Bachelor 24 - Peter Weber - Media SM - *Sleuthing Spoilers* #4

So, technically, he chose both. And will stay with neither.
Unimpressive season.

I do not think that Peter has handled things well. I am glad that he broke it off with HA if he did not want to be with her rather than dragging the engagement out.

My question is when do we think he broke things off with HA? Madison was spotted filming in Auburn on February 11 according to RS.

IF RS is right. it seems to be turning out to be the same thing they made Arie do. Get engaged to his F2 , break up on camera and then go after and try to win back the one he really wanted. The only other thing that makes me pause on that one is, that's been done before so it's nothing we haven't seen. What could be going on that never happened before? jmo

Jolena wrote:IF RS is right. it seems to be turning out to be the same thing they made Arie do. Get engaged to his F2 , break up on camera and then go after and try to win back the one he really wanted. The only other thing that makes me pause on that one is, that's been done before so it's nothing we haven't seen. What could be going on that never happened before? jmo

Madi says no?

Jolena wrote:IF RS is right. it seems to be turning out to be the same thing they made Arie do. Get engaged to his F2 , break up on camera and then go after and try to win back the one he really wanted. The only other thing that makes me pause on that one is, that's been done before so it's nothing we haven't seen. What could be going on that never happened before? jmo

I think the difference is Madi left on her own, so he didnt pick HA over her...she was just the one left

Jolena wrote:IF RS is right. it seems to be turning out to be the same thing they made Arie do. Get engaged to his F2 , break up on camera and then go after and try to win back the one he really wanted. The only other thing that makes me pause on that one is, that's been done before so it's nothing we haven't seen. What could be going on that never happened before? jmo

That Madison left prior to the FRC. We've never had a girl in the F2 leave prior to the FRC. Andi and Cassie don't count because they left at F3.

@Jolena yeah! His demeanor may mean he is preparing himself for ALL the haters! It's going to be crazy.

Exactly. No contestant has left after MTP/LCD's.

Cassie self-eliminated during FSD's and at the time she left, there were still 2 other girls in the mix.  Other contestants that left also left during the FSD time period.  Ali/Frank, Desiree/Brooks come to mind.

Several leads have eliminated their F2 before the FRC but that was their choice. Emily/Arie and Ali/Chris come to mind.

Peter didn't eliminate Madison, she eliminated herself.

RS' spoiler has been the theory that I've been running with for a few weeks now. We'll see if he's right. But I feel certain he didn't pull a Colton. All season long what we've seen from Peter is general indecisiveness and the fact that he doesn't truly know himself or what he wants. I felt there was no way it was ever going to be as simple as him chasing after Madi after she left.

I don't see how any self respecting woman could watch this season and actually actively want to be with Peter, so that makes me certain that Madison's taken him back. Because neither Peter nor his final women strike me as being particularly bright, especially when it comes to matters of the heart.

All jmo

I think he knew what he wanted but like Arie went along with what the producers wanted. They wanted an engagement and they want Drama Drama. jmo

Crazylady29 wrote:

Jolena wrote:IF RS is right. it seems to be turning out to be the same thing they made Arie do. Get engaged to his F2 , break up on camera and then go after and try to win back the one he really wanted. The only other thing that makes me pause on that one is, that's been done before so it's nothing we haven't seen. What could be going on that never happened before? jmo

Madi says no?

Let's hope she does!