Re: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Media Thread - Fan Forum - Discussion Thread #3

by umngirl Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:01 pm

GuardianAngel wrote:
umngirl wrote:
Litta, along with others, figured out a great deal of the wording on the letter and compared writing samples to determine it was from Catherine. I never doubted it was from her, they passed notes all season, but watching them figure it out was entertaining and awesome.

I remember that! I don't remember what the story line was around the letter. Did they make a big deal about the letter which supposedly was going to make for a shocking ending? I'm thinking maybe the letter is in fact from the F1 as it was in Catherine's case.

ETA: forget that. CH says its' from one of her F2

EETA: I'm confusing myself! When did Sean get Catherine's letter?

They made a huge deal about the letter. During the live cut-ins of CH during the finale they were hyping it and Sean's sudden change in relationship or something like that. It was totally stupid.

He got the letter right before Cat showed up at the FRC.

by stuckinsc Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:04 pm

So the babe thing. I hear it all the time at the medical school I attend here in GA. To my generation babe was for the one. Not how I hear it used here at all.

It may be significant or it maybe not much.

by docnash14 Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:14 pm

isittrue wrote:I think maybe she does not choose anyone at least at FRC. Now what happens at the ATFR is anyone's guess but the SM and rumors still favor Josh as F1 so maybe this is just more drama.

I will be completed flummoxed if Andi chooses no one at the FRC. As far as I'm concerned, Andi understood fully well what her job was - secure a proposal at the FRC and obtain as many I love you's along the way as she could. We know she delivered the second mandate and I have no doubt she did the same with the first.

by tryingnottoobsess Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:15 pm

Maybe this has been speculated on - could the letter be from Josh? It's being used as a vehicle to cast doubt, but, really it's a love note or one of encouragement. It looks like she is dressed in the before MTA outfit. Everyone is "assuming" the note is from Nick. Could just be the TPTB attempt to deflect spoilers and Nick video and get viewership up for the the finale. I've lost count of how many MOST dramatic rose ceremonies there have been. CH deserves an award for keeping a straight face.

by **GuardianAngel** Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:16 pm

umngirl wrote:
GuardianAngel wrote:
umngirl wrote:
Litta, along with others, figured out a great deal of the wording on the letter and compared writing samples to determine it was from Catherine. I never doubted it was from her, they passed notes all season, but watching them figure it out was entertaining and awesome.

I remember that! I don't remember what the story line was around the letter. Did they make a big deal about the letter which supposedly was going to make for a shocking ending? I'm thinking maybe the letter is in fact from the F1 as it was in Catherine's case.

ETA: forget that. CH says its' from one of her F2

EETA: I'm confusing myself! When did Sean get Catherine's letter?

They made a huge deal about the letter. During the live cut-ins of CH during the finale they were hyping it and Sean's sudden change in relationship or something like that. It was totally stupid.

He got the letter right before Cat showed up at the FRC.

Thanks for the refresher, yes I remember that now!

by atem Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:21 pm

eirekay wrote:All I gotta say is that TPTB have us EXACTLY where they want us....at the edge of our seats and guaranteed to be in front of a screen on Monday night!

They don't have me there.

by atem Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:26 pm

I highly doubt that she would dump one guy the day before and the other at the RC. She gets engaged and the letter was probably not read until the MTA.

by 2observe Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:36 pm

tryingnottoobsess wrote:Maybe this has been speculated on - could the letter be from Josh? It's being used as a vehicle to cast doubt, but, really it's a love note or one of encouragement. It looks like she is dressed in the before MTA outfit. Everyone is "assuming" the note is from Nick. Could just be the TPTB attempt to deflect spoilers and Nick video and get viewership up for the the finale. I've lost count of how many MOST dramatic rose ceremonies there have been. CH deserves an award for keeping a straight face.

Welcome aboard TNTO.

by Guest Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:40 pm

Alanna wrote:
soccermom333 wrote:
gabriele wrote:
per the bold i don't think andi changed her mind at all. she's been calling josh babe since at least HTDs and has never called nick that. the producers are using the plane vid to shape the story which is rather bizarre but we will probably see more and more of this in future shows with the prevalence of SM & spoilers.

i believe andi will send nick home the morning of the FRC. she picks josh. all is well. then da da dun. the letter! right at the end of the FRC and cut to commercials. at the ATFR we see the whole thing with nick and the letter. does she even read it? who knows? maybe not. nick comes out, they talk. nick leaves. josh comes out and it's happy couple time. the end.

Gabriele you have the right scenario I believe! She lets Nick go early... Josh proposes and she says she loves him and accepts.... The note is brought up at the ATFR but Andi wants nothing to do with it because she would be disrespecting Josh.... Josh comes out and all is well. :cutesmile!:
I wonder if she'll read it. I would be so curious, even if I knew tptb had manipulated the guy into writing it! I would probably break down and read it. Maybe not if I with Josh though, he's a good deterrent from note-reading from other men

i'm not sure if she'll read the letter or not. in a way it is rather insulting if she were to just hand it back unread like emily did with arie's journal. while i'd rather they not have the letter be an issue at all i think for nick's sake i'd rather she have read it (not onscreen) and then just reiterate that she's happy with josh. it's more likely she won't read it though. jmo.

by Tiggerlgh Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:41 pm

tryingnottoobsess wrote:Maybe this has been speculated on - could the letter be from Josh? It's being used as a vehicle to cast doubt, but, really it's a love note or one of encouragement. It looks like she is dressed in the before MTA outfit. Everyone is "assuming" the note is from Nick. Could just be the TPTB attempt to deflect spoilers and Nick video and get viewership up for the the finale. I've lost count of how many MOST dramatic rose ceremonies there have been. CH deserves an award for keeping a straight face.

Yes I think this is very possible as well, the letter could be from Josh. This has been discussed some if it's a SeanCat knockoff with the letter from F1.

by Piper61 Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:43 pm

stuckinsc wrote:So the babe thing. I hear it all the time at the medical school I attend here in GA. To my generation babe was for the one. Not how I hear it used here at all.

It may be significant or it maybe not much.

That is not what I hear at my medical school. On another note, kids my H.S. son's age call their girlfriends/boyfriends "Bae" and not babe. I think babe is still mostly for the significant other though.

ETA: pander, you make a good point. If it was common for Andi, she wouldn't only be calling Josh that IMO.

by pander3575 Thu Jul 24, 2014 11:46 pm

Piper61 wrote:
stuckinsc wrote:So the babe thing. I hear it all the time at the medical school I attend here in GA. To my generation babe was for the one. Not how I hear it used here at all.

It may be significant or it maybe not much.
That is not what I hear at my medical school. Kids my H.S. son's age call their girlfriends/boyfriends "Bae" and not babe.

Stuck, I know what you're saying that it can be common but if Andi was using it in that way she'd be saying it to all the guys or at least she would have called Nick Babe too. I think it's different because we've only heard her say it to Josh.

by Sponsored content