Re: Brooks Forester - Bachelorette 9 - Fan Thread - Discussion #5

by Judiful Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:10 pm

Adele1117 wrote:
Judiful wrote:
Adele1117 wrote:To go along with what I said earlier that it's not a very girl thing to be able to switch from one great love to another like that in the course of five days/two weeks. I also realized just now how little Des fought to keep Brooks. Did she really even try to stop him? I mean, I would've at least tried to work things out and tried to keep him. She just started going whoa is me, no one loves me, okay, go then, what else are you going to do? I wonder what would've happened if she'd actually asked him to stay, showed more love, begged a little. I'm ashamed to say I probably would've begged a little.
. Who really knows what happened..those editors let us see what they want us to. There's so much hidden from us. I really want to know what it was about her that he didn't love. IveI've been so curious about that..
True. But then of course they wouldn't show her begging and him denying her because they wouldn't be able to use the "Is Brooks coming back?" line for a week.

. You've got it !!

by Rolly Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:12 pm

I think Des will say a lot of things to justify how quickly she went from the broken heart of Brooks to accepting Chris' proposal. I think she loved Brooks "I love you ...you're the only one I can say that to". "I was conflicted because when I was on dates I wanted to be on dates with you. I wanted to give my heart to you".

Now she talks about how important the last two weeks are...it was really 5-7 days from the time Brooks left until Chris' proposal. Think about that. It would have been much more believable if she would have said as much as I want to walk away from here with a ring on it, it's been such an emotional time, maybe it would be best if we date for a month or two and then ask me again. No, she talks about how things are "accelerated" in the bubble and it's totally reasonable that she can be in love with Brooks, fall out of love with Brooks and then in love with Chris in less than one week. Just don't buy it.

She can explain away all she wants what happened but it was Brooks that she wanted and if he would have stayed he would have gotten the final rose.

by Aunties_Love Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:17 pm

BarbB222 wrote:
Aunties_Love wrote:
BarbB222 wrote:
2observe wrote:
sfrank wrote:That's the nature of the show...go back and watch Ben and Ashley during their LCD and tell me if you could believe watching those scenes she was madly in love with JP.

As for the Chris stuff, I think she wrote the poem out of appreciation for the two Chris had already written to her. The 1on1 time during dodgeball was orchestrated by Chris and TPTB not Des, the sketches I will give you (albeit the same thing Zak did for her). I think she definitely had feelings for Chris - in fact i believe that she was falling for him. But she was already in love with Brooks. However, now yes she seems to be love with Chris. Its easy to fall in love especially when its a great guy like Chris and he loves that much! Time will tell if they will be a successful couple but they seem to have a good shot!
I just thought that it was extremely telling that Des gave Chris the Dodge Ball group date rose instead of Brooks since he was the one that got injured for his efforts.
I don't think it was telling at all. Des already admitted with every date she went on she WISHED it was with Brooks and we also know she fell for Brooks early. He was on meds and didn't have a chance to shower. I think it was good thing he didn't get that group date. Appropriate actually considering the circumstance.
I see this is a thought carried by many, but IMO, it was a thing said in the heat of the moment during Brooks breakdown and leaving. I really don't know how much weight something like that can hold when it is said during a time of stress and emotion like that. As far as Brooks not getting "that date"; he was on that date and didn't get the date rose. Going by the look on his face when she gave it to Chris, IMO, he really thought that rose would of been his and since it wasn't, that is why it was telling, IMO.
Blah blah blah! Chris was F2 until Des' true F1 bowed out. Simple really. No need for flowery words or explanations. It was what it was.

I guess some will see it that way, but facts are, she chose to accept the proposal from Chris. Has left her beloved southern California to move to Seattle with Chris and is really happy with him so I really don't see how Brooks's F1 status is in debate. It is obvious that it is Chris according to Des as she did choose him and did fall in love with him.

by bilolo Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:17 pm

Yeah i really don't know why people are trying to find something telling about Chris during the show really, everybody saw the episodes and knew Brooks was Des's choice to marry if he did not choose to leave her. Why even try, they're happy now (all the party involved) and that's what's important everything else is blabla

by Guest Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:21 pm

I want another Brooks pic or the twerking video.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

by BarbB222 Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:22 pm

Rolly wrote:I think Des will say a lot of things to justify how quickly she went from the broken heart of Brooks to accepting Chris' proposal. I think she loved Brooks "I love you ...you're the only one I can say that to". "I was conflicted because when I was on dates I wanted to be on dates with you. I wanted to give my heart to you".

Now she talks about how important the last two weeks are...it was really 5-7 days from the time Brooks left until Chris' proposal. Think about that. It would have been much more believable if she would have said as much as I want to walk away from here with a ring on it, it's been such an emotional time, maybe it would be best if we date for a month or two and then ask me again. No, she talks about how things are "accelerated" in the bubble and it's totally reasonable that she can be in love with Brooks, fall out of love with Brooks and then in love with Chris in less than one week. Just don't buy it.

She can explain away all she wants what happened but it was Brooks that she wanted and if he would have stayed he would have gotten the final rose.

Remember when Brooks' fans were accused of having rose colored glasses on? Guess not only his fans went to that sale. Des is a spin doctor now because what she said was caught on tape. She needs to cover her tracks when they were exposed for a reason. Whomever said MF does not care about the love story is right. They spent all that time with Brooks' breaking up with Des to show how deep her feelings were for him and how quick they changed. ITA Rolly!

by Rolly Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:23 pm

Are some people here in the wrong thread?!? Just saying this is Brooks fan thread.... there is a Des and Chris thread.

Does anybody have another picture of Brooks????

by sfrank Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:24 pm

Rolly...those words are something huh?! What some people want to dismiss as " heat of the moment " I call "truth. Heartbreaking truth from a girl who was laying all her cards out the table." That was the realest scene in the shows history...

Lets get back to Brooks now!

by BarbB222 Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:27 pm

Aunties_Love wrote:
BarbB222 wrote:
Aunties_Love wrote:
BarbB222 wrote:
2observe wrote:
sfrank wrote:That's the nature of the show...go back and watch Ben and Ashley during their LCD and tell me if you could believe watching those scenes she was madly in love with JP.

As for the Chris stuff, I think she wrote the poem out of appreciation for the two Chris had already written to her. The 1on1 time during dodgeball was orchestrated by Chris and TPTB not Des, the sketches I will give you (albeit the same thing Zak did for her). I think she definitely had feelings for Chris - in fact i believe that she was falling for him. But she was already in love with Brooks. However, now yes she seems to be love with Chris. Its easy to fall in love especially when its a great guy like Chris and he loves that much! Time will tell if they will be a successful couple but they seem to have a good shot!
I just thought that it was extremely telling that Des gave Chris the Dodge Ball group date rose instead of Brooks since he was the one that got injured for his efforts.
I don't think it was telling at all. Des already admitted with every date she went on she WISHED it was with Brooks and we also know she fell for Brooks early. He was on meds and didn't have a chance to shower. I think it was good thing he didn't get that group date. Appropriate actually considering the circumstance.
I see this is a thought carried by many, but IMO, it was a thing said in the heat of the moment during Brooks breakdown and leaving. I really don't know how much weight something like that can hold when it is said during a time of stress and emotion like that. As far as Brooks not getting "that date"; he was on that date and didn't get the date rose. Going by the look on his face when she gave it to Chris, IMO, he really thought that rose would of been his and since it wasn't, that is why it was telling, IMO.
Blah blah blah! Chris was F2 until Des' true F1 bowed out. Simple really. No need for flowery words or explanations. It was what it was.
I guess some will see it that way, but facts are, she chose to accept the proposal from Chris. Has left her beloved southern California to move to Seattle with Chris and is really happy with him so I really don't see how Brooks's F1 status is in debate. It is obvious that it is Chris according to Des as she did choose him and did fall in love with him.

She took the fast track to validate her Second choice. The media knows it and so do many others. We can tit for tat all day long but the fact will remain, Chris was Des' second choice. You cannot spin that away. We all saw it .

by Guest Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:27 pm

BarbB222 wrote:
Rolly wrote:I think Des will say a lot of things to justify how quickly she went from the broken heart of Brooks to accepting Chris' proposal. I think she loved Brooks "I love you ...you're the only one I can say that to". "I was conflicted because when I was on dates I wanted to be on dates with you. I wanted to give my heart to you".

Now she talks about how important the last two weeks are...it was really 5-7 days from the time Brooks left until Chris' proposal. Think about that. It would have been much more believable if she would have said as much as I want to walk away from here with a ring on it, it's been such an emotional time, maybe it would be best if we date for a month or two and then ask me again. No, she talks about how things are "accelerated" in the bubble and it's totally reasonable that she can be in love with Brooks, fall out of love with Brooks and then in love with Chris in less than one week. Just don't buy it.

She can explain away all she wants what happened but it was Brooks that she wanted and if he would have stayed he would have gotten the final rose.
Remember when Brooks' fans were accused of having rose colored glasses on? Guess not only his fans went to that sale. Des is a spin doctor now because what she said was caught on tape. She needs to cover her tracks when they were exposed for a reason. Whomever said MF does not care about the love story is right. They spent all that time with Brooks' breaking up with Des to show how deep her feelings were for him and how quick they changed. ITA Rolly!

They did do that, didn't they? I think they were mistaken in thinking we'd find the ending entertaining and surprising and amazing. Brooks even said he was "blown away" by it, totally sarcastically I'm sure. Blown away so much that he unfollowed her on Twitter.

by nannymargie Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:32 pm

Can I ask what happened to our Brooks FAN THREAD?

I will believe what I saw and heard and no one will change my mind.

by iamreal2u Wed Aug 14, 2013 8:35 pm

2observe wrote:
sfrank wrote:That's the nature of the show...go back and watch Ben and Ashley during their LCD and tell me if you could believe watching those scenes she was madly in love with JP.

As for the Chris stuff, I think she wrote the poem out of appreciation for the two Chris had already written to her. The 1on1 time during dodgeball was orchestrated by Chris and TPTB not Des, the sketches I will give you (albeit the same thing Zak did for her). I think she definitely had feelings for Chris - in fact i believe that she was falling for him. But she was already in love with Brooks. However, now yes she seems to be love with Chris. Its easy to fall in love especially when its a great guy like Chris and he loves that much! Time will tell if they will be a successful couple but they seem to have a good shot!
I just thought that it was extremely telling that Des gave Chris the Dodge Ball group date rose instead of Brooks since he was the one that got injured for his efforts.

Don't think so at all. Brooks was to medicated to continue a date late into the night.

by Sponsored content