Bachelor 19 - Chris Soules - FD- LCD - FRC - F1/2/3 - *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

chiliwhili wrote:Plus do the other girls know who won anyway?  So would it really matter too them if the F1 came, because they wouldn't even know she was the F1 yet.  Wouldn't that be true?

oh, I think they know...

^^^ oh Ok thanks, I guess these things have a way of getting out the other girls...

So we have a couple posts about necklaces at the FRC and it seems none of the women have worn necklaces to FRC. Whitney loves her big chunky necklaces and she doesn't have one on in FRC dress either. Do we know if the women aren't allowed to wear necklaces to the FRC? Just wondering.

chiliwhili wrote:Plus do the other girls know who won anyway?  So would it really matter too them if the F1 came, because they wouldn't even know she was the F1 yet.  Wouldn't that be true?

I think some/most of the girls definitely know. Sammi was on after buzz and she said that she knew who he picked. So, I would imagine if she knows, other girls that they were close to (Kaitlyn, Carly, Jade) probably know, as well.

I think that's probably the case in most seasons. Was it Brad's season, where no one except Michelle Money knew that Emily won because everyone believed RS?

chasingpavements wrote:

chiliwhili wrote:Plus do the other girls know who won anyway?  So would it really matter too them if the F1 came, because they wouldn't even know she was the F1 yet.  Wouldn't that be true?

I think some/most of the girls definitely know. Sammi was on after buzz and she said that she knew who he picked. So, I would imagine if she knows, other girls that they were close to (Kaitlyn, Carly, Jade) probably know, as well.

I think that's probably the case in most seasons. Was it Brad's season, where no one except Michelle Money knew that Emily won because everyone believed RS?

hmm interesting!. Oddly enough, this season resembles Brad 2.0 in so many ways... hmmmmmm

I don't see how F1 can keep it a secret...I know I couldn't! So if the F1 hung out with the other girls at the WTA after party, I would think the girls would know!

In Brad 1.0 Jennie didn't jnow that Deanna had been sent home.....

^^^^ I think "contestants" were scared of the lawsuit threats much more than they are today. No way that would be kept a secret anymore. The girls and guys talk.

I posted this in another thread and no one offered any opinion so I am going to post it here again. Aunties_love said that she thought Whitney may have arrived earlier. So here is my theory. It would be an unexpected twist too.

Due to the fact that the limos would be seen passing each other and the second girl would then "know" she was the F1. what about if Whitney goes first, is proposed to and then goes to the farmhouse with the family and then Becca comes second? I know it is off the wall but there have been a couple of others done this way and it eliminates the problem of the limos passing each other.

nuts2uiam wrote:I posted this in another thread and no one offered any opinion so I am going to post it here again.  Aunties_love  said that she thought Whitney may have arrived earlier.  So here is my theory.  It would be an unexpected twist too.

Due to the fact that the limos would be seen passing each other and the second girl would then "know" she was the F1.  what about if Whitney goes first, is proposed to and then goes to the farmhouse with the family and then Becca comes second?  I know it is off the wall but there have been a couple of others done this way and it eliminates the problem of the limos passing each other.

I think your theory is plausible but I thought they have hyped in the most recent previews that the unexpected twist is at ATFR? Or am I hopelessly confused?

KB_Mom wrote:

nuts2uiam wrote:I posted this in another thread and no one offered any opinion so I am going to post it here again.  Aunties_love  said that she thought Whitney may have arrived earlier.  So here is my theory.  It would be an unexpected twist too.

Due to the fact that the limos would be seen passing each other and the second girl would then "know" she was the F1.  what about if Whitney goes first, is proposed to and then goes to the farmhouse with the family and then Becca comes second?  I know it is off the wall but there have been a couple of others done this way and it eliminates the problem of the limos passing each other.

I think your theory is plausible but I thought they have hyped in the most recent previews that the unexpected twist is at ATFR?  Or am I hopelessly confused?  

I read about an unexpected twist and paid no attention that it was at the ATFR. Ok so maybe the theory goes to the scrap heap.

Plus there are two relatively equally long ways to get to the farm, so they could have gone different routes.