Re: Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Fan Forum - General Discussion Thread #2

[GuardianAngel]

Well to have a baseball team of kids like Josh wants, I would think he better start with a younger woman.

I have to disagree with this for all those who are older than 30 married and are still having children. A relative of mine will be 39yrs old next month and she is due with her 3rd in the summer. He is still young. I hope he enjoys his single status and just goes with the flow. Sometimes when you're not looking, that's when the right one comes along.

[aviej]

These next couple weeks are just going to be so awkward. Running into each other at the gym, grocery etc. would be hard.

[Guest]

I'm 36 and just had my 4th 5 days after Josh and Andi got engaged I'd have 5 more if my hubby would let me. Women are having babies older now, I would expect Emily Maynard to have a few, especially if she looks as beautiful as she does now

[laurentx]

I wonder if they were planning to quietly separate and wait to issue a statement, but then RS upset the apple cart when he posted in his blog the "don't shoot the messenger" comments earlier this week about their imminent breakup.

Otherwise, how embarrassing is it to make a major appearance together, making the comments she made, only to split 3 days later?

[eirekay]

I'm 36 and just had my 4th 5 days after Josh and Andi got engaged I'd have 5 more if my hubby would let me. Women are having babies older now, I would expect Emily Maynard to have a few, especially if she looks as beautiful as she does now

I too had #4 at age 36! IMO, having a successful marriage and raising happy children has little to do with beauty and more to do with values.

[mamahamme]

I totally believe u can have children probably at whatever age that its possible to. My sister had her first at 37. She tried for years and was getting so upset and then with lots of prayer GOD gave her what she wanted so bad. Now she has 2 girls. I'm just thinking Josh might not want somebody older than him. But I'm not him so he will do what's best for him. I just don't think it will be soon.only my opinion

[AnandaMarie]

I am basing it on the following:
We started a fan thread for both Josh and Andi separately yesterday after the break up.
Josh: link
He has 20 posts and 809 views.
Andi: link
She has 0 posts and 114 views.

I provided the links above should anyone be interested.

I must admit, in a couple months I believe I too would stop following Andi on Twitter and IG. I just want to see how this relationship would pan out first. If they get back together I'd add her back on. But as of right now, I'm more interested in Josh's future, to be totally honest.

I will continue following them both because I love Andi just as much as Josh but everyone is entitled to their own opinions.

[GuardianAngel]

I wonder if they were planning to quietly separate and wait to issue a statement, but then RS upset the apple cart when he posted in his blog the "don't shoot the messenger" comments earlier this week about their imminent breakup.

Otherwise, how embarrassing is it to make a major appearance together, making the comments she made, only to split 3 days later?

I would think the statement was already prepared and it was a matter of authorizing it be released. Being under contract they would have had to coordinate the time with TPTB as well. JMHO

[Guest]

I don't think RS upset anything, we had all basically chalked it up to speculation and unless you read his blog you wouldn't have picked up on it, he wasn't tweeting it or anything

Any update on Josh going to Advocare tonight? I think regardless of his personal issues that he would be the type of person to still show up because he made a commitment to it. I would guess that if he does go MM and Chad will be there. He might do his speech then bail quickly. Anyone here going?

[AnandaMarie]

I don't know why and could very well be wrong of course but I have a feeling this couple will try one more time. No idea if we will even know about it but if only for pride sake, I can see them working on it once more. Josh, I know, never planned to propose twice and Andi IMO would now feel like a failure that she couldn't make the relationship work. I could see them letting the dust settle and start talking again. They would love to say they got over the hurdle and made it work in the end.

You have no idea how much I hope and pray that you a right. I would just love to see them try this again because I will always believe that they were meant to be together.
Maybe its easier for some of you guys to get over this because you have had life and relationship experience that I don't. Maybe I'm too naïve and have a too idealistic view of relationship but I cant help it and I just want to see them happy and in love with each other.

[AnandaMarie]

I don't know why and could very well be wrong of course but I have a feeling this couple will try one more time. No idea if we will even know about it but if only for pride sake, I can see them working on it once more. Josh, I know, never planned to propose twice and Andi IMO would now feel like a failure that she couldn't make the relationship work. I could see them letting the dust settle and start talking again. They would love to say they got over the hurdle and made it work in the end.

I would love to see that happen.  Their chemistry  and the love for each other  was undeniable.  Maybe they will both realize the mistakes they made and work them out.  Sometimes time apart works wonders when you see what you have lost.  They each lost their best friend (each other)  in all of this also.

Yes. I agree 100% and really hope that you're right and they give it another try.

[Guest]

elan gale (@theyearofelan) tweeted at 4:19pm - 9 Jan 15:

elan gale ‏@theyearofelan 23m23 minutes ago
A fun thing you can do with your opinion is scream it into a garbage can where it belongs

[Sponsored content]