Re: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Fan Forum - General Discussion Thread #3

by eliza3 Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:06 pm

Andi may have gone to the lake house. That's where I would go if I was her -- a private place to reflect

by AnandaMarie Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:10 pm

eliza3 wrote:Andi may have gone to the lake house. That's where I would go if I was her -- a private place to reflect

Probably. I think she's really hurt too. They loved each other but made mistakes. Hopefully they can fix the mistakes and make it work because love like that is special.

by Maggenzm Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:34 pm

AnandaMarie wrote:
eliza3 wrote:Andi may have gone to the lake house. That's where I would go if I was her -- a private place to reflect

Probably. I think she's really hurt too. They loved each other but made mistakes. Hopefully they can fix the mistakes and make it work because love like that is special.

ITA, I believe Andi is really devastated and inconsolable. Remember how heart broken she was when she left JPG, she was wondering if she would ever find someone. So, can you imagine, how she must feel for losing her great love, especially if he is the one who broke it of?

IMO, MM was too quick to declare their break up publicly, I find it very strange. She should have waited. I hope she doesn't eat her words, bcs Andi might not be ready to give up Josh yet, and might want to fight for the relationship.You never know...

by Alanna Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:44 pm

Maggenzm wrote:
AnandaMarie wrote:
eliza3 wrote:Andi may have gone to the lake house. That's where I would go if I was her -- a private place to reflect

Probably. I think she's really hurt too. They loved each other but made mistakes. Hopefully they can fix the mistakes and make it work because love like that is special.

ITA, I believe Andi is really devastated and inconsolable. Remember how heart broken she was when she left JPG, she was wondering if she would ever find someone. So, can you imagine, how she must feel for losing her great love, especially if he is the one who broke it of?

IMO, MM was too quick to declare their break up publicly, I find it very strange. She should have waited. I hope she doesn't eat her words, bcs Andi might not be ready to give up Josh yet, and might want to fight for the relationship.You never know...

I believe mm called the breakup "wise," sounds like she 100% supports it. JMO.

by nannymargie Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:50 pm

Alanna wrote:
Maggenzm wrote:
AnandaMarie wrote:

Probably. I think she's really hurt too. They loved each other but made mistakes. Hopefully they can fix the mistakes and make it work because love like that is special.

ITA, I believe Andi is really devastated and inconsolable. Remember how heart broken she was when she left JPG, she was wondering if she would ever find someone. So, can you imagine, how she must feel for losing her great love, especially if he is the one who broke it of?

IMO, MM was too quick to declare their break up publicly, I find it very strange. She should have waited. I hope she doesn't eat her words, bcs Andi might not be ready to give up Josh yet, and might want to fight for the relationship.You never know...
I believe mm called the breakup "wise," sounds like she 100% supports it. JMO.

Yes, and most of us know why. I think Andi should fight for this relationship if she truly loves Josh. Remember LOVE IS WAR AND WORTH FIGHTING FOR.

by aviej Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:51 pm

Maggenzm wrote:
AnandaMarie wrote:
eliza3 wrote:Andi may have gone to the lake house. That's where I would go if I was her -- a private place to reflect

Probably. I think she's really hurt too. They loved each other but made mistakes. Hopefully they can fix the mistakes and make it work because love like that is special.

ITA, I believe Andi is really devastated and inconsolable. Remember how heart broken she was when she left JPG, she was wondering if she would ever find someone. So, can you imagine, how she must feel for losing her great love, especially if he is the one who broke it of?

IMO, MM was too quick to declare their break up publicly, I find it very strange. She should have waited. I hope she doesn't eat her words, bcs Andi might not be ready to give up Josh yet, and might want to fight for the relationship.You never know...

Exactly. I think she may be overestimating the power of her influence and underestimating the power of Andi. I happen to think that also Josh seems pissed right now, he is still absolutely goo-goo ga ga over her. And he wants desperately to have his ever after with her - just all the ducks have to be in a row

by Alanna Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:52 pm

nannymargie wrote:
Alanna wrote:
Maggenzm wrote:

ITA, I believe Andi is really devastated and inconsolable. Remember how heart broken she was when she left JPG, she was wondering if she would ever find someone. So, can you imagine, how she must feel for losing her great love, especially if he is the one who broke it of?

IMO, MM was too quick to declare their break up publicly, I find it very strange. She should have waited. I hope she doesn't eat her words, bcs Andi might not be ready to give up Josh yet, and might want to fight for the relationship.You never know...
I believe mm called the breakup "wise," sounds like she 100% supports it. JMO.

Yes, and most of us know why. I think Andi should fight for this relationship if she truly loves Josh. Remember LOVE IS WAR AND WORTH FIGHTING FOR.

I think you misunderstood me, it sounds like mm supports the breakup. It's jmo.

by Jolena Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:52 pm

[quote="AnandaMarie"]Sorry but I disagree with everyone who thinks that Josh should be the bachelor. I still feel that he and Andi were perfect together and I hope they get back together.[/quote

I thought they were perfect together too but apparently they don't think they are. I would love if they could work out there differences and reconcile but if they can't and Josh is still single by the time they are casting for next bachelor then I would love to see have first dibs as the lead for all the reasons that I stated in my earlier post.

by AnandaMarie Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:53 pm

Maggenzm wrote:
AnandaMarie wrote:
eliza3 wrote:Andi may have gone to the lake house. That's where I would go if I was her -- a private place to reflect

Probably. I think she's really hurt too. They loved each other but made mistakes. Hopefully they can fix the mistakes and make it work because love like that is special.

ITA, I believe Andi is really devastated and inconsolable. Remember how heart broken she was when she left JPG, she was wondering if she would ever find someone. So, can you imagine, how she must feel for losing her great love, especially if he is the one who broke it of?

IMO, MM was too quick to declare their break up publicly, I find it very strange. She should have waited. I hope she doesn't eat her words, bcs Andi might not be ready to give up Josh yet, and might want to fight for the relationship.You never know...

Yes, I think she should have waited too, but since Andi and Josh are so quiet maybe she just wanted to confirm instead of leaving fans wondering and asking questions. Alanna, whether MM approves or not, i think she's a good parent and will do what's best for her child and i think that of Josh and Andi get back together, she would hopefully support them.
And i think both Andi and Josh are extremely heartbroken right now. I hope they realize how much they miss and love each other and get back together.

by AnandaMarie Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:55 pm

Jolena wrote:
AnandaMarie wrote:Sorry but I disagree with everyone who thinks that Josh should be the bachelor. I still feel that he and Andi were perfect together and I hope they get back together.[/quote

I thought they were perfect together too but apparently they don't think they are. I would love if they could work out there differences and reconcile but if they can't and Josh is still single by the time they are casting for next bachelor then I would love to see have first dibs as the lead for all the reasons that I stated in my earlier post.

I feel that they are perfect together and I don't necessarily think that they don't feel they are. They both seem to be very hurt right now and I think it's because they still love each other. They made mistakes obviously but i hope that they can fix those mistakes and get back together.

by nannymargie Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:55 pm

Alanna wrote:
nannymargie wrote:
Alanna wrote:
I believe mm called the breakup "wise," sounds like she 100% supports it. JMO.

Yes, and most of us know why. I think Andi should fight for this relationship if she truly loves Josh. Remember LOVE IS WAR AND WORTH FIGHTING FOR.

I think you misunderstood me, it sounds like mm supports the breakup. It's jmo.

I did not misunderstand you I agreed that MM supports it. I said most of us know why she supports the break up.

by stuckinsc Sun Jan 11, 2015 9:55 pm

MM did not post anything until after the official statement.

I understand the being sad, I went through it with Charlie and Sarah, they were so good together and their love was so real. I was overjoyed when the got back together. But, in the end they were just delaying the inevitable. I learned then to appreciate that the couples knows their situation best.

If this is truly the second break up and the first was during the Mexico trip in November, it seems like they really tried and it just wasn't making them happy.

by Sponsored content