Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 8 - HTDs - Jul 07/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

Rolly wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

missjayne wrote:

okay well perhaps he's a victim of editing as well...I mean why else are he and Nick still friends.

Editing does play a big part.  For most of the season, Chris said nothing.  He was said to of not existed.  Then in two epis where we hear from him, he's now called a disturber....sheesh, the poor guy can't win.

Aunties_Love, ITA seems like Chris can't win...he is one of my favorites! :Woah-hoo: 

He's not getting the next bachelor edit. Maybe that will change tomorrow.

rosesrREd wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:I guess I have a hard time as I don't see this as a done deal for Josh.  I'd prefer to say the IF when dealing with who she may/may not be with and not the I know comment.  IMO, we don't REALLY KNOW yet.

I agree Aunties_Love, we do NOT KNOW.   I realize that Josh is the spoiled F1, but we all know RS has been wrong before.  It just seems as if anyone mentions clues that may indicate Nick or anyone else is the F1, they quickly get dismissed, however, the clues that Josh is F1 are rock solid.  As, we know Fleiss has outsmarted RS before, and it can happen again.

I agree. To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed. To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet. Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

Piper61 wrote:

soccermom333 wrote:

Piper61 wrote:^^^Love both of your posts, Sophie and judiful.  Well said.

I am reminded that it really does happen that one season you can be totally reading a different book than some members, and then the next season you are totally on the same page with them.  No need to be upset or anything with anyone because, and I do remind myself of this, it's what makes things interesting when we all don't agree and see things exactly the same way.  Eeeees ok!   

    Okay, this is why I need to read all the way through a page before I post!!!  I just said this.  LOL  

 :cutesmile!:   We are reading the same book, on the same page, at the same time!

This is really a lot of fun .Everybody sees people places , and things in their own unique ways, but it's always cool to be on the same page with people . I think the bickering between Andi and Josh is kind of cute...making up will be the most adorable . The edits made it seem worse than it was IMO .. I can't imagine her with anybody but him .. I love them together   

Aunties_Love wrote:

rosesrREd wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:I guess I have a hard time as I don't see this as a done deal for Josh.  I'd prefer to say the IF when dealing with who she may/may not be with and not the I know comment.  IMO, we don't REALLY KNOW yet.

I agree Aunties_Love, we do NOT KNOW.   I realize that Josh is the spoiled F1, but we all know RS has been wrong before.  It just seems as if anyone mentions clues that may indicate Nick or anyone else is the F1, they quickly get dismissed, however, the clues that Josh is F1 are rock solid.  As, we know Fleiss has outsmarted RS before, and it can happen again.

I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

nutty1 wrote:At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

Seriously Nutty, I said this almost a month ago....It's not just at this point it's been frustrating everything is a foiler if everything is a foiler for Josh where are the clues pointing to any of the rest of the guys?

luvlady345 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

rosesrREd wrote:


I agree Aunties_Love, we do NOT KNOW.   I realize that Josh is the spoiled F1, but we all know RS has been wrong before.  It just seems as if anyone mentions clues that may indicate Nick or anyone else is the F1, they quickly get dismissed, however, the clues that Josh is F1 are rock solid.  As, we know Fleiss has outsmarted RS before, and it can happen again.

I agree.  To me, the thought of another being the F1 is completely silenced as the "Josh is the F1" seems to be the only thing that can be said/believed.  To me, I just don't/can't believe it yet.  Something really seems off with this season to me and if I am wrong, then I will be wrong, but until then, I feel that keeping an open mind to the possibility of someone else being F1 will help me in the sleuthing of it.

  It's funny because every bit of the information pointing to Josh has been swept aside and dismissed RS spoiler, Snap chat, Josh coming back later than Nick, Josh traveling after the show has ended.. Every one of these clues have been said to be a foiler.....Like I said weeks earlier why is everything regarding Josh not evidence but a foiler...

I don't dislike Josh, and if he is the F1, then great. However, I don't understand how many posters can be so "definite" about it.

nutty1 wrote:At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

Hey not so, not so! 
I really don't have a favorite and I see equal things for 2. I stand on center line with my hands on my head and go:  :atomic:

luvlady345 wrote:

nutty1 wrote:At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

Seriously Nutty, I said this almost a month ago....It's not just at this point it's been frustrating everything is a foiler if everything is a foiler for Josh where are the clues pointing to any of the rest of the guys?

i think they are going by the romance they see building with andi and nick. that's my guess. i do see a relationship building there but i see fireworks with josh. andi seems like the type to really go for the passion, imo.

luvlady345 wrote:

nutty1 wrote:At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

Seriously Nutty, I said this almost a month ago....It's not just at this point it's been frustrating everything is a foiler if everything is a foiler for Josh where are the clues pointing to any of the rest of the guys?

I think the issue is there are so many things pointing to Josh and things falling into RS's lap……that is what are making people wonder. And no one will forget how RS was foiled once. I think that is the basis for people thinking others may be the F1. And no one will know for sure until July 28!

For me, it is better than just knowing and having nothing to look at and figure out. A big part of the fun of this show for me is figuring stuff like that out. I am a Nick fan, but I do look at all clues. I am prepared for the worst, but will be ecstatic if there is another KABOOM for RS!!

I have a funny feeling that both of the them  will say they love each other on FD away from any cameras.

I also wonder if Josh will ask permission from Hy to marry  Andi?  As much as he believes in family I think he will but will they show us?

Kashathediva wrote:

nutty1 wrote:At this point, I think many people are looking for clues for their favorite, dismissing the rest. JMO, of course.

Hey not so, not so! 
I really don't have a favorite and I see equal things for 2. I stand on center line with my hands on my head and go:  :atomic:

Kasha!!!    I said MANY, not all!!!