Episode 9 -- Fantasy Dates -- airs TUESDAY February 25

stuckinsc wrote:I think the show kind of rebooted with DeAnna's season, so I will just go back that far. DeAnna wanted Graham, I don't think there was any other deep connection on her season. Jesse might have been the physical.
Jason, I didn't watch until the end, but Melissa seemed physical and Molly was definitely more emotional.
Jillian went with her physical for F1 as I found Reid to be her emotional connection.
Jake, I am not sure he likes women, so yeah, who knows.
Ali has said it was Frank who really would be her F1, so Roberto was most likely the physical F2.
Brad was pretty much all in for Emily from day one, I thought that Ashley was actually his F2 if their FD hadn't gone off the rails so badly. Chantal was the physical F2/3.
Ashley for me from the episode 3 date was JP to me. So there was no real difference JP was both physical and emotional.
Ben again it was all Courtney, so it again no emotional or physical just her and the filler.
Emily is one where I think her emotions for Jef won out over the physical Arie.
Sean was dazzled by Tierra, and Cat was so hidden it is hard to call others. AshLee or Des could have been emotional at first.
Des was emotional with Chris and physical with Brooks, and since I believe she would have chosen Brooks if he hadn't left. In the long run it was best that she end up with Chris.
This season I see Clare as the physical and Nikki as emotional and Sharleen as what would have been impossible to get F1.
I really don't care who JPG choses, I like Nikki as a person and would smack Clare upside the head, but if JPG chooses Clare, it won't matter to me.

pbmax wrote:

stuckinsc wrote:I think the show kind of rebooted with DeAnna's season, so I will just go back that far.  DeAnna wanted Graham, I don't think there was any other deep connection on her season.  Jesse might have been the physical.
Jason, I didn't watch until the end, but Melissa seemed physical and Molly was definitely more emotional.
Jillian went with her physical for F1 as I found Reid to be her emotional connection.
Jake, I am not sure he likes women, so yeah, who knows.  
Ali has said it was Frank who really would be her F1, so Roberto was most likely the physical F2.
Brad was pretty much all in for Emily from day one, I thought that Ashley was actually his F2 if their FD hadn't gone off the rails so badly.  Chantal was the physical F2/3.
Ashley for me from the episode 3 date was JP to me.  So there was no real difference JP was both physical and emotional.
Ben again it was all Courtney, so it again no emotional or physical just her and the filler.
Emily is one where I think her emotions for Jef won out over the physical Arie.
Sean was dazzled by Tierra, and Cat was so hidden it is hard to call others.  AshLee or Des could have been emotional at first.  
Des was emotional with Chris and physical with Brooks, and since I believe she would have chosen Brooks if he hadn't left.  In the long run it was best that she end up with Chris.
This season I see Clare as the physical and Nikki as emotional and Sharleen as what would have been impossible to get F1.
I really don't care who JPG choses, I like Nikki as a person and would smack Clare upside the head, but if JPG chooses Clare, it won't matter to me.

I agree except for a few things.
I think it was Melissa all the way but after it was all done Jason realize Melissa wasn't really into him and saw he had chose the wrong one.
Jillian wanted Wes but he was chosen to be the villian and not the F1
JP became her total focus after she saw nothing was going to happen with Bently.
I don't know what line Ali is shooting now but I know right after the show finish taping, Ali was to giddy, on cloud nine. That didn't come from Frank.
Emily wanted Arie, it changed after the HTD when she saw a taste of Jef life.
Even though they didn't show us all Sean and Catherine connection, I could see he was different with her.

Sprite wrote:

pbmax wrote:

stuckinsc wrote:I think the show kind of rebooted with DeAnna's season, so I will just go back that far.  DeAnna wanted Graham, I don't think there was any other deep connection on her season.  Jesse might have been the physical.
Jason, I didn't watch until the end, but Melissa seemed physical and Molly was definitely more emotional.
Jillian went with her physical for F1 as I found Reid to be her emotional connection.
Jake, I am not sure he likes women, so yeah, who knows.  
Ali has said it was Frank who really would be her F1, so Roberto was most likely the physical F2.
Brad was pretty much all in for Emily from day one, I thought that Ashley was actually his F2 if their FD hadn't gone off the rails so badly.  Chantal was the physical F2/3.
Ashley for me from the episode 3 date was JP to me.  So there was no real difference JP was both physical and emotional.
Ben again it was all Courtney, so it again no emotional or physical just her and the filler.
Emily is one where I think her emotions for Jef won out over the physical Arie.
Sean was dazzled by Tierra, and Cat was so hidden it is hard to call others.  AshLee or Des could have been emotional at first.  
Des was emotional with Chris and physical with Brooks, and since I believe she would have chosen Brooks if he hadn't left.  In the long run it was best that she end up with Chris.
This season I see Clare as the physical and Nikki as emotional and Sharleen as what would have been impossible to get F1.
I really don't care who JPG choses, I like Nikki as a person and would smack Clare upside the head, but if JPG chooses Clare, it won't matter to me.

I agree except for a few things.
I think it was Melissa all the way but after it was all done Jason realize Melissa wasn't really into him and saw he had chose the wrong one.
Jillian wanted Wes but he was chosen to be the villian and not the F1
JP became her total focus after she saw nothing was going to happen with Bently.
I don't know what line Ali is shooting now but I know right after the show finish taping, Ali was to giddy, on cloud nine. That didn't come from Frank.
Emily wanted Arie, it changed after the HTD when she saw a taste of Jef life.
Even though they didn't show us all Sean and Catherine connection, I could see he was different with her.

Sorry, but I don't buy the highlighted. Ed was who Jillian wanted and that is who she got...for better or worse. If I remember correctly, there was talk over how inconsolable she was after he left and they had to do something...hence he came back.

I'm also not so sure about the Bentley thing. As much crying as there was over him, Ashley was warned in advance and I never quite bought that she was as into him as was made out. I think the crying with him was spurred on by her insecurity of the guys wanting Emily instead of her...something William didn't help either.

Everything else, I think you are spot on. Ali seems to have wanted to get back at Roberto after the break up for whatever reason. Bitter Nellie. Cat and Sean...seriously, man couldn't stand to touch AshLee or Lindsey by the end. Hands at his sides on the last dates...I was killing myself laughing as people were still going on about how much he was into them. And Emily...the most excited I saw her was when she saw the family ranch in Utah. Yah, she was all over that.

This season I see JPab physically into Sharleen, Clare and Nikki. He can't talk to Sharleen and she took herself out. That basically leaves the other two. I would really be curious to know if he would have taken her to the end if she had stayed. Of Clare and Nikki...it's a toss up. He seems much more physical with Clare (and I think he is a very physical guy), but he seems to be into Nikki as well...I just don't buy that she is as into him. Don't care who he ends up with since I doubt either will last.

pbmax wrote:I respect your opinion. But I will go down in history, that it was Wes that Jillian wanted . She seem prefectly fine after Ed left, sure she did a little tears cause of of insecurity about herself...nothing like DeAnna and Desiree not even Ali. Afterward she was fine and dandy. It was so telling how she felt about Wes on his HTD.

Jason wanted Melissa
Jillian wanted Wes
Ashley wanted Bently at first
Ali picked who she wanted
Emily wanted Arie
Desriee wanted Brooks
And Andrew wanted Kirsten
That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Words are cheat, people lie like the wind blow, but their actions tell it.

soccermom333 wrote:

pbmax wrote:I respect your opinion. But I will go down in history, that it was Wes that Jillian wanted . She seem prefectly fine after Ed left, sure she did a little tears cause of of insecurity about herself...nothing like DeAnna and Desiree not even Ali. Afterward she was fine and dandy. It was so telling how she felt about Wes on his HTD.

Jason wanted Melissa
Jillian wanted Wes
Ashley wanted Bently at first
Ali picked who she wanted
Emily wanted Arie
Desriee wanted Brooks
And Andrew wanted Kirsten
That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Words are cheat, people lie like the wind blow, but their actions tell it.

I respect your opinion, but as far as Jillian goes, she wanted Ed and even Wes knew it.  You can PM me for more details and a more in depth conversation if you want.

Umngirl and Litta, I might need your help on this.  ;)

umngirl wrote:

soccermom333 wrote:

pbmax wrote:I respect your opinion. But I will go down in history, that it was Wes that Jillian wanted . She seem prefectly fine after Ed left, sure she did a little tears cause of of insecurity about herself...nothing like DeAnna and Desiree not even Ali. Afterward she was fine and dandy. It was so telling how she felt about Wes on his HTD.

Jason wanted Melissa
Jillian wanted Wes
Ashley wanted Bently at first
Ali picked who she wanted
Emily wanted Arie
Desriee wanted Brooks
And Andrew wanted Kirsten
That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Words are cheat, people lie like the wind blow, but their actions tell it.

I respect your opinion, but as far as Jillian goes, she wanted Ed and even Wes knew it.  You can PM me for more details and a more in depth conversation if you want.

Umngirl and Litta, I might need your help on this.  ;)

I'll totally back you on this. Jillian wanted Ed no matter what, bar none. Wes was more of a fun buddy than a true romantic interest. Their last date should be clear evidence of that.

pbmax wrote:I respect your opinion. But I will go down in history, that it was Wes that Jillian wanted . She seem prefectly fine after Ed left, sure she did a little tears cause of of insecurity about herself...nothing like DeAnna and Desiree not even Ali. Afterward she was fine and dandy. It was so telling how she felt about Wes on his HTD.

Jason wanted Melissa
Jillian wanted Wes
Ashley wanted Bently at first
Ali picked who she wanted
Emily wanted Arie
Desriee wanted Brooks
And Andrew wanted Kirsten
That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Words are cheat, people lie like the wind blow, but their actions tell it.

b wrote:

umngirl wrote:

soccermom333 wrote:

pbmax wrote:I respect your opinion. But I will go down in history, that it was Wes that Jillian wanted . She seem prefectly fine after Ed left, sure she did a little tears cause of of insecurity about herself...nothing like DeAnna and Desiree not even Ali. Afterward she was fine and dandy. It was so telling how she felt about Wes on his HTD.

Jason wanted Melissa
Jillian wanted Wes
Ashley wanted Bently at first
Ali picked who she wanted
Emily wanted Arie
Desriee wanted Brooks
And Andrew wanted Kirsten
That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Words are cheat, people lie like the wind blow, but their actions tell it.

I respect your opinion, but as far as Jillian goes, she wanted Ed and even Wes knew it.  You can PM me for more details and a more in depth conversation if you want.

Umngirl and Litta, I might need your help on this.  ;)

I'll totally back you on this. Jillian wanted Ed no matter what, bar none. Wes was more of a fun buddy than a true romantic interest. Their last date should be clear evidence of that.

I agree Jillian wanted Ed!  I think she was infatuated with Wes, but b/c he was a (tall/dark) country singer (she had said growing up that was her fantasy....if I rem correctly).  If he had reciprocated, he may have been some competition for Ed though.  I so liked Ed until the suite in Spain, when I realized he was not as into her as she was him....and as much as I liked Reid and his neuroses, it was Ed all the way!

Chris Harrison ‏@chrisbharrison  49m
Tonight at 11:35PM ET/PT, @JimmyKimmelLive will feature an exclusive sneak peek from Tuesday night’s fantasy suite date turned nightmare!