Re: Bachelor 19 - Becca Tilly #4

by hmbach Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:17 pm

Hopefully wrote:I think someone needs to make another video of Becca and C hint hint. I so love them. The only thing they put me tears.

Just came across this one that her sister retweeted... I mean come on!!! These two are together. NO WAY your sister retweets this if he picked someone else. Not for any kind of money.

by notarose Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:19 pm

concerned36 wrote:
hmbach wrote:
quietpal wrote:Yeah, some of us have pondered about that, why they would show that on the beach, but no one has come up with any answers yet.

My theory that it was a hidden love letter from Chris to Becca saying, "you're the one" from here on out it's all show.

Remember the conversation they had in the loft about her being nervous because Dez didn't reciprocate feelings to her? My theory is that this was Chris' way of telling her that he loves her and he's all in. They would have had to spend their alone time doing something if not having sex... perhaps they walked the beach and he spelled it out for her? Could he have done it while they were together and then the producers threw it in as a reminder to B when watching the show back that he loved her all along? I know it's far fetched but it just came to mind when I saw it. I am a ridiculous hopeless romantic.

That wasn't in the loft, that was at night on the date in South Dakota, when she said her ex didn't reciprocate feelings. In the loft, her story was a little different. She said she had never been in love before and that she could not picture her ex as her husband and the father to her children.

I really think the I LOVE YOU in the rocks was either already there, Bali is a honeymoon spot, or the producers did it. It is a romantic spot. Why not capture it on the Bachelor? I don't think any of the cast and crew have time to create that...

I agree. The rock message was probably there before the crew arrived.

giggling

or it could have been foreshadowing that Kaitlyn's love story was going to be "on the rocks". She had a completely different FS venue with dinner by a structure made of huge rocks plus she had lit the " I PINKHEART

you sign."... now unlit and rock rubble on the beaches of Bali.

by hmbach Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:20 pm

concerned36 wrote:A few seasons ago, I read that the F2 have to agree not to reject a proposal. That it's a rule of the show, that once a contestant makes top 2, they cannot say no to a proposal. I'm sure it was Desiree's season where this was mentioned bc this is why Brooks backed out. He was pretty sure if he didn't walk away, he wouldn't be able to once he got another rose. Is this maybe one of the rules this season, that they did away with. Because, if this was still a rule, then Chris knows that he can propose to either woman and get a yes. Becca should have backed out in Bali, if she was unsure.

That is what I think their heated discussion in Bali was all about that we didn't get to see.

Maybe he gives her a Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds The Proposal type proposal. "Marry Me so that I can date you" :cutesmile!:

by Beagle Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:22 pm

happygolucky wrote:Beagle - love your avatar, but maybe is time to change the signature Shar is engaged.

I wrote my deductions in general thread - but just to sum up: I still believe the edit leads to Becca as F1, and from that I draw out that she was in the "corner of his eye" before Whitney. Even when I watched the first part of Whitney's 1on1 date at the broad daylight and compare it to Chris&Becca's interaction on the roof on the evening (which happened before) ... I see different expression on Chris' face. But I could be reading it all wrong.

, I know Sharleen is engaged, but I haven't been posting much this season and I got lazy giggling

. I'll get right to it, or maybe if I leave it long enough it will happen j/k.

In regards to the edit, without knowing the spoilers, I would think Becca was F1, BUT unfortunately every season now we deal with SM after filming, and sure enough every season they give us clues to make the outcome known and I can't ignore what I'm seeing in SM which to me points directly to Whitney.

by Hopefully Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:24 pm

I can understand why C would say remember make love out west. When they were with the elders. They asked him for advice. Maybe they were telling them in better forms. Your love lies out west. Into the same words. Maybe it was the elders telling Chris his love ( Becca) lives to the west. Or they could be telling him the love you seek is west of you. I like elders they are wise.;)

by Guest Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:28 pm

hmbach wrote:
concerned36 wrote:A few seasons ago, I read that the F2 have to agree not to reject a proposal. That it's a rule of the show, that once a contestant makes top 2, they cannot say no to a proposal. I'm sure it was Desiree's season where this was mentioned bc this is why Brooks backed out. He was pretty sure if he didn't walk away, he wouldn't be able to once he got another rose. Is this maybe one of the rules this season, that they did away with. Because, if this was still a rule, then Chris knows that he can propose to either woman and get a yes. Becca should have backed out in Bali, if she was unsure.

That is what I think their heated discussion in Bali was all about that we didn't get to see.

Maybe he gives her a Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds The Proposal type proposal. "Marry Me so that I can date you" :cutesmile!:

But if she showed up for the RC ready to get a rose, she was taking a big chance, fully committing to being F2. A big risk, if she wasn't sure.

by hmbach Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:30 pm

Hopefully wrote:I can understand why C would say remember make love out west. When they were with the elders. They asked him for advice. Maybe they were telling them in better forms. Your love lies out west. Into the same words. Maybe it was the elders telling Chris his love ( Becca) lives to the west. Or they could be telling him the love you seek is west of you. I like elders they are wise.;)

For sure!! I loved that he tweeted that! All of his followers were like what does that mean? But it was another sign to Becca publicly that even though he can't tell her yet in public he loves her he can drop a hint (just like the luckiest man alive comment that her brother retweeted I think it was close to Valentines day?). That and the fact that the west theme seems to be BIG on this season. Think about it, the destinations... all out west, the sunset kiss on the rooftop, the sun setting in Iowa in the last episode, Becca living in the West. ALL these things point directly at Becca. That is no coincidence.

by Hopefully Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:32 pm

But the thing at the RC. Becca told the girl she thinks she is going home.

by hmbach Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:33 pm

concerned36 wrote:
hmbach wrote:
concerned36 wrote:A few seasons ago, I read that the F2 have to agree not to reject a proposal. That it's a rule of the show, that once a contestant makes top 2, they cannot say no to a proposal. I'm sure it was Desiree's season where this was mentioned bc this is why Brooks backed out. He was pretty sure if he didn't walk away, he wouldn't be able to once he got another rose. Is this maybe one of the rules this season, that they did away with. Because, if this was still a rule, then Chris knows that he can propose to either woman and get a yes. Becca should have backed out in Bali, if she was unsure.

That is what I think their heated discussion in Bali was all about that we didn't get to see.

Maybe he gives her a Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds The Proposal type proposal. "Marry Me so that I can date you" :cutesmile!:

But if she showed up for the RC ready to get a rose, she was taking a big chance, fully committing to being F2. A big risk, if she wasn't sure.

It's my opinion that she was sure, or she would have told him so. Just my two cents. She was sure she didn't want them to end. She just isn't sure she wants to move to Arlington yesterday (and wisely so) they have only been on what? 5 dates? That would be insane in her (and most everyones) eyes.

by Guest Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:36 pm

Hopefully wrote:But the thing at the RC. Becca told the girl she thinks she is going home.

My thought was because they had said they would talk before the RC after thinking more about the questions that Chris had when they woke up in the FS that morning. But Chris said he didn't have time. (CH said producers decided on the timing right before the RC) So if I were Becca, I would think I was going home if Chris had not reached out to her in those days since. She didn't know he was going to pull her out of the RC to talk.

by Hotmomma Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:37 pm

I believe Becca told him she was all in..NO? Durning their talk?

by hmbach Sun Mar 01, 2015 5:37 pm

Hopefully wrote:But the thing at the RC. Becca told the girl she thinks she is going home.

When would she have seen her though? W and B wouldn't have seen each other since the RC at HTD's right? And doesn't B say that if she is reading the feelings she had on the HTD as being really in love that she would look back on it and say it started right there? Could be producers were feeding into her insecurities about being a virgin heading into the FS and how likely would it be for a Bachelor to pick a virgin after the FS? She would probably think she didn't have a chance until their date in Bali.

by Sponsored content