Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 10 - MTP-LCD-FRC- July 28/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

I looked at the filming schedule we have and there were no day offs.   Just trying to figure it all out.[/quote]

Me too just trying to figure it out. So, I know this has been asked a million times, but who did they film first, do we know?

I'm thinking, if they filmed F2 guy first, they have their LCD, the next morning, she realizes she needs to let him go. She's thinking by the water, get's dressed in her feathery dress, in the morning before the F1 LCD, (does this fall in line with the weather forcast) and lets him go. She has the LCD with the F1. Therefore there aren't any s/caps of guys/suits/rings/and hands.

I just can't see her letting the F2 go in the morning of the FRC, getting composed and ready for 12 noon.[/quote]


Do we know what time the LCD start? If the dates do not start until later in the day then she could potentially have said goodbye to F2 BEFORE going on her LCD w/ her F1. When I look at the SC and they show her and Josh sitting on the sofa and she says "I spend all my time worrying about..." her eyes look like she 'could' have been crying.

Another letter? Did we know about this one??

Bringing this over from the Josh Fan Thread. Thanks to GrandmaPeg she caught a preview on ENews. They showed the two gifts Josh, baseball card with Andi Murray on it, and Nick sand in a bottle and charms. Someone asked what was on the card.

Grandma Peg wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

Grandma Peg wrote:E! didn't mention what was on the card and talked over most of the scene when he was reading from a letter, both of them smiling ear to ear, then he shows her the card and she laughs at the "Andi Murray" and he says it has a nice ring to it!  So cute!   

Who was reading from a letter??

Josh ^

GuardianAngel wrote:Another letter? Did we know about this one??

First I've heard about this one, but a gift to the lead from each of the final 2 has been a show staple for a long time. I've seen pictures, puzzles, scrapbooks, all kinds of things. I've heard they always do this but they don't always include it in the final edit. I think one time they had the F1 gift as a deleted scene. If a letter was part of one gift I don't think it changes the trajectory of anything.

Lucas15 wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:Another letter? Did we know about this one??

First I've heard about this one, but a gift to the lead from each of the final 2 has been a show staple for a long time. I've seen pictures, puzzles, scrapbooks, all kinds of things. I've heard they always do this but they don't always include it in the final edit. I think one time they had the F1 gift as a deleted scene. If a letter was part of one gift I don't think it changes the trajectory of anything.

I agree and it probably wouldn't have anything to do with the letter she got at the MTA. It's just something Josh wrote to Andi as in seasons past.

It may be from Andi

I loved what JP wrote to Ashley on their LCD, it was beautiful.

GuardianAngel wrote:Another letter? Did we know about this one??

Bringing this over from the Josh Fan Thread. Thanks to GrandmaPeg she caught a preview on ENews. They showed the two gifts Josh, baseball card with Andi Murray on it, and Nick sand in a bottle and charms. Someone asked what was on the card.

Grandma Peg wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

Who was reading from a letter??

Josh ^

I really think the letter went along with the baseball card, but not really sure. I was able to make out what was on the back of the baseball card:


Bats: Right throws Richt
Drafted: 1st round 1st pick
Games Played: Doesn't play games
Runs: Into Josh's arms
Walks: In Piedmont Park
Doubles: As an Attorney
Errors: Can't dance, swears too much
Slugging Percentage: Hope to never find out
Strike-outs: 0
Steals: Josh's heart
Saves: Josh from being a lonely man

Fun Fact: Her husband has never missed a day saying I love you

^typo...first line should be "bats right, throws right"

Grandma Peg wrote:^typo...first line should be "bats right, throws right"

Thanks we knew that, really appreciate you doing this for us. Best.gift.everrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!!!!!  

Grandma Peg wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:Another letter? Did we know about this one??

Bringing this over from the Josh Fan Thread. Thanks to GrandmaPeg she caught a preview on ENews. They showed the two gifts Josh, baseball card with Andi Murray on it, and Nick sand in a bottle and charms. Someone asked what was on the card.

Grandma Peg wrote:

Josh ^

I really think the letter went along with the baseball card, but not really sure. I was able to make out what was on the back of the baseball card:


Bats: Right throws Richt
Drafted: 1st round 1st pick
Games Played: Doesn't play games
Runs: Into Josh's arms
Walks: In Piedmont Park
Doubles: As an Attorney
Errors: Can't dance, swears too much
Slugging Percentage: Hope to never find out
Strike-outs: 0
Steals: Josh's heart
Saves: Josh from being a lonely man

Fun Fact: Her husband has never missed a day saying I love you

This is the most adorable thing Josh has done. So romantic.

I was thinking maybe the letter we see CH hand to Andi is from Josh, as GrandmaPeg mentions, we hear him narrate it.

In other words, they make a big deal about the letter. Andi is all concerned, she stares at it as if it's bad news, where in fact it's a sweet letter from Josh? She picks it up and starts reading it, we hear Josh's voice reading the letter.

Grandma Peg wrote:^typo...first line should be "bats right, throws right"

Richt .. Football coach UGA