Re: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Media Thread - Fan Forum - Discussion Thread #4

by Ash2214 Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:09 pm

timfan wrote:What I found interesting is andi said if josh was not on the show she would not be engaged I had thought if josh was not casted she probably would have chose nick

I think she's essentially saying that yes, obviously she fell in love with Josh and is happy with him, but if he wasn't there (assuming the other guys were) she couldn't see herself ending up engaged to someone from the show. Whether Josh was there or not, she still had a relationship with Nick and according to Andi, she liked him and was attracted to him, but it didn't go further than that, so even her "number two" guy didn't compare to her relationship or how she felt with Josh, so it would be difficult to imagine herself getting engaged to any other guy that was there.

by soccermom333 Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:11 pm

Best interview ever! They are such a "normal" couple. I really hope they do get married on TV. Sounds like they would not mind Atlanta though. Interesting that she already named a date... May 9th. Haha Smiley

Come on now ABC make it happen! They are sooooo popular.

by Alanna Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:11 pm

Ash2214 wrote:
timfan wrote:What I found interesting is andi said if josh was not on the show she would not be engaged I had thought if josh was not casted she probably would have chose nick

I think she's essentially saying that yes, obviously she fell in love with Josh and is happy with him, but if he wasn't there (assuming the other guys were) she couldn't see herself ending up engaged to someone from the show. Whether Josh was there or not, she still had a relationship with Nick and according to Andi, she liked him and was attracted to him, but it didn't go further than that, so even her "number two" guy didn't compare to her relationship or how she felt with Josh, so it would be difficult to imagine herself getting engaged to any other guy that was there.

I think there's also some wishful thinking here on her part. Let's face it, would she want to be the most hated Ette ever and not get engaged/walk away like Brad? No. If Josh wasn't there, she'd be engaged to Nick right now. They would probably break up long before she would leave atl or make any serious real world commitment, but she'd be engaged at this moment. Obviously, Josh is her perfect fit and fate/luck/casting girl named Sandy brought them together but if there was a snafu in the universe and he wasn't on the show, she would still walk away engaged imo.

by soccermom333 Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:15 pm

It is also interesting that she mentioned how much she LOVED football!! I bet they both head to KC this Thursday. Smiley

by pander3575 Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:15 pm

:cutesmile!: Wonderful MJC

by GrahamGal Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:20 pm

I think Josh approves! giggling

Wow, my fiancé @AndiDorfman is smokin' ... and Taken!! #JezebelMagazineAtlanta pic.twitter.com/4tC4OEjdzm
— Josh Murray (@jmurbulldog) August 5, 2014

by GrahamGal Tue Aug 05, 2014 5:31 pm

MJC1969 wrote:Enjoy Y'all

Enjoy I did. Haven't met a Jodi video I haven't loved. Thanks for this afternoon delight.

by nannymargie Tue Aug 05, 2014 6:57 pm

soccermom333 wrote:Best interview ever! They are such a "normal" couple. I really hope they do get married on TV. Sounds like they would not mind Atlanta though. Interesting that she already named a date... May 9th. Haha

Come on now ABC make it happen! They are sooooo popular.

AS luck may have it May 9th is on a sat next year. Prefect day for a wedding.

by eliza3 Tue Aug 05, 2014 7:02 pm

Alanna wrote:
Ash2214 wrote:
timfan wrote:What I found interesting is andi said if josh was not on the show she would not be engaged I had thought if josh was not casted she probably would have chose nick

I think she's essentially saying that yes, obviously she fell in love with Josh and is happy with him, but if he wasn't there (assuming the other guys were) she couldn't see herself ending up engaged to someone from the show. Whether Josh was there or not, she still had a relationship with Nick and according to Andi, she liked him and was attracted to him, but it didn't go further than that, so even her "number two" guy didn't compare to her relationship or how she felt with Josh, so it would be difficult to imagine herself getting engaged to any other guy that was there.
I think there's also some wishful thinking here on her part. Let's face it, would she want to be the most hated Ette ever and not get engaged/walk away like Brad? No. If Josh wasn't there, she'd be engaged to Nick right now. They would probably break up long before she would leave atl or make any serious real world commitment, but she'd be engaged at this moment. Obviously, Josh is her perfect fit and fate/luck/casting girl named Sandy brought them together but if there was a snafu in the universe and he wasn't on the show, she would still walk away engaged imo.

I think Andi would have left alone if she wasn't ready to truly get married to someone. She is a strong woman who obviously made some demands during the show (no hot tub/pool parties early on, etc) Plus I think family means way to much to her to become engaged to someone she knows she will break up with. So while I think it would have been difficult , I can totally seeing her walking away alone.

by Georgia Lindsay Tue Aug 05, 2014 7:13 pm

soccermom333 wrote:It is also interesting that she mentioned how much she LOVED football!! I bet they both head to KC this Thursday.

Yes, she grew up on Saturday football, as most of us SEC fans did, #GoUGA. I think they will go to KC, and meet up with Lauren and Denny. Maybe they will celebrate Josh's birthday early with Aaron and the family before Josh and Andi go back to ATL and the Murrays back to Tampa?

I loved her interview, all she wants to do is marry Joshalicious! Smart girl.

by nanbrooks Tue Aug 05, 2014 7:27 pm

What an awesome down-to-earth interview! My favorite by far! :yes:

by Maggenzm Tue Aug 05, 2014 8:02 pm

eliza3 wrote:
Alanna wrote:
Ash2214 wrote:

I think she's essentially saying that yes, obviously she fell in love with Josh and is happy with him, but if he wasn't there (assuming the other guys were) she couldn't see herself ending up engaged to someone from the show. Whether Josh was there or not, she still had a relationship with Nick and according to Andi, she liked him and was attracted to him, but it didn't go further than that, so even her "number two" guy didn't compare to her relationship or how she felt with Josh, so it would be difficult to imagine herself getting engaged to any other guy that was there.
I think there's also some wishful thinking here on her part. Let's face it, would she want to be the most hated Ette ever and not get engaged/walk away like Brad? No. If Josh wasn't there, she'd be engaged to Nick right now. They would probably break up long before she would leave atl or make any serious real world commitment, but she'd be engaged at this moment. Obviously, Josh is her perfect fit and fate/luck/casting girl named Sandy brought them together but if there was a snafu in the universe and he wasn't on the show, she would still walk away engaged imo.

I think Andi would have left alone if she wasn't ready to truly get married to someone. She is a strong woman who obviously made some demands during the show (no hot tub/pool parties early on, etc) Plus I think family means way to much to her to become engaged to someone she knows she will break up with. So while I think it would have been difficult , I can totally seeing her walking away alone.

totaly agree with you. It would have been difficult, but she would have done it for sure. Cus what Nick and her had wasn't strong enough to last. He needed too much reassurance from her. Infatuations don't last, just like Julian blog said " I’m proud Andi was able to distinguish the physical love between the emotional love - I mean her and Nick had it going on... ,but it didn’t really seem to go beyond the sexual connection (cue sexual healing). IMO, her relationship with Nick is the same as JPG/Clare.

by Sponsored content