

[docnash14]

^ Yes, they can take place during the week, but there were pictures and tweets that proved Andi was in Atlanta during the week too.

Just because some people might want to see this - So, Josh posted a picture to his Instagram less than two hours ago from a golf tournament (it might have been the one from last weekend/monday?) and I guess while he was there Eric Decker and Jessie James Decker were also there. Andi is a huge Jessie James Decker fan and Jessie even sent out a tweet recently that said "Isn't Andi Dorfman gorgeous?" and Andi responded to her. It's only been a couple of hours since Josh posted the instagram picture and now Andi is following Eric Decker on Twitter too now as she just started following him within the past couple of hours. Josh started following them on Twitter last night and Eric Decker now follows Josh too.

Could be nothing, but the timing was funny and I figured I'd post that here.

Ash, Josh actually started following the Deckers on twitter the first of the week - either Sunday or Monday can't recall which. I think you are right that the IG photo was from an earlier date possibly Sunday or Monday as he included #tbt in his description of the picture.

[Aunties_Love]

I think the difference is that Josh flew to where the crew of TB was.  Brooks went on a cruise by himself.

I can't see Josh being a contestant on BIP.  What the audience will see is Josh getting his heart broken one week and the next week he's single and ready to mingle.  It negates the claim that people actually fall in love on the show.   For me there are only 2 options as to why Josh was there, A safe house visit or he's the next Bachelor.  If he's the next Bachelor he really needs to cut the yellow bracelet off.  

But at the same time as the BIP was filming??  I believe he had that yellow one before filming.

The yellow braided bracelet showed up in the middle of Josh and Andi's 1-1 in Brussels. As of 2 days ago he still had it on.

I could of sworn that I saw a cap here somewhere that was PRE bachelorette filming time of him wearing a yellow band.  Now to see if I can find it for sure...maybe even on his facebook it was.


ETA:

I thought I saw one.

Here's the yellow band on his arm from Oct. 8/12 picture on his facebook.




https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10101312408150391&set=pb.5034512.-2207520000.1404452263.&type=3&theater

[Aunties_Love]

Well everything is speculation until the finale, but it is fun to speculate.

Speculation is fun and part of the process, I think when you aren't convinced of the spoilers and others are and those who are convinced state things as fact, when the are just speculation it causes those who aren't convinced to cringe.  

I know the posts that we know they watched the world cup game together were like that for me.  It is possible, but since 70% of the people I knew watched that game and commented about it on FB and many were in different states making almost the same comments at almost the same time, I am not convinced for fact that they watched the game together.  The probably did, and if people said they probably did it wouldn't annoy me, but when I am told for fact they did.  It gets old.  

RichLP was a member here during Emily's season and that was his pet peeve, he hated people stating speculation as fact.

I agree with you struck...when thoughts or opinion grow legs and become fact, it does get old. IMO, there is no definitive proof Josh is F1 other than RS's word and regarding to what he says about Josh being in Cancun, IMO, he's only telling us what his source told him....If one was to look at it that way, then the resounding question would be who is RS's source and is that source on Fleiss's payroll, hence he could be telling RS that mars is blue and venus is red for all we know...

[Aunties_Love]

 I haven't kept up with him but he is only recently active, right?

Chris has been posting pretty regularly on twitter since June 8th.  He didn't post anything from June 9th to June 12th. The only time I can tell he was out of town was when he went to Chicago with family and visited Nick on June 22nd.

He was also inactive on twitter from the 13-16th.

[Sponsored content]