Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 10 - MTP-LCD-FRC- July 28/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

stuckinsc wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

pander3575 wrote:I don't have a problem with ATFR being live what I have a problem with is during the showing of the dates and proposal they talk to the audience and former cast members i.e. Sean/Cat/JP/Ash/Jason/Molly etc.  Sorry I don't want to hear what any of them say and I doubt the general public doesn't either.

IA - I love seeing the previous couples, but don't necessarily want to hear what they have to say during the live portion. I don't mind reading later on SM, but at that point in time it should be all about the lead and the F1. IMO Their comments can have a huge effect on viewers opinions.

I'd like for them to focus more time on the couple, show some bloopers, discuss some fun facts, as well as their plans for the future etc.

The worst was the JPG AFTR, when it became a battle between Sean and Cat and JPG.  I found it obnoxious.  It changed my perspective on Sean and Cat quite a bit.

Me too! I still like Sean and Cat but the way they treated both JPG and Nikki REALLY brought my opinion of them down A LOT!! They were my favorite couple, along with JP and Ashley, but now I still like them but not nearly as much!

Please no past contestants at ATFR! Or, just have them sit there and MAYBE a question or two about who they think will be f1. But after the last train wreck, I'm not interested in what they have to say about the final couple or their 'raw' reactions to what they're seeing.   

George1218 wrote:

stuckinsc wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

IA - I love seeing the previous couples, but don't necessarily want to hear what they have to say during the live portion. I don't mind reading later on SM, but at that point in time it should be all about the lead and the F1. IMO Their comments can have a huge effect on viewers opinions.

I'd like for them to focus more time on the couple, show some bloopers, discuss some fun facts, as well as their plans for the future etc.

The worst was the JPG AFTR, when it became a battle between Sean and Cat and JPG.  I found it obnoxious.  It changed my perspective on Sean and Cat quite a bit.

Me too!  I still like Sean and Cat but the way they treated both JPG and Nikki REALLY brought my opinion of them down A LOT!!  They were my favorite couple, along with JP and Ashley, but now I still like them but not nearly as much!

Awwww, I love Seancat and they were just stating their opinion when asked a question(s). Not sure why we are discussing Seancat and JuanPablo but, imo, Juan was very disrespectful. Maybe he had his reasons and it is his right, but that is how it came off to most viewers. Not saying his feelings were right or wrong, but everyone has a right to react the way they feel too.

Wish all couples the best though. ;) Hopefully TPTB focus on Andi and Josh and the happy couple and minimize the drama this time. (Wishful thinking!) ;)

If I had to guess, there will most likely be past contestants/couples in attendance. But generally, if TPTB believe/like the couple, those past ones are asked questions minimally and usually not during the ATFR portion. Since I believe TPTB is very much pro Josh/Andi as a couple, I think the input from the past contestants will be very little. Last season they needed it to distract from the trainwreck and this season they don't.

umngirl wrote:If I had to guess, there will most likely be past contestants/couples in attendance. But generally, if TPTB believe/like the couple, those past ones are asked questions minimally and usually not during the ATFR portion. Since I believe TPTB is very much pro Josh/Andi as a couple, I think the input from the past contestants will be very little. Last season they needed it to distract from the trainwreck and this season they don't.

ITA. Their edits have been pretty great so I think tptb are very on board with Jodi. Plus, Jodi did what they needed to do for the show, happy, engaged in DR and still happy by atfr, if the sm and interviews are any indication. If other people show up, it'll be to promote BIP or for SeanCat to basically give their approval and invite them into their clique and double date

^And I'd totally be down for that! Lol

Just curious on the 1% chance that Nick is F1, is everyone still on board with the former couples at the AFTR?

Can you imagine if it is Josh who has been pursuing Andi because he cannot believe she would take Nick over him? That would be an interesting turn of events at the atfr

remockered wrote:Can you imagine if it is Josh who has been pursuing Andi because he cannot believe she would take Nick over him?  That would be an interesting turn of events at the atfr

It SURE would be.   

To add to the conversation ... and taking from my post on Nick's fan thread in response to the US weekly article:

OK, WOW – very interesting tidbit in the article. It’s says the F2 tried to change Andi’s mind postfinale…. Was thinking about getting a ring, etc…

Well, based on the plane video then, F2 is NOT Nick since he says he didn’t try and change her mind.  

BUT it’s VERY interesting (smart TPTB)   then this is all described PERFECTLY on the plane video, so that the story falls in line with what actually happened, but not to WHO it actually happened.

The plane video is real and I believe Nick going after Andi at the MTA is either producer driven or made up.

stuckinsc wrote:Just curious on the 1% chance that Nick is F1, is everyone still on board with the former couples at the AFTR?

I just don't want a repeat of the awkward last ATFR with Nick or Josh as f1. If there are alumni, I dont imagine things getting weird since Josh and Andi are hopefully doing just fine. So I guess it's moot then, no counseling needed here