The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers Thread #2

[GuardianAngel]

Continue Final 1 Final 2 speculation here.

[nutty1]

I just went back and listened/watched the videos from RS of Nick on the plane.
I havent listened to them since he released them. After watching 4 episodes now, I am more convinced than ever that Nick is definitely the F2, and Josh the F1. If that was a set up, Nick is a dang good actor. What he was saying about Josh fits what I have seen so far (temper, competitive). I think they were real. How the person recognized him is still amazing to me, but I do believe the videos are the real deal. Also, if Nick were F1, he wouldn't have been returning home that early.

[Alanna]

I just went back and listened/watched the videos from RS of Nick on the plane.
I havent listened to them since he released them. After watching 4 episodes now, I am more convinced than ever that Nick is definitely the F2, and Josh the F1. If that was a set up, Nick is a dang good actor. What he was saying about Josh fits what I have seen so far (temper, competitive). I think they were real. How the person recognized him is still amazing to me, but I do believe the videos are the real deal. Also, if Nick were F1, he wouldn't have been returning home that early.

ITA! Is this a first for us, girl?? We've only been watching this together for like 8 years        

[nutty1]

:Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo:

PS….I have become a huge JP and Ashely fan!!

[Alanna]

:Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo: :Woah-hoo:

PS….I have become a huge JP and Ashely fan!!

Cupcakes for all!!!

Apologies, back to your regularly scheduled Meeeeendi talk now.

[Aunties_Love]

I just went back and listened/watched the videos from RS of Nick on the plane.
I havent listened to them since he released them. After watching 4 episodes now, I am more convinced than ever that Nick is definitely the F2, and Josh the F1. If that was a set up, Nick is a dang good actor. What he was saying about Josh fits what I have seen so far (temper, competitive). I think they were real. How the person recognized him is still amazing to me, but I do believe the videos are the real deal. Also, if Nick were F1, he wouldn't have been returning home that early.

Okay, I know my wild speculation game is back at it, but what IF Nick was F2, Josh was F3 and HE came back and interrupted Andi/Nick on a LCD. Wouldn't that be enough for Nick to be bitter with Josh??

Again, I know...wild speculation, but for some reason that video is still giving me major red flags so trying to figure out how it all fits.

[nutty1]

Yep, wild speculation!   

[Aunties_Love]

Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen? I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video. Thanks for your input.

[Piper61]

Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen?  I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video.  Thanks for your input.

I think one point made with regard to the video was the date/timing of it.  If Nick is F1, he supposedly wouldn't be on the final leg plane ride home but rather still on location with Andi on that date.

[nutty1]

Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen?  I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video.  Thanks for your input.

First, I don't think Chris is the F1 guy. He's not being shown enough, IMO.
Also, I do think Josh wouldn't have been the main subject if he was F3. I think Nick sounded like a guy who just got dumped and was feeling that initial sting and of course, a bit of animosity toward the F1 guy, Josh.

[Retiredswimmom]

Yep, wild speculation!   

So from your perspective that just couldn't happen?  I ask as I am wondering what I am missing with that video.  Thanks for your input.

First, I don't think Chris is the F1 guy. He's not being shown enough, IMO.
Also, I do think Josh wouldn't have been the main subject if he was F3. I think Nick sounded like a guy who just got dumped and was feeling that initial sting and of course, a bit of animosity toward the F1 guy, Josh.

You're right, the timing was wrong. He would have stayed a few days with Andi on location after the filming was done. And for it to be a fake video, we have to ask 2 questions: What would he gain by agreeing to do it? Just to prove that RS was wrong? Would he put his integrity on the line for MF?

[nutty1]

And if Josh was not the F1, I'd imagine they'd want him as the next Bachelor, and would they really have Nick trash talk him on a video they were going to release?

[Sponsored content]