Bachelor 24 - Peter Weber - S/Caps - *Sleuthing Spoilers*

Agent99 wrote:

gabriele wrote:On the preview I just caught something: when Peter says, “I am falling in love with her,” it looks like he’s saying that to HA’s father but Peter is in a dark plaid shirt which is what he wore on Madi’s HTD. I think he was wearing a solid black shirt for HA’s HTD. So, he’s talking about Madi to her parents not HA’s.

It's HA father - the brick background is the same.  And this is Peter's shirt.  I guess he is going to say he is falling in love with the others, but only I love you to Madi.

Oops! I could have sworn he had that shirt on with Madi. ETA: it’s a different plaid shirt with Madi!

gabriele wrote:

gabriele wrote:In the preview when Madi, in the silver dress, is walking away it is nighttime. Then, at the RC I’m presuming, CH asks “what happened last night?”  HA says, “I don’t even know what to do right now.” Is HA saying that at the F3 RC? Or maybe FRC?

Maybe CH was referring to VF’s HTD the previous night? I can’t keep all these RCs straight.

When Madi walks away in the silver dress maybe she left right before the FS during the dinner portion? It doesn’t seem to have been totally planned as we see production people in the shot when she walks away. I’m thinking this is a bit similar to HB & Luke P’s fiasco FD dinner. The rolling on the bed red dress that we now think is Madi may have not been from a FS as someone here suggested since it’s a different dress.  

Isn't the rolling on the bed dress black? where's the SC of rolling on the bed in red dress? TIA This is the most confusing season I have ever watched.

CaliforniaGirl wrote:


I think the silver dress is the hometown rose ceremony.

The blinds behind MADISON look purple, but it’s because there is a purple light on the floor. The same blinds are behind Kelsey.

Does anyone know where the F4 ceremony was filmed?

I've gone back through the archived threads and can't find that information anywhere but I definitely think you're onto something.

I didn't start sleuthing this season till they got to AU - does anyone recall if the location of the F4 to F3 RC was revealed?

Jolena wrote:

gabriele wrote:

gabriele wrote:In the preview when Madi, in the silver dress, is walking away it is nighttime. Then, at the RC I’m presuming, CH asks “what happened last night?”  HA says, “I don’t even know what to do right now.” Is HA saying that at the F3 RC? Or maybe FRC?

Maybe CH was referring to VF’s HTD the previous night? I can’t keep all these RCs straight.

When Madi walks away in the silver dress maybe she left right before the FS during the dinner portion? It doesn’t seem to have been totally planned as we see production people in the shot when she walks away. I’m thinking this is a bit similar to HB & Luke P’s fiasco FD dinner. The rolling on the bed red dress that we now think is Madi may have not been from a FS as someone here suggested since it’s a different dress.  

Isn't the rolling on the bed dress black? where's the SC of rolling on the bed in red dress? TIA This is the most confusing season I have ever watched.

Rewatching the vid it is either a dark red or black. It’s hard to tell really. SC should be in SC section.

Okay I have a crazy theory: at the dinner portion of FD Madi and Peter have a convo and Madi finds out he slept with someone. Madi gets upset and decides to leave before the FS. Then, she comes back at the RC and stuff probably happens. Echoes of Luke P and HB. No idea if I’m on to anything or not. Got to go to bed!

CaliforniaGirl wrote:


I think the silver dress is the hometown rose ceremony.

The blinds behind MADISON look purple, but it’s because there is a purple light on the floor. The same blinds are behind Kelsey.

Does anyone know where the F4 ceremony was filmed?

If it’s at the HTD RC how would this convo happen? I’m trying to remember, don’t the women usually just arrive and they go straight to the RC or is that just F3 RC? Is it usually light out at HTD RC or nighttime like this scene?

Bobette wrote:Is this the same dress?  





Source

I'm still not convinced these are the same dress (the sequining and neckline seem a bit different to me) nor that they are both Madi.  

After watching the video again, IMO the woman walking away has Vic F's body shape (curvier than Madi) her hair is curled at the ends exactly how Vic's curls and is not as long as Madi's, and the white nails match Vic F's in other SCs.

Wouldn't be surprised if they deliberately put all three women in similar silver dresses so they could do this kind of thing in the edit.  







Source

^^^ In the 2nd photo where the woman is walking away she has a very scraggly piece of hair that hangs down. I’ve noticed Madi’s hair to be that way on her IG. Her extensions are a bit choppy & uneven at the bottom.

ETA: https://www.instagram.com/p/B5T_0qTHh7J/?igshid=h4i68wt10dtm

I think we need to do a height comparison.  Did anyone get SCs of Madi and Peter on the bridge in the Peru episode?  

(Full disclosure: I stopped watching pre-Costa Rica )

ETA:  OK this will probably do.



Source

Flipped:



Comparison:



Source

Looks pretty close actually. Now need one of him with Vic F...

It looks like it could definitely be a height match.

When CH asks Peter “what happened last night?” Peter is in the tan suit so that is the RC after FDs. This would line up with my theory Madi left at FD dinner if her FD was the night before. Do we know the FD order?

I’m starting to think @atem ‘s original theory that Madi left and came back might be true.

Vic F comparison shots

Back/Hair



Source

Flipped

Bobette wrote:



Source

Height





Source

Dang. Now it looks like VF. Not sure what to think!