Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 3 - Sun - Jun 1/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

Thoughts on Last night's episode:

-Nick V wins again for doing something thoughtful for Andi.

-JODI's kiss was very hot! I may have rewinded that scene a few times   They acted like they've kissed a million times before. i.e. Andi-"I hate it when you do that face". You can tell they had a conversation that was cut out. Andi was sitting up at first and when josh reached in to kiss her her head was layed back on the chair and she was looking very happy and relaxed. I'm wondering if their conversations would give much more away. When she gave hi the rose, she said he opened up to her.

The drama- Why did JJ have to get Josh involved? Why not confront him himself? I feel like all the guys who already knew hid behind Josh who just found out. If you noticed, even Nick V chimed in. I don't think Josh was that angry and he confronted him with the idea of getting his side of the story.

I went back and watch the scene of the confrontation, if you look at it again and not concentrate on Josh, it was a lot more guys involved in this I was shocked that Nick V was also because the first time around I didn't notice him......

I think tptb riled the guys up and because Josh is already the most invested in Andi and is the most grown ass of the men, he was front and center. Not a great look, but tptb definitely helped him along.

As for typical f1 edit/ chemistry edit, the person and relationship dictate the edit. The women typically go for their chemistry guy unlike the men who spend all season over one chick and then decide to go for the other one.

luvlady345 wrote:I went back and watch the scene of the confrontation, if you look at it again and not concentrate on Josh, it was a lot more guys involved in this I was shocked that Nick V was also because the first time around I didn't notice him......

He was involved cause he was at the dinner/in the car when it happened and heard it first hand. Josh I dunno he just decided to make it his business.... Weird if you ask me.

Alanna wrote:I think tptb riled the guys up and because Josh is already the most invested in Andi and is the most grown ass of the men, he was front and center. Not a great look, but tptb definitely helped him along.

As for typical f1 edit/ chemistry edit, the person and relationship dictate the edit. The women typically go for their chemistry guy unlike the men who spend all season over one chick and then decide to go for the other one.

This is true! I remember Jillian and Ed. Bachelorettes do tend to go for the guy, who as Jillian said, "you want to rip their clothes off."   

emad0722 wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:I went back and watch the scene of the confrontation, if you look at it again and not concentrate on Josh, it was a lot more guys involved in this I was shocked that Nick V was also because the first time around I didn't notice him......

He was involved cause he was at the dinner/in the car when it happened and heard it first hand. Josh I dunno he just decided to make it his business.... Weird if you ask me.

Josh didn't just decide to make it his business JJ came to him with it....

emad0722 wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:I went back and watch the scene of the confrontation, if you look at it again and not concentrate on Josh, it was a lot more guys involved in this I was shocked that Nick V was also because the first time around I didn't notice him......

He was involved cause he was at the dinner/in the car when it happened and heard it first hand. Josh I dunno he just decided to make it his business.... Weird if you ask me.

Nick V said he was in bed when Andrew told him about the number, I went back and watched it......Why did Nick V decide to make it his business?

luvlady345 wrote:

emad0722 wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:I went back and watch the scene of the confrontation, if you look at it again and not concentrate on Josh, it was a lot more guys involved in this I was shocked that Nick V was also because the first time around I didn't notice him......

He was involved cause he was at the dinner/in the car when it happened and heard it first hand. Josh I dunno he just decided to make it his business.... Weird if you ask me.

Nick V said he was in bed when Andrew told him about the number, I went back and watched it......Why did Nick V decide to make it his business?

watch again nick was at the dinner and in the car... He said he was told in the car then Andrew bragged again in the bedroom. he was involved cause everyone was in the group when Andrew was there and Josh referred to the fact he had been told by multiple people and Nick backed him up. Im not hating on Josh he just seemed to step up more than those who saw it first hand (could be an edit though who knows)  :cutesmile!:

luvlady345 wrote:

emad0722 wrote:

luvlady345 wrote:I went back and watch the scene of the confrontation, if you look at it again and not concentrate on Josh, it was a lot more guys involved in this I was shocked that Nick V was also because the first time around I didn't notice him......

He was involved cause he was at the dinner/in the car when it happened and heard it first hand. Josh I dunno he just decided to make it his business.... Weird if you ask me.

Nick V said he was in bed when Andrew told him about the number, I went back and watched it......Why did Nick V decide to make it his business?

Nick V and JJ were I believe the only other two to actually witness it as they were the only two there... So I am assuming he was backing up the claim tosupport the other two guys as he was actually there

Josh was very confrontational and indignant for someone who only heard about something second-hand.  Seemed to me he jumped all over it as soon as JJ shared it with him.   JJ stirred the pot by telling Josh...he knew Josh would freak given his volatile personality. It all seemed really fake to me. Andrew could barely keep from bursting out laughing.

Piper61 wrote:

docnash14 wrote:It's interesting to me that Josh is frequently described here as arrogant.  Tonight I thought he was much less so than Marcus.  For instance, Josh commented that he "felt good about us" (which I take as self-confident) but he wasn't sure he would get the rose as he didn't know what was going on in her connections with the other guys whereas Marcus stated (paraphrasing) that while he didn't know what kind of connection Andi had with Josh he (Marcus) knew it wasn't as strong as the one they (he and Andi) had (which I see more as arrogance).  

I have to agree with this because I was thinking the same thing after Marcus' PI. I also agree with Alanna? who posted that Josh is a bit crazed but about Andi, and it showed what he described as his protectiveness for people he cares about.

I don't see Marcus being arrogant at all. First of all, you can never really know when these PI actually happen because TPTB slice and dice conversations so much. Maybe it happened later and they put it in now.....who knows. Besides I look at what Marcus said as similar to what Chris said about not caring so much about the other relationships because he trusted what he and Des had and how strong their relationship was. I think Marcus is adorable and should be the next Bachelor....JMO.   

IrishGal wrote:Josh was very confrontational and indignant for someone who only heard about something second-hand.  Seemed to me he jumped all over it as soon as JJ shared it with him.   JJ stirred the pot by telling Josh...he knew Josh would freak given his volatile personality.  It all seemed really fake to me.  Andrew could barely keep from bursting out laughing.

I agree though, Josh did get extremely agitated too quickly. Me thinks he has a temper for sure!