Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 3 - Sun - Jun 1/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

Sophie , you don't believe that Josh is F1? Do you have sources telling you something else?

sophienette wrote:

nannymargie wrote:

sophienette wrote:Even if he is her F1, I like to analyse as I go along, to get a feel of what the relationship might be like post-show

Please share your thoughts when you are done.  I am very interested in what you think.

Did you happen to get any information on who the F1 is?

Nothing! I was told "not to believe RS 100%"... but then again, that doesnt take a brain surgeon considering how well he did on the F4 for Des!
Nohing else!

I am not believing 100% and waiting to see what the wonderful sluethers come up with. But I do like her and Josh together.

 Last season with Brooks most definitely causes one pause to not believe the spoilers 100%. I kept waiting throughout the entire 2nd part of the finale for Brooks to return.   

Piper61 wrote: Last season with Brooks most definitely causes one pause to not believe the spoilers 100%.  I kept waiting throughout the entire 2nd part of the finale for Brooks to return.    

I was hanging with you waiting for the same thing. I am hoping Josh is F1 but I am a little more cautious and waiting for more clues. Even though I think Nick's video is a good one.

carnegiesmith2014 wrote:Sophie , you don't believe that Josh is F1? Do you have sources telling you something else?

As stated above, I was not given anything. Only not too believe RS 100% (it might refer o F1, F4, locations... I have no clue).

And FYI based on what I see on screen and my own sleuthing of the various characters, I DO believe Josh is F1. If only because I feel "it" between them, and cant see her with anyone else. But that might yet change!
And I am staying opened!

sophienette wrote:And FYI based on what I see on screen and my own sleuthing of the various characters, I DO believe Josh is F1. If only because I feel "it" between them, and cant see her with anyone else. But that might yet change!
And I am staying opened!

Another thing that made me think that is that Josh is her type. Plus he asked not to stereotype him and told her he's more than that. So I think it put her mind more at ease and she is starting to fall for him.

What does it mean not to believe the spoilers 100%? Should we believe 99%, 75% 50% and so on. If it is 99% I think we are OK as RS had the boys moving to Santa Barbara and they didn't. He also originally didn't have Josh on the basketball date but had 2 Nicks. So the original spoilers have been fairly spot on but not 100%. Because of when the videotape of Nick was taken and no face time between Andi and Chris in the third episode in my humble opinion I think F-1 is between Josh and Marcus. If we get confirmation that Marcus is on BIP then it has to be Josh or no one.

nannymargie wrote:

Piper61 wrote: Last season with Brooks most definitely causes one pause to not believe the spoilers 100%.  I kept waiting throughout the entire 2nd part of the finale for Brooks to return.    

I was hanging with you waiting for the same thing.  I am hoping Josh is F1 but I am a little more cautious and waiting for more clues.  Even though I think Nick's video is a good one.

I agree. I can't wait for Josh's 1-on-1 date, and then as we get further into the season, seeing what extended previews we get that can be sleuthed to support or contradict Josh as F1.

sophienette wrote:

carnegiesmith2014 wrote:Sophie , you don't believe that Josh is F1? Do you have sources telling you something else?

As stated above, I was not given anything. Only not too believe RS 100% (it might refer o F1, F4, locations... I have no clue).

It might be the line up of he F4's.

Rosepetal wrote:What does it mean not to believe the spoilers 100%? Should we believe 99%, 75% 50% and so on. If it is 99% I think we are OK as RS had the boys moving to Santa Barbara and they didn't. He also originally didn't have Josh on the basketball date but had 2 Nicks. So the original spoilers have been fairly spot on but not 100%. Because of when the videotape of Nick was taken and no face time between Andi and Chris in the third episode in my humble opinion I think F-1 is between Josh and Marcus. If we get confirmation that Marcus is on BIP then it has to be Josh or no one.

For me too, I find it unbelievable that he's only f4, not f2. It must be because tptb wanted Chris for the lead and/or Andi didn't want to rile Josh up by leaving his real competition in and going to the fs with him.

Alanna wrote:

Rosepetal wrote:What does it mean not to believe the spoilers 100%? Should we believe 99%, 75% 50% and so on. If it is 99% I think we are OK as RS had the boys moving to Santa Barbara and they didn't. He also originally didn't have Josh on the basketball date but had 2 Nicks. So the original spoilers have been fairly spot on but not 100%. Because of when the videotape of Nick was taken and no face time between Andi and Chris in the third episode in my humble opinion I think F-1 is between Josh and Marcus. If we get confirmation that Marcus is on BIP then it has to be Josh or no one.

For me too, I find it unbelievable that he's only f4, not f2. It must be because tptb wanted Chris for the lead and/or Andi didn't want to rile Josh up by leaving his real competition in and going to the fs with him.

Makes sense. Maybe after HTD Andi was certain Josh was F1 and Marcus wasn't--the Murray family gelled with her--so she eliminated Josh's only real competition before the FS. Easier for her to keep Chris and Nick at arm's length (if she wanted to).