Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 8 - HTDs - Jul 07/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

I agree that it makes perfect sense that the reason there was no long "honeymoon" for the final couple this season was due to filming being delayed at least 2 days, if not more, because of Eric's death. So regardless of who the F1 is, I don't see this development as significant as far as being a clue.

From reading the thread, I'm getting the feeling that some are upset with the wording of certain posts which assume Josh is F1. Obviously some here are convinced that he is, and that's fine. Isn't every post written with the understanding that it is just that person's OPINION, regardless of whether or not the wording so indicates? If some people here are convinced that Nick is F1, they are certainly welcome to post their comments accordingly, no?

Kashathediva wrote:

Alanna wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:Many times the lead has a good idea from night one who the F1 will be.

 I am wondering if Josh was it from the beginning, that the time frame shortening the honeymoon time on DR was irrelevant as the couple would be in the same city and be able to see each other on the lam much easier.

But they didn't know who would be f1 before they created the travel schedule I assume. I really think Eagle's theory makes the most sense- they would have had 5 days like everyone else if filming wasn't delayed for a few days.

Yes, of course, but the schedule was altered very unfortunately from Eric's death. 
At that point, most leads do know who their F1 are, many know from the M/G. 
So the abbreviated honeymoon phase would not be such a hardship for local lovers very cross country lovers.

But even if Nick was f1, it's not like they could have changed the schedule and they would have had reduced time too, even if they would have probably been more cranky about it than neighbors Josh & Andi. I'm probably misunderstanding you and need more coffee!

When do we get the episode description for Episode 8?

mtnlvr55 wrote:When do we get the episode description for Episode 8?

tomorrow.

But even if Nick was f1, it's not like they could have changed the schedule and they would have had reduced time too, even if they would have probably been more cranky about it than neighbors Josh & Andi. I'm probably misunderstanding you and need more coffee!

Yes.   
You need more coffee and you are misunderstanding me.   
It does not matter who the F1 would have been. The alteration of the schedule due to an unfortunate situation(understatement) would have been the same. 
The alteration would be easier to swallow if the couple is geographically in each other's back yard vs a few states away. 
Example: Meandi goes to mall, parks her car, goes in one entrance and out another and is picked up by a handler in another car and swept away to a hide away. Same with Josh. The have an afternoon delight. 
You can't do this as easily states away.

I thought it was sleuthed and confirmed that the FRC was on May the 9th.

Is there proof that it was not ?

Kashathediva wrote:

But even if Nick was f1, it's not like they could have changed the schedule and they would have had reduced time too, even if they would have probably been more cranky about it than neighbors Josh & Andi. I'm probably misunderstanding you and need more coffee!

Yes.   
You need more coffee and you are misunderstanding me.   
It does not matter who the F1 would have been. The alteration of the schedule due to an unfortunate situation(understatement) would have been the same. 
The alteration would be easier to swallow if the couple is geographically in each other's back yard vs a few states away. 
Example: Meandi goes to mall, parks her car, goes in one entrance and out another and is picked up by a handler in another car and swept away to a hide away. Same with Josh. The have an afternoon delight. 
You can't do this as easily states away.

I think we agree!

I'm trying to figure out when exactly Andi and the guys were told about Eric's death. Was it before or after HTDs???
In the sc they are all sitting together when CH tells them. 

^^ before HTDs... Andi can not make it through the RC without breaking down

BachfanNY wrote:I'm trying to figure out when exactly Andi and the guys were told about Eric's death. Was it before or after HTDs???
In the sc they are all sitting together when CH tells them. 

From the scene, it would seem that it was after all of the HTDs when the four are together in one location before the RC. I believe we learned it was after Josh's HTD, and he was the last one.

SueSt wrote:^^ before HTDs... Andi can not make it through the RC without breaking down

Thanks Sue, ...I'm curious though because they were all together when CH tells them which means it would have been before leaving to HTDs in belguim or after the HTDs in Cali, right? But, I thought I read that Eric didn't pass until Andi's HTD with Josh so in my head I reasoned that perhaps they were told the day of the Ep 8 RC when they were all back. Is that totally wrong?

She looks really broken up at the RC.

Piper61 wrote:

BachfanNY wrote:I'm trying to figure out when exactly Andi and the guys were told about Eric's death. Was it before or after HTDs???
In the sc they are all sitting together when CH tells them. 

From the scene, it would seem that it was after all of the HTDs when the four are together in one location before the RC.  I believe we learned it was after Josh's HTD, and he was the last one.  

oops, missed your post. that's what I remember too!