Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 9 - Fantasy Dates - July 14/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

stuckinsc wrote:

Tiggerlgh wrote:I know they change things up but has a non F1 ever got the secluded island date?

Back in the good old days, when they actually went three different places for the FDs, the beach date was the kiss of death, until Estella got the beach date in Belize (I remember her telling Bob he better Belize it).  Of course, was being Bob's F1 really a win.

What I have noticed more than a pattern with FDs is the LCD.  The intimate quite LCD tends to be F1 where as the activity is more an F2 thing.  Jason and Chantal both with sharks, Ben and Clare both helicopter, Courtney and Lindzi both had activities, Arie had the botanical gardens and love potion (that was active for Emily).

I think if there is a more intimate date the F1 usually gets it for LCD.

stuckinsc wrote:

Tiggerlgh wrote:I know they change things up but has a non F1 ever got the secluded island date?

Back in the good old days, when they actually went three different places for the FDs, the beach date was the kiss of death, until Estella got the beach date in Belize (I remember her telling Bob he better Belize it).  Of course, was being Bob's F1 really a win.

What I have noticed more than a pattern with FDs is the LCD.  The intimate quite LCD tends to be F1 where as the activity is more an F2 thing.  Jason and Chantal both with sharks, Ben and Clare both helicopter, Courtney and Lindzi both had activities, Arie had the botanical gardens and love potion (that was active for Emily).

I think if there is a more intimate date the F1 usually gets it for LCD.

jcrbil wrote:^^^ Catherine and Lindsay both had activities, too.... though for Catherine, it was a bucket list item (riding the elephant which she got to do twice!).

Cecilia wrote:I asked this in another thread but what F1's have not gotten the traditional F1 FD?  The day with the locals is never the F1 FD in my memory.

soccermom333 wrote:

SueSt wrote:^^^All good points... however if I'm Andi and Josh is my F1, I'm taking him to the secluded beach... Let the producers come up with different dates for F2 and F3.

But it really isn't secluded with the cameras and all the producers.  LOL  She has time later to be "alone" with him.  ;)  Even though they show her having doubts about taking Josh to FS, like get real.  She goes and we all know it!!  Silly producers!    

umngirl wrote:

SLA44 wrote:

Tiggerlgh wrote:I know they change things up but has a non F1 ever got the secluded island date?

Yes, Sean did on Emily's season.

I'm a huge Sean fan, but I couldn't remember what his FD was. Now I remember why, I completely erased that awkwardfest from my mind.

And while it's not exactly the same, AshLee got a private beach/lagoon for her FD, after the cave of course.

nutty1 wrote:Do you think when comparing fantasy dates, it makes a difference if it's the Bachelor or Bachelorette bring compared?

nutty1 wrote:Wouldn't you think if you were one of the final 3, and finally had alone time on the FD, you'd expect the lead to tell you he/she loves you and you're the one?
I wonder if all have? I also wonder if the F2's ever considered why they weren't told?