Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 5 - Jun 16/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

foodie wrote:

Kaltie wrote:Andi liking all sorts of pics on Instagram with Josh and her #somebodydoesntgiveashit

  

Well she is drinking tonight!   

soccermom333 wrote:

foodie wrote:

Kaltie wrote:Andi liking all sorts of pics on Instagram with Josh and her #somebodydoesntgiveashit

  

Well she is drinking tonight!    

Does anyone else get the feeling that through social media Andi is slyly giving TPTB the bird?   

black_tears wrote:

soccermom333 wrote:

foodie wrote:

Kaltie wrote:Andi liking all sorts of pics on Instagram with Josh and her #somebodydoesntgiveashit

  

Well she is drinking tonight!    

Does anyone else get the feeling that through social media Andi is slyly giving TPTB the bird?   

YUPPERS this season is ridic on signs isn't it

I thought I read where filming hadn't started yet for BIP. It obviously had to if they showed previews. Already seems like drama. Tonight's show really had me contemplating turning it off, quite boring. I liked Josh's date, but it was too short. Too much filler with the movie and the Josh Groban thing.

emad0722 wrote:

black_tears wrote:

soccermom333 wrote:

foodie wrote:

Kaltie wrote:Andi liking all sorts of pics on Instagram with Josh and her #somebodydoesntgiveashit

  

Well she is drinking tonight!    

Does anyone else get the feeling that through social media Andi is slyly giving TPTB the bird?   

YUPPERS this season is ridic on signs isn't it

She might as well tweet... JOSH AND ANDI lurvers for life at this rate.  

The threads are now open.  :WAVEY: 

soccermom333 wrote:

pbmax wrote:

ThankMeLater wrote:I think Marcus was Andi's real F2 after tonight. Nick went down a couple notches in my book.

He was F1 tonight. What I find interesting tonight was they trying to sell Josh as the F1 with CH asking Andi is she's falling in love. How can she be falling in love with Josh and she hasn't had a 1-1 yet at that point. Or they are trying to hide the real F1. Something isn't what it seem.  From tonight show I would say she's falling in love with Marcus. She had no problem being under him, while with Josh she's still at a distance. she's relaxed with Marcus and enjoying it. If she choose Josh, something happens and she settles and that's fine with me.

I don't think Andi will "settle" for anyone. IF she chooses Josh, it will be because she wants to choose him and feels they are the best chance for a real relationship outside the bubble.

I don't know how when she is questioning him. On that date she saw something that she didn't like about JuanP. He like talking about sports and himself too. From the look of the preview, she's still having some issue with him that she doesn't like.

pander3575 wrote:Funny because I thought when CH asked her about falling in love it was more about Nick than Josh at this stage.  

I think so too.

I still think it is Josh vs. Nick. Marcus is nice and hot and drama free and easy. But I still am not seeing the same emotional connection that she has with Nick or the physical connection with Josh. Also with both Nick and Josh she challenges them and they challenge her in different ways. I have a similar personality as Andi and I could never be with anyone who doesn't challenge me.

Josh again incredible chemistry, they act like a couple who has dated for a while. However I still feel like we haven't seen a real conversation between them that shows true depth. I feel if he is F1 his "obstacle" will be whether she can trust him and achieve an emotional/mental chemistry. I totally see him being the F1, but they NEED to progress their emotional connection.

Nick, I wasn't impressed with his demeanour on the group date however I feel as though it was edited to make it look a lot worse. I actually really enjoyed him and Andi's sit down conversation, I personally thought it was the most real conversation to date, like Josh, that conversation made them look like a real couple. Hated the poem, but I hate poems, I actually FF that part. It made me sad that she wasn't sure whether Nick was being real or not to her, I think he has genuine and sincere feelings, he just got too confident too fast, but I still feel like he isn't confident, its almost a defense mechanism.

The Cody vs. Nick drama was waaaaaaay overblown. I mean even when Cody was telling Andi "Nick is a great guy but... he mocked me by saying I am Mr. Thankful". Really that is what you are so offended by, that gets you that riled up to be in someone's face. I really like Cody I think he seems to be a great guy who is, sorry Cody, really "thankful" to be there. If this was one of the major "dramas" it shows you the type of guys she had.

The Marquel and Andrew drama, wow so impressed with Marquel, I can't even explain. I was also impressed with how Andrew received the conflict as well. Over all impressed with how the show and how the guys handled that very delicate issue.

Maggenzm wrote:

ThankMeLater wrote:I think Marcus was Andi's real F2 after tonight. Nick went down a couple notches in my book.

Right now, Marcus is F1 in her mind cus she has not found anything wrong with him yet. He received the 1st rose last and this wk at RC, that says a lot.

I am pretty sure producer's pick the rose order.

california90 wrote:what was the nick drama about?

Andi called Nick "salty" because he wasn't embracing the group date experience.  Nick says he doesn't like group dates. Andi says Nick should make the most of group dates since it's a chance for them to spend time together.  

In the evening portion of the group date Nick says he has the strongest connection with Andi.  The other guys are jealous.  They think Nick is smug and over confident.  

Cody is thankful to be part of the Bachelorette.  At some point when the guys were together Cody made a comment and Nick started mocking Cody for being thankful.  Cody didn't like it.  Nick apologized.

Nick was upset he didn't get the group date rose.  In a voice over Nick said "I no longer feel confident in my relationship with Andy"

sbolduc wrote:

pander3575 wrote:Funny because I thought when CH asked her about falling in love it was more about Nick than Josh at this stage.  

I think so too.

I still think it is Josh vs. Nick. Marcus is nice and hot and drama free and easy. But I still am not seeing the same emotional connection that she has with Nick or the physical connection with Josh. Also with both Nick and Josh she challenges them and they challenge her in different ways. I have a similar personality as Andi and I could never be with anyone who doesn't challenge me.

Josh again incredible chemistry, they act like a couple who has dated for a while. However I still feel like we haven't seen a real conversation between them that shows true depth. I feel if he is F1 his "obstacle" will be whether she can trust him and achieve an emotional/mental chemistry. I totally see him being the F1, but they NEED to progress their emotional connection.

Nick, I wasn't impressed with his demeanour on the group date however I feel as though it was edited to make it look a lot worse. I actually really enjoyed him and Andi's sit down conversation, I personally thought it was the most real conversation to date, like Josh, that conversation made them look like a real couple. Hated the poem, but I hate poems, I actually FF that part. It made me sad that she wasn't sure whether Nick was being real or not to her, I think he has genuine and sincere feelings, he just got too confident too fast, but I still feel like he isn't confident, its almost a defense mechanism.

The Cody vs. Nick drama was waaaaaaay overblown. I mean even when Cody was telling Andi "Nick is a great guy but... he mocked me by saying I am Mr. Thankful". Really that is what you are so offended by, that gets you that riled up to be in someone's face. I really like Cody I think he seems to be a great guy who is, sorry Cody, really "thankful" to be there. If this was one of the major "dramas" it shows you the type of guys she had.

The Marquel and Andrew drama, wow so impressed with Marquel, I can't even explain. I was also impressed with how Andrew received the conflict as well. Over all impressed with how the show and how the guys handled that very delicate issue.

Great post. I agree with everything and there is no real villain this season. They are ALL nice guys, so TPTB have to manufacture some drama. Andi got very lucky with this group.

sbolduc wrote:

Maggenzm wrote:

ThankMeLater wrote:I think Marcus was Andi's real F2 after tonight. Nick went down a couple notches in my book.

Right now, Marcus is F1 in her mind cus she has not found anything wrong with him yet. He received the 1st rose last and this wk at RC, that says a lot.

I am pretty sure producer's pick the rose order.

I'm sure not always.