Andi Dorfman - The Bachelorette 10 - Discussion

Hotmomma wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:Change of topic:
I have a fun speculation I had been spinning in my head. 
What if Andi did not make a choice at the end, but decided to date both her F1 and F2 for a span of time like Charlie did? 
It could account for her abbreviated time in DR. 
It could account for her taking off work for 6 months, to allow dating.  It could account for the strange edits and SM diarrhea from all sources. 
It would extend her 15 minutes of fame without even having to do another show, then she could always do that after, too.
This idea doesn't keep my awake at night. 
It's not an obsession. It's just another spin.

I come play with you.( It doesn't keep me awake either)
Maybe that is why Nick is still wooing her thru SM.
Josh's camp has been pretty quiet lately about the show.

Just spinning...

The Jimmy Kimmel interview dress   

notarose wrote:

The Jimmy Kimmel interview dress   

Huh??  

SueSt wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:Change of topic:
I have a fun speculation I had been spinning in my head. 
What if Andi did not make a choice at the end, but decided to date both her F1 and F2 for a span of time like Charlie did? 
It could account for her abbreviated time in DR. 
It could account for her taking off work for 6 months, to allow dating.  It could account for the strange edits and SM diarrhea from all sources. 
It would extend her 15 minutes of fame without even having to do another show, then she could always do that after, too.
This idea doesn't keep my awake at night. 
It's not an obsession. It's just another spin.

I like it - unless you are 100% sure... and how can you be... it make the most sense in the context of this crazy show

I think it is funny that every season we come up with a "what if..." that totally throws a monkey wrench in the spoilers. They rarely come true but shows how much we get invested in the process.

I think that Andi did have to choose someone and they had to propose. TPTB DID NOT want another Juan P. They wanted a "proper" ending. Is Josh the F1--it seems too easy that he is the one and too pat that the spoilers are right and that there is so much confirmation that he is "the one."
I feel that there is some type of twist to the season: why is Josh shown so openly travelling to Mexico? I can't help but remember the cruise that Brooks took. Everyone said that it couldn't be that he was alone: Des must somehow be connected or it was scheduled before so they would meet up later. Well, he really was alone and they had "broken up" prior to the fantasy suite.
I don't think it is Nick. His video seems too real for it not to be real. I don't think it is Chris (but he was handing out roses ala Chris S) because I don't see the connection and I don't think Andi would move to Iowa and live on a farm.
I do think she is going to be on DWTS (boy, will that be a mess--she will make Sean look like Fred Astaire)

What will happen? I can only think that it is Josh and everything is neatly tied up in a bow.(despite the fact that it seems too obvious.)

Kashathediva wrote:Change of topic:
I have a fun speculation I had been spinning in my head. 
What if Andi did not make a choice at the end, but decided to date both her F1 and F2 for a span of time like Charlie did? 
It could account for her abbreviated time in DR. 
It could account for her taking off work for 6 months, to allow dating.  It could account for the strange edits and SM diarrhea from all sources. 
It would extend her 15 minutes of fame without even having to do another show, then she could always do that after, too.
This idea doesn't keep my awake at night. 
It's not an obsession. It's just another spin.

I would love this! It would make me like Andi again. I truthfully have been waiting for another lead to do this, even though in Charlie's case he didn't seem all that undecided to me, except his friends thought Sarah was too bossy.

They could do this "Charlie scenario" even if the lead knew concretely who her F1 was early on, if they could get the f2 to work with them.

Charlie's season, he was pretty sure who his F1 was and went for the scenario. Krisily was not surprised during the dating portion and knew he was not going to pick her. 
If TPTB sweetened the pot ($), I bet all hands would be on deck.(the lead, F1, F2)
 They could provide episodes for a couple weeks showing their 1:1 dates and then have a live FRC.
 I think the viewers would be very invested in this.

^^^ absolutely; I mean they wouldn't even have to film it... but it extends the talk about the show... a win/win

Kashathediva wrote:They could do this "Charlie scenario" even if the lead knew concretely who her F1 was early on, if they could get the f2 to work with them.

Charlie's season, he was pretty sure who his F1 was and went for the scenario. Krisily was not surprised during the dating portion and knew he was not going to pick her. 
If TPTB sweetened the pot ($), I bet all hands would be on deck.(the lead, F1, F2)
 They could provide episodes for a couple weeks showing their 1:1 dates and then have a live FRC.
 I think the viewers would be very invested in this.

I would love it. I actually would have been more on board with Des if she had just dated Chris at first. The whiplash between crying her eyes out over Brooks and accepting Chris's proposal made it hard for me to get on board with her and Chris for a while.

The season where they really should have let that happen was Jason's.  He truly was torn.  It's not often when the lead isn't favoring one finalist over the other by the end, if not downright, 100% (in their mind at least) certain.

But I don't believe the producers will ever allow a lead to continue dating both, or worse, pick nobody, again.  I'm sure they were furious with JPG for not budging on the non-proposal.

mtnlvr55 wrote:

SueSt wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:Change of topic:
I have a fun speculation I had been spinning in my head. 
What if Andi did not make a choice at the end, but decided to date both her F1 and F2 for a span of time like Charlie did? 
It could account for her abbreviated time in DR. 
It could account for her taking off work for 6 months, to allow dating.  It could account for the strange edits and SM diarrhea from all sources. 
It would extend her 15 minutes of fame without even having to do another show, then she could always do that after, too.
This idea doesn't keep my awake at night. 
It's not an obsession. It's just another spin.

I like it - unless you are 100% sure... and how can you be... it make the most sense in the context of this crazy show

I think it is funny that every season we come up with a "what if..." that totally throws a monkey wrench in the spoilers. They rarely come true but shows how much we get invested in the process.

I think that Andi did have to choose someone and they had to propose. TPTB DID NOT want another Juan P. They wanted a "proper" ending. Is Josh the F1--it seems too easy that he is the one and too pat that the spoilers are right and that there is so much confirmation that he is "the one."  
I feel that there is some type of twist to the season: why is Josh shown so openly travelling to Mexico? I can't help but remember the cruise that Brooks took. Everyone said that it couldn't be that he was alone: Des must somehow be connected or it was scheduled before so they would meet up later.  Well, he really was alone and they had "broken up" prior to the fantasy suite.
I don't think it is Nick.  His video seems too real for it not to be real. I don't think it is Chris (but he was handing out roses ala Chris S) because I don't see the connection and I don't think Andi would move to Iowa and live on a farm.
I do think she is going to be on DWTS (boy, will that be a mess--she will make Sean look like Fred Astaire)

What will happen? I can only think that it is Josh and everything is neatly tied up in a bow.(despite the fact that it seems too obvious.)

I agree with your entire post mtnlr. I think the cat is really out of the bag this season and TPTB cannot do anything about it. I really do not see this as a repeat of Des season.

On another note, if that's your dog on your avatar, then his/her twin lives with me. I keep thinking what is my Lucy doing on your avatar.   

Andi just tweeted AGAIN about tonight. By my count that is 5 tweets, 2 Instagram photos and a number of Retweets all about Belgium. Someone is EXCITED!!!

Or someone is trying to spark interest in hopes the ratings will be better!  

Beagle wrote:

mtnlvr55 wrote:

SueSt wrote:
I like it - unless you are 100% sure... and how can you be... it make the most sense in the context of this crazy show

What will happen? I can only think that it is Josh and everything is neatly tied up in a bow.(despite the fact that it seems too obvious.)

I agree with your entire post mtnlr. I think the cat is really out of the bag this season and TPTB cannot do anything about it. I really do not see this as a repeat of Des season.

On another note, if that's your dog on your avatar, then his/her twin lives with me. I keep thinking what is my Lucy doing on your avatar.   

Yep, that is my boy Scout. Lot's of people think he is a girl because he has a pretty face!