Bachelor Canada - Season 2 - *Sleuthing - *Spoilers* - *Speculation* - Discussion #2

northernviewer wrote:I wonder why the pic of Lisa is shown with it?  is it because she has more in common with her than we thought?  I noticed in one scene when Lisa is being mean, I think its Trisha that's sitting real close to her (when she has that seafoam coloured dress on.. don't remember where that was?)

Also, something just occurred to me.  When the girls were in Italy and talking about somebody not being there for the right reasons... Lisa was there and Trish was on her date.  We all assumed they were talking about Lisa, right in front of her, and the edit wanted us to think they were... but what if they were really talking about Trish??  something to think about IMO  If I get a chance, I'm going to go look at it later with that thought in mind.

See what I posted [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] starting in 2nd paragraph of my post ... We are thinking along the same lines. 

The only other reason I can explain Trish's behavior if by the smallest % that she is F1 is that she is no longer with him. I just don't see her as F1 though. Too many pieces of the puzzle, the edit and post-show behavior combined doesn't look good for her or on her.

"Who Do You Think Will Get the Final Rose?"

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

This show is enough to make anyone insecure, but Trish was pretty even keel all the way through it. She seems completely comfortable in her own skin. She's real, so you get the good and bad. In the Bahamas, she called Lisa Jekyll and Hyde because Lisa was being phony to Natalie. As far as her mean girl tweet, she's probably a bit hurt to watch it play out on TV. No one is perfect. She certainly wasn't making the kinds of mistakes Lisa did or Courtney or Vienna. The negative side to her is mild imo.

I didn't expect to like her because of the beauty pageant stuff, but she's fun. If she was overly into her looks, she wouldn't have made all the goofy faces and she would have changed her earrings! Compare her to someone like Emily and she's just not narcissistic at all to me. This picture of Trish is the girl her family knows. From HTD and this, she seems close with them and pretty down to earth imo. Every season there's a girl that all the others seem to like. It's never the mean girl. We can't exactly "know" her from the show, but I don't see any major red flags with her.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

Wow they are really pushing Trish - arent they?  I think it's a Classic ploy to build a dilemma - where there isnt one. The only surprise for me will be when exactly Trisha goes.
I think she will not have a  LCD. So what will be the finale dilemma that must be resolved?
I'm guessing  Trish wont be gone by the end of tonight's episode, or folks would not tune in next week to see " who he chooses".  I bet she'll be let go early in the episode next week and then there will be one short LCD and a FRC, followed by an ATFR. That should fill one hour handily.

richmondrose wrote:"Who Do You Think Will Get the Final Rose?"

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Interesting. I hadn't seen that before. Funny, the girls that picked April were the ones that I liked better throughout the taping and always seemed drama free and more objective to me.

Sprite wrote:

richmondrose wrote:"Who Do You Think Will Get the Final Rose?"

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Interesting. I hadn't seen that before. Funny, the girls that picked April were the ones that I liked better throughout the taping and always seemed drama free and more objective to me.

Love that one of the reasons Lisa gives for picking Trish is "I've always liked Trish and HAVE NEVER HAD ANYTHING BAD to say about her" :vomit:

sophienette wrote:

HEA wrote:

well if Trisha said she found love, we could know immediately the outcome no?

I think she can hardly say that and it is way possible that she found also friendship with the girls, they all do because they shared something unique that happens once in a lifetime.

I think people have a dreamed image of what a F1 should be but in reality the person remains human with qualities and defaults like everybody else. She is not a fairy princess. A F1 may be pictured that way with the edits but reality is another story. Plus each lead and each F1 are different or it would be totally boring.

It does not bother me that Trish is not perfect. Thanking her friends who voted for her is not sour grapes. I do not see negativity in that. It is for me a girl who is happy that her friends saw her as F1 and saw also her love story. For me, it shows a happy woman, not a sour grapes. I guess people see what they want to see and that is fine, we will all know for sure next week

I see it this way... she could have stopped at "This was just the sweetest video to watch. I love my bettes! "... the rest was unnecessary!
Plus the posting of it in the first place is just weird (some would say mean/petty) whether she is F1, F1 broken up or F2... just not nice any way

could have, should have... it is all a matter of perception. someone can take it as a personal offense, some like me do not see the negativity in it. What is not nice really? april posting a pic of bianca and claiming she had a special date with her and make it extra super special... some could say that she was pity to rub Trish's face if she is F1... some will not see much into it...

same with the SM. It is always dangerous in my book to assume what was behind the words of someone we do not know in real. A novel could be written out of nothing IMO

(sorry forgot to clic on quote, this is a response to AAL pointing me it is bianca that took the selfie)

ah. but she "could" have said no don't do that
see... it is all a matter of perception

HEA wrote:(sorry forgot to clic on quote, this is a response to AAL pointing me it is bianca that took the selfie)

ah. but she "could" have said no don't do that
see... it is all a matter of perception

You're comparing apples and oranges here. It was Bianca's idea to take and post the picture of the two of them... it was Trish's idea to post the picture saying that more girls liked her than April and she herself made the comment. There's no rationale IMO to saying it's the same thing.

One can see both sides to something and perception is personal yes, however, am having difficulty in seeing a positive reason that Trish would like a post stating that getting dumped by Tim is actually dodging a bullet?

imo, when someone says that they dodged a bullet that is a negative connotation. So, using this line of logic, dodging a bullet in this scenario means being thankful NOT to be with Tim. Again, where is the positive reason for liking this?

AllAboutLove wrote:One can see both sides to something and perception is personal yes, however, am having difficulty in seeing a positive reason that Trish would like a post stating that getting dumped by Tim is actually dodging a bullet?

imo, when someone says that they dodged a bullet that is a negative connotation. So, using this line of logic, dodging a bullet in this scenario means being thankful NOT to be with Tim. Again, where is the positive reason for liking this?  

for me to thank a group of girlfriend who saw a love story with tim IS positive. I see an impulsive woman happy that her friends saw her love story on tv. *I* see first degree thank you, not a 2nd or 3rd degree with ugly bad nasty mean intention behind this simple thank you. again. perception

dodging a bullet could be a friend support to a girl that was pictured the villain all season when in reality she was not that bad. We all saw an edited version of Lisa, yes she did an enormous mistake to kiss that waiters and it was disrespectful but if I had a friend who made a big mistake, would I not try to show her that I am still her friend even if I disagree what she did?. again. perception

everything has 2 faces to see a coin. For me, unless I have all the facts and I know personally the person and understand why she did it, i will not judge. Everyone is making mistake and it is so very easy to do then on SM.

I guess we will have to agree to disagree.

AllAboutLove wrote:One can see both sides to something and perception is personal yes, however, am having difficulty in seeing a positive reason that Trish would like a post stating that getting dumped by Tim is actually dodging a bullet?

imo, when someone says that they dodged a bullet that is a negative connotation. So, using this line of logic, dodging a bullet in this scenario means being thankful NOT to be with Tim. Again, where is the positive reason for liking this?  

IMO In Lisa's mind she felt she dodged a bullet. By liking Lisa's comment, I don't think that Trisha was necessarily agreeing with the comment, but more about affirming Lisa's right to feel she had dodged a bullet.