Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion - #3

I feel bad for the girls. How confused are they going to be when they were already told josh is leaving (forever?) and then he'll magically be back? Ugh.

I believe Amanda may have traveled for Sabel's memorial ceremony. I'm sure Sabel has been a big part of Amanda's family to warrant the attention given. There are two possibilities that we can speculate on (IMHO):

1) They have reconciled, again. And we know it doesn't take much for this relationship to move to Splitsville again, especially now that they will rack up miles. This will mean that this thread will be active for a little while longer.

2) They are spending time with each other as friends (with benefits or otherwise) and will announce their split on Monday.

Either way, I think it will end the same - we just need to be patient.

(Note: I'm NOT a fan of either one, my knowledge of their relationship is limited to what I read on the board - so these thoughts are really JMO. I've always been partial to Nick so that pretty much sums up my interest in anything Josh)

If they include Duh and BOR in couples update special, it will have to be done live.  Always the risk right up to the moment of airtime that DUH will be disrespectful, like expressing a preference as to what shoes she wants to wear or daring to acknowledge some male they randomly run into when out and about.  Or just daring to talk at all without prior permission

They already filmed something a couple weeks ago, but that can easily be scrapped.  

Many here have been posting about and hoping for a live break up announcement/interview like Jake and Vienna and anticipating that it would be more dramatic and entertaining.  

Pathetic.

Okay.  Have to put my 2 cents in.

This does not surprise me at all.   Amanda has been doing IG stories of the girls and in one IG story literally telling one of them what to say or what kind of face to make.  She again, is using these girls to get what she wants.  What is it her ex said?  She's needy, when he went to work she would call him 10 times a day.  I don't believe she can handle being alone without a boyfriend/significant other/fiancé.  I just have a gut feeling about this so this is all just my opinion but I don't believe that she was crazy about Sabel like the other ex was.  Of course, she must feel bad that he is gone and that Josh is so sad, as we all do, but I believe it ends there.  She is again, in my opinion using Josh's vulnerability right now to get back in his favor.

What surprises me is that Josh is usually not one for letting things go such as when she met her ex for lunch and told him all the things about Josh that she couldn't stand, about the fact that Sabel shed, she had to have a house cleaner.  He scolded her for being on her phone and not watching his brother's playing football game.  Also said she was mad because Josh cancelled an event that she was to appear at where Nick was involved.  Said she called Nick but lied to Josh and told him she didn't.  I know these sites are not always accurate but just by what was in the article in my opinion the ex would not have known unless she  said these things to him.    

And since this break up she has actually said that it wasn't just the incident at the Jingle Ball and that he did not pay anything toward the house expenses.  So she made that all public but Josh seems to be okay with it.  I didn't hear but the live IG or whatever they call it but heard that she said her and Josh were broken up and she wouldn't say they won't go back together but just not now.  So that was just a couple days ago, I believe.

I believe that Guardian Angel also put on here a post about some article online that stated that Josh insists they are not broken up and they are happy.

So again, not surprised at this but surprised that Josh cannot see through her very manipulative ways.  He must have invited her to Atlanta so he must want her there.  So I believe he still is in love with her and wants her back.  I don't see it, but what do I know.  I just hope that he thinks all this through before driving all the way back to LA again.

Sorry to be so snarky but here she is in the picture with an armful of clothes, like she doesn't have enough clothes.  But she believes she's a big celebrity now and has to have a celebrity's wardrobe.   JMO

IMO this isn't a relationship that can end in a friendship. Amanda herself said that there were multiple reasons for the split. Why would you stay friends with someone who has no respect for you?

And IMO Amanda deserves to get called out. She's as manipulative as they get. She uses her kids to gain sympathy and attention, and uses them as tools against her ex and yes Josh. She also uses her bach friends to back her up when she wants to 'win:. According to her side, Josh is controlling, manipulative and has issues flying off the handle. This is the woman who trashed her ex on bachelor, went to him to trash about Josh, when that backfired, she had her family trash the same ex on sm, openly said how she wanted to change the kds last names etc. She's as manipulative as Josh IMO. Josh is more agressive and volatile, but Amanda uses her kids. Both are dangerous ways to play with people. All this is only MO.

Laura Walsh wrote:Okay.  Have to put my 2 cents in.
snipped..

Also said she was mad because Josh cancelled an event that she was to appear at where Nick was involved.  Said she called Nick but lied to Josh and told him she didn't.  snipped   JMO

Now that you mention it, the last time I saw an ad for that event, her picture was not on it, like it was on the first one we saw that was posted here. I just figured there were too many pictures to put on the ad. I wonder if she cancelled. When that ad was first posted, and her picture was on it, I commented that that should be good for another breakup for the cuzilionth time.

Sorry for the double post but I went looking. It looks like Amanda cancelled her involvement with Sarah's charity. When I look through Sarah's original post, the link is broken. So did Amanda cancel her appearance becasue she "disrespected" Josh, and now everything is Happy Happy Happy again?

This is her latest post. She has Amanda's name on the bottom but no pic like I'm sure there was on the first ad.

https://twitter.com/sarahherron


On January 2nd, Ben & Lauren, Becca & Robert, Carly & Evan, Amanda, Ashley I., Sarah, Jared, Chase, Robby, Wells, James Taylor, Lace, Jade, Emily & Haley will be celebrating the season premier with...

This was originally posted Dec 13th. but that link no longer works, and same with Sarah's twitter.
https://www.bachandbachettefans.net/t3862p516-josh-murray-amanda-stanton-bip-3-discussion-2

hae1001 wrote:I just saw on Instagram Sarah Herron Is hosting a viewing party during the premier to raise money for her charity shelift. Amanda is listed as one of the many bachelor alum but Josh isn't. I wonder how Amanda got permission to support anything Nick related? Instagram Post

@GuardianAngel im not sure if you mean a different photo or are overlooking Amanda in that photo. If the latter, she is the last person in the second row making the kissy face.

Isn't that Amanda in the right column second row from the top?

Amanda is the girl in the second column with the sunglasses on.