Josh Murray - BIP - Famously Single - Season 3 - *Sleuthing - Spoilers* #3

StacyNor wrote:

Nibbles22 wrote:yeah sorry, the only person I see obsessed with Josh is MM.  I think peeps always ask Nick about Josh (given the circumstances on BIP with the two of them together again), but I honestly think he couldn't care less about him, and probably cringes anytime someone brings up Josh's name.   I know I would.

Basically. I followed Andi season very closely and it would be Josh making snide comments about Nick on interviews. He seemed very hurt that time about Andi choosing Josh, but he was never cruel or made snide comments about Josh (The plane video doesn't count as that was taken when he was having a private conversation to a friend). He, Josh is the one that seem never got over Nick sleeping with Andi and has held that against him all these years. According to Andi, he even called her a wh--e because of it. The thing I have against Josh and this has been happening since Andi's season. I feel like people always excuse his actions, from Andi's book, to Nick and now Amanda. I believed Andi when I read the snippets from her book, because I saw they type of person he was from her season. It is always someone's fault on how he acts and reacts in situations. He has a temper, he is very controlling and very manipulative. It has been that way since Andi's season, but then people were excusing his actions and some are still doing so. I don't think Nick cares about Josh at all. He just loves making fun of him because he knows how he will react and have fun for his benefit. Nick is older and wiser than Josh, that is why 3 years later after being crucified by the public and basically despised the tide changed to people actually liking and rooting for him and getting the very gig Josh wanted from day 1, while you read Amanda's Instagram comments are people telling their own stories about how they dated a narcissistic like Josh and she should run away from him. The very same Josh that was well liked and once upon a time people wanted as a bachelor..

Seabear wrote:IMO neither Nick or Josh like each other and that dislike is a two way street. IMO Nick toys with Josh with snarky comments and Josh explodes and rants in response. Nick is like the cat outside the fence that parades back and forth in front of the dog taunting it and Josh is like the Rottweiler that barks and barks and lunges at the fence even though there is no way to get on the other side. I think sex with Andi is a sore subject for them both. In different ways it was a blow to both their egos...and neither one can let it go. The Amanda choosing Josh over Nick...just reignited bitter feelings and the competition that endures. Luckily for Nick he had production on his side and got the good edit this time. I see both of them as equally flawed and equally blessed.....each in his own unique way.
JMO

MiniDiva wrote:

Seabear wrote:IMO neither Nick or Josh like each other and that dislike is a two way street. IMO Nick toys with Josh with snarky comments and Josh explodes and rants in response. Nick is like the cat outside the fence that parades back and forth in front of the dog taunting it and Josh is like the Rottweiler that barks and barks and lunges at the fence even though there is no way to get on the other side. I think sex with Andi is a sore subject for them both. In different ways it was a blow to both their egos...and neither one can let it go. The Amanda choosing Josh over Nick...just reignited bitter feelings and the competition that endures. Luckily for Nick he had production on his side and got the good edit this time. I see both of them as equally flawed and equally blessed.....each in his own unique way.
JMO

Very well stated.  I see it the same way.  Production knew what it was doing when they put these two together.  

Alanna wrote:

MiniDiva wrote:

Seabear wrote:IMO neither Nick or Josh like each other and that dislike is a two way street. IMO Nick toys with Josh with snarky comments and Josh explodes and rants in response. Nick is like the cat outside the fence that parades back and forth in front of the dog taunting it and Josh is like the Rottweiler that barks and barks and lunges at the fence even though there is no way to get on the other side. I think sex with Andi is a sore subject for them both. In different ways it was a blow to both their egos...and neither one can let it go. The Amanda choosing Josh over Nick...just reignited bitter feelings and the competition that endures. Luckily for Nick he had production on his side and got the good edit this time. I see both of them as equally flawed and equally blessed.....each in his own unique way.
JMO

Very well stated.  I see it the same way.  Production knew what it was doing when they put these two together.  

Exactly right imo. Nick is the little sibling screwing with the older one who then immediately runs to mom and dad once he gets punched. Just because one is a weasel doesn't make it right or good that the other is a bully who cannot control his temper imo. Ugh. Poor women of this franchise.

havadrpepper wrote:I really don't think that Nick was falling for Amanduh.  I think he does like her... as a little sister and is very concerned about her being with Josh.  But being jealous because Josh stole her away from him. Nope. Not believing it at all.