Bachelor Canada - Season 2 - Tim Warmels - *Sleuthing - *Spoilers* - *Speculation* - Trisha

HEA wrote:week 2
Discovering Trish (dragon party). she is fun and open. no opportunity. first attraction.
Discovering April (photoshop/rimmel). she is pretty and mysterious. took opportunity to know her more

week 3: beach group date (?)
Trish: nothing special, she was in the middle of the girls. edits? did they have special moments that we never saw on TV?
April: he ran after her and made up in the water with her in front of everyone not caring about reactions. very attracted obviously.

week 4
2-on-1: knew already he would pick trish. opportunity to know her more. no distraction, on beach to speak and learn more.
sharks: april was the only one staying longer in the water. admiration. no fears

week 5:
first date with april: who is she? still very reserved. Tim and April talk about relationships, her past betrayal, how love is unconditional, takes her to his 'life-changing' spot and says he is doing the same thing again, introduces April to his best-friend and Tim's best-friend's fiance.
group date wonderland: he hurt Trish (and sachelle and lisa). regrets. Tim realize that feelings are real. First time seeing trish unhappy and upset.

week 6:
Italy: falling in love with Trish. discovering further the intellectual and emotional
Painting: he picked lisa, not april. lost opportunity with her Had previously had 1:1 with April, unlikely to be able to do so again, still had April on his 3:1 date, have SCs of April (only other option is Kaylynn but unlikely) with Tim on Vespa in Italy, April having breakfast beside Tim

week 7:
HTD Trish: perfect, easy, loving, fun (reminds me of Ash and JP)
HTD April: tensed IMO. both distant physically. april shared her past at week 7 SCs of Tim and April making out in previews, not part of episode (a lot not part of episode but in previews/blogs)

week 8:
MTP trish: looks like everything went okay
MTP April: Not so okay at all.

so...... considering the above, the love story I see is with trish. I have no doubt he was attracted to April but even if she opened at hometown was it a bit too late and even if she talked about her past, I did not see a love declaration, only insecurities. I always thought it was a bit arrogant from April to say that she is hard to catch but she is worth it.

But again, that was the edited version. Will they repeat the same Bianca hard to catch or will they show us an easy and fun love story with no drama from the start?

Here is my dilemma. Repeat of Bianca hard to catch OR easy, fun love story? To me, Trish and Tim's relationship is BOTH of these, not OR.

Case in point: I will say that I can see the love story for Tim and Trish but it was very hidden. I outlined the love story earlier in this thread but here it is more simply...
1. Tim learning Trish won't give her all unless 100% (2-1 date)
2. Tim telling Trish he is scared that HE will get hurt in the end (Italy date)
3. Tim waiting to tell Trish his own feelings and doing so only AFTER she tells him how she feels about him (HTD)
4. Previews of upcoming episodes - Tim saying he is crazy about Trish and wants her to believe in 'us' (when she says her heart and head don't match)

I say 'hidden' because I had to look for these clues and connect them. Though they may seem obvious to some, they are certainly NOT obvious to many and thus the reason so many people, leading up to HTD, thought April is F1. I am not the only one who thinks this—the majority of the girls for WTA blogs that said they thought Trish will be F1 because it came out of left field (Tim telling Trish he fell a long time ago) during HTD.  So, it was hidden for most of the time and now only more obvious. But as to the easy-going relationship? That was there from the start and all the girls stated how easy Tim and Trish are with one another. So, imo, it is almost a case of both Bianca/Easy and not either.

ETA: regarding April's dates (again, so much of what I added was not aired but shown in previews or part of blogs. So hidden). Can lean either way: hidden because not F1 or because already obvious to so many (as is definitely the case with most viewers having chosen April as F1) that needed to not have it in there. But again, I can see the love story with Trish/Tim as being more of a progression whereas with Tim/April it is a rollercoaster, up and down, up and down.

great points AAL
I would not have believed much Trish if she said from the start that she was madly in love with him too. For her to say that her head says it is crazy is more acknowledging that she did fall in love despite the unusual situation.
Everyone who want to participate have reservation and no matter if they said they came to find potentially love, they do not believe it. what are the odds it would really happen. It is all nice and fun to say it but to really accept it, is another matter.
I think trish is more afraid that is it not real love vs april is more afraid that she can trust him. looks the same but it is not. Trish knows she loves him and she trust him but not herself, april does not trust him at this point, not her. they are both waiting the ILY from tim but for different reasons.
not sure if i make sense, sorry.

Ok. Reminder--this is a Trisha thread.

Kashathediva wrote:Ok. Reminder--this is a Trisha thread.

But this is not a fan thread? Not sure how we can discuss if April cant be mentionned?
(not being snarky, promise! Just want to figure out how we can discuss points that touch on both girls when brought up here?)

sophienette wrote:But this is not a fan thread? Not sure how we can discuss if April cant be mentionned?
(not being snarky, promise! Just want to figure out how we can discuss points that touch on both girls when brought up here?)

April is mentioned all over at the other threads, my understanding this is the thread to prove why we think Trisha is F1, mods please let me know if that is right?

Apologies if my post was not pro-Trish when that was my intention. My dilemma was not about Trish not being F1 but about why having to have to choose between a Bianca edit or an easy relationship when Trish has both. What I was actually trying to state is that Trish can be both Bianca (F1 from last season) and easy-going (F1 for this season) and thus, doubling up on both these things further affirm that she is F1. Whitney was up and down, up and down (as April has been shown to be). All the red stuff I posted I stated were hidden/not included in the episodes (so outside information) and thus less reliable than what is seen with Trish and Tim. At the end of my post I reaffirmed that Trish and Tim have a progression of a love story rather than just the up/down rollercoaster of April. Again, apologies if that never came across correctly but I was trying to show how Trish can be both Bianca and have something easy and this be an F1 like Bianca but without the drama (April/Whitney)- thus both things can support her as F1, not just one or the other.

i am a bit lost too
if i want to make my point, I cannot avoid mentioning april to make comparison and state points that trish is F1
not sure where to go then, can you help me?
I am confused, sorry

4health wrote:

sophienette wrote:But this is not a fan thread? Not sure how we can discuss if April cant be mentionned?
(not being snarky, promise! Just want to figure out how we can discuss points that touch on both girls when brought up here?)

April is mentioned all over at the other threads, my understanding this is the thread to prove why we think Trisha is F1, mods please let me know if that is right?  

This is not a fan thread but it is a thread to show more evidence supporting Trish=F1.

Please read my post again (my most recent and the one before that). I understand it may be misunderstood but I have expounded on why I posted it as I did since it was actually my way of trying to show how Trish can be F1 based on a previous season and also her easy going relationship (not about drama) this season. That both these things can contribute to her being F1 not either or. Hope that makes sense?

AAL, HEA  I am not the mod here but both your posts are not the issue FYI

AAL you are ok.
This is not a fan thread, agreed. But let's try to keep the discussion on Trisha in this thread. If any comparisons need be made regarding another cast--there are various threads those can be posted. Thank you.

Oh. Haha. Thanks for the clarification 4health. Well, I was trying to actually show more evidence for Trish as F1 based on HEA's post that Trish is either Bianca edit or easy going and saying I think she can be both those edits (thus a double emphasis = F1).

Lol. Whenever the mods say something, the first thing I think is I need to fix myself! Haha.