Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 5 - Jun 16/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

pander3575 wrote:Who is putting up posts on FB about romance with Josh and Andi?

The bachelorette

He probably found out from reading this site.

SLA44 wrote:He probably found out from reading this site.

Actually I think I remember some discussion to that effect for sure.

It was posted here first.

So RS conveniently made it his business to drop by (nearby).


Nobody said that there aren't various spies among us.  

Aunties_Love wrote:

Mirzam wrote:I don't agree with your logic. I think it is most likely the video is real.

Are you saying that about my post?  Just wondered.

What makes you think this is not real? This is Nick having a conversation with someone about what went down with Andi. How can someone set up something like that?. HE IS NOT F1. May be Josh isn't either, but he definitely is NOT F1.

Maggenzm wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

Mirzam wrote:I don't agree with your logic. I think it is most likely the video is real.

Are you saying that about my post?  Just wondered.

What makes you think this is not real? This is Nick having a conversation with someone about what went down with Andi. How can someone set up something like that?. HE IS NOT F1. May be Josh isn't either, but he definitely is NOT F1.

Please be careful in your wording. It's one thing to have an opinion but this is bordering on telling others what to think. None of us "know" anything at this point.

pbmax wrote:

pander3575 wrote:Who is putting up posts on FB about romance with Josh and Andi?

The bachelorette

I went to the bachelorette and the bachelorette fan by Wetpaint and didn't really see anything different than mentioning the show. Was it something earlier or another bachelorette on FB?

timfan wrote:I think something next episode with the lie detector causes Andi to start to question Josh all over again this is why I think he is f1 because she does not grill the other guys like she does him I think it is because she really wants Josh to be the one but she is scared of getting hurt

I think its because she don't know if he's there for her or the competition. She can clearly see he competitive, she's already discussed it with one of the basketball player.

pbmax wrote:

timfan wrote:I think something next episode with the lie detector causes Andi to start to question Josh all over again this is why I think he is f1 because she does not grill the other guys like she does him I think it is because she really wants Josh to be the one but she is scared of getting hurt

I think its because she don't know if he's there for her or the competition. She can clearly see he competitive, she's already discussed it with one of the basketball player.

Would'nt just be easier to just send him home if she can't trust him? She has NIck, Marcus and Chris, right?   She wants Josh bad. Listen to the words in that song, she knows she has something amazing with Josh that's why she is grilling him like that.

I'm gonna just say, there's a lot this season that make me go hmmmmm. That got me puzzled and not quite making sense to me. Josh's edit from the get go, too many pi's that reminds me of F2 or mot guys. Then they show him and JJ bullying Andrew with his I'm a grown azz man comment. Then we see his anger every week on top of his aggressive competitive behavior in the game Andi noticed and spoke of.His interaction with Andi reminds me of Chantal and Brad. His edit is kind of like Clare last season.I just can't see where they are going. like Alley season I couldn't see her not choosing someone, when I saw how she was with Roberto and nothing but acting with Frank. It just didn't make sense to me. After watching the preview and seeing she is questioning Josh, it isn't making sense.

Maggenzm wrote:

pbmax wrote:

timfan wrote:I think something next episode with the lie detector causes Andi to start to question Josh all over again this is why I think he is f1 because she does not grill the other guys like she does him I think it is because she really wants Josh to be the one but she is scared of getting hurt

I think its because she don't know if he's there for her or the competition. She can clearly see he competitive, she's already discussed it with one of the basketball player.

Would'nt just be easier to just send him home if she can't trust him? She has NIck, Marcus and Chris, right?   She wants Josh bad. Listen to the words in that song, she knows she has something amazing with Josh that's why she is grilling him like that.

And why wouldn't she take the time to find out, instead of sending him home right off the bat cause she still got Nick, Marcus and Chris there.

Maggenzm wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

nd4reality wrote:I would think 5 million dollars was his context.

Something about that video doesn't ring true to me.  LIke it was a complete setup from the word go.

Aunties, this is Nick, his voice, to me it seems he really didn't care.

I do realize he's in the video, I just think the video is a setup is all.

pbmax wrote:I'm gonna just say, there's a lot this season that make me go hmmmmm. That got me puzzled and not quite making sense to me. Josh's edit from the get go, too many pi's that reminds me of F2 or mot guys. Then they show him and JJ bullying Andrew with his I'm a grown azz man comment. Then we see his anger every week on top of his aggressive competitive behavior in the game Andi noticed and spoke of.His interaction with Andi reminds me of Chantal and Brad. His edit is kind of like Clare last season.I just can't see where they are going. like Alley season I couldn't see her not choosing someone, when I saw how she was with Roberto and nothing but acting with Frank. It just didn't make sense to me. After watching the preview and seeing she is questioning Josh, it isn't making sense.

I agree, there are a lot of things this season that really aren't adding up...from the edit to the SM to the video.  Stuff isn't backing each other up PROPERLY.  That video looks like it's made up.  Before it gets started, yes I do understand that it is Nick in the video, but whose to say that the producers didn't put him up to it to throw everyone off.  All the clues on SM by the LEAD which isn't normal...almost like the Lead isn't on twitter but the producers are contorlling it.  I am sorry, but I can't find myself following the concept that Josh is F1.  Too many what if's that just don't line up with anything right now.


Edited to add:

BTW, who would antagonize and verbally assault Chris when he gets the rose on the group date? Doubt it would be Marcus, Nick isn't on the date, doubt it would be Dylan, so who does that leave??? Josh??