Bachelorette 10 - Andi Dorfman - Episode 1 Premiere - May 19/14 *Spoilers & Sleuthing* - Discussion

FLChica wrote:

pavalygurl wrote:Andi told Chris at one point last night that she was open to the possibility of moving or she would not have come on the show.  Also said if she didn't want to move she could have just dated a guy from Atlanta.

Listening to Me-andi (thanks Kasha!) reminded of an old Rod Stewart song that said "her ad-libbed lines were well rehearsed".  This Bachelorette performed in the courtroom on a regular basis and the experience will serve her well.

Credit for MeAndi goes to Bet2win! She coined that from the hissy fit ala Meanna(Deanna). Credit for the Me-osh and Me-andi portmanteau to MEME--all mine!

soccermom333 wrote:Unless something drastically changes, I believe Josh is probably the final one.   It is obvious that Andi is taken with Josh.  She seemed attracted to Marcus--physical edit--and Chris.  Not sure Andi would want to be a "farmers wife" though.  IMO, the exchanged between Nick and Andi seemed off.  I guess I need to see more.  

We have a major spoiler, but now the sleuthers need the "proof."  That is what I will be looking for in screencaps and edit.  One thing I noticed  during Josh and Andi's conversation was Josh mentioning his mother.  TPTB left that in for a reason.  Final ones in the past have done this.  Ed, Chris, and I know there are others.  Big clue imo.      

Let the sleuthing begin.  

I am wondering why the only thing that is attributed to Chris is being a farmer..what happened to the real estate agent and business man part of him? I think there is so much more than just the simple classification of farmer.

nd4reality wrote:Marcus mentioned his mother also so I don't count the mother thing as a clue at all.

Chris talked about his mom too, so think that's debunk now.

Aunties_Love wrote:

nd4reality wrote:Marcus mentioned his mother also so I don't count the mother thing as a clue at all.

Chris talked about his mom too, so think that's debunk now.

Hahaha, I guess you are right. Back to sleuthing. And Auntie, blame tptb on Chris's "farmer" attribute. They are so shallow, but that is the nature of the show. ;)

SLA44 wrote:

pavalygurl wrote:Andi told Chris at one point last night that she was open to the possibility of moving or she would not have come on the show.  Also said if she didn't want to move she could have just dated a guy from Atlanta.

  If RS' spoiler is correct that is exactly what she is doing - dating a guy from Atlanta.

For some reason, this made me think of her Q&A when asked if she'll go back to her job. Her reply was "for now". The first reaction is she's looking for something outside of her current profession, OTOH, if she chose someone other than Josh, then she might be looking at moving.

FLChica wrote:
Listening to Me-andi (thanks Kasha!) reminded of an old Rod Stewart song that said "her ad-libbed lines were well rehearsed".  This Bachelorette performed in the courtroom on a regular basis and the experience will serve her well.

OT I'm the lucky girl going to see my boyfriend May 31st in Buffalo! Because seeing him 20+ times in concert isn't enough!!! :sweetheart:

Sarah_XV wrote:The video on Hulu (http://www.hulu.com/watch/638282 ) pretty much says he lives on the farm.

But he does more than just being on the farm. I think that should be brought to the table too versus just saying farmer.

soccermom333 wrote:

Aunties_Love wrote:

nd4reality wrote:Marcus mentioned his mother also so I don't count the mother thing as a clue at all.

Chris talked about his mom too, so think that's debunk now.

Hahaha, I guess you are right.  Back to sleuthing.  And Auntie, blame tptb on Chris's "farmer" attribute.  They are so shallow, but that is the nature of the show.  ;)

Maybe so, but IMO, I had a grandfather as a "farmer", one of the best men I have ever known. Full of strength and fortitude, caring nature and all around great guy. To be labelled as a simple farmer without looking at the rest of the guy and who he is as a man I think can be up to us all. Just because the bach crew named him that, doesn't mean that's all he is, IMO!

Mustang19 wrote:

murasaki1393 wrote:

Litta123 wrote:mura, my impression was that Josh and Andi had NOT met before. I found Josh to be nervous, talking a mile a minute. It felt a little awkward to me, frankly, but I'll watch again and might change my mind. Right now, I'm leaning towards Andi knew who he was...perhaps even Hy/mom/sister tipped her off he was coming. Certainly, Josh knew who she was and knew a lot about her. I wouldn't call it a set up though.

Now where's my cake?

Ha!... Thanks for your thorough take, Litta!! Here is a special one 4 you !! :27:  

I seriously Wonder whether Andi was referring to Josh's MnG when she mentioned about totally believing love at the First sight  on media  . I mean..her itm... 'Pegged it...Nailed it!! ' can it be more obvious??? . I cant recall any of former lead saying that line in an ITM about a hypothetical F1 before... Not even Ali on Roberto who admittedly having an instant attraction . SCMIIW

Man!! If thats the case,  I feel for Nick .Poor guy. Plus the video fiasco..i just Hope he is doing alright

ETA. Btw thanks for y'all responses on my curio whether  JoDi have met before . Looks like the majority here think they seem havent met prior to this season

She looked pretty taken with Josh right off the bat. I can see the AFR special now where the Nick asks her "when did you know it wasn't me?", and Andi is going to say (as they usually do) "not until that day". Poor Nick.

Ditto, mustang..the F2 ATFR/grilling is always so cringeworthy for me. Tbh I'm glad Clare passed it last season. I for once dying to see a lead tell us the truth!!.

So.. I made up an imaginary horrible NickAndi ATFR (assuming he is the F2) in my wild imagination

Nick : when did you know it wasn't me??

Andi : the moment when Josh stepped out of the limo, of course!. He is my sport celebrity crush, ya know..:eyesigh: 
Hello??? He is a Murray for heaven's sake...:halo:  Not to mention handsome, has a killer smile, hawt, and sweet  among his other endless great qualities :Flirty: . For all the right reasons in the world I won't let Pops down  !!!  

Nick:        *his face turn to blue, red,purple,.. Basically to all of the colors in the world you can think of  *  

Btw, I would love Andi forever if she has the gut to do that..  

[quote="Alanna"]I don't see Andi leaving her parents and her community unless it was for some guy that really was her husband, father of children, but it would be a stretch I think. Josh being from Atlanta isn't so much convenient as it is just another reason he's the perfect fit. The sexy pool bantering where they're flirting like mad but saying nothing coherent was totally organic IMO. Most women have been there, done that and can probably relate, I could.[/quote]

Been there, done that as well. Just that Andi IMHO is flirting like mad and participating in sexy banter with a good number of the guys and I don't blame her a bit.

murasaki1393 wrote:

Mustang19 wrote:

murasaki1393 wrote:

Litta123 wrote:mura, my impression was that Josh and Andi had NOT met before. I found Josh to be nervous, talking a mile a minute. It felt a little awkward to me, frankly, but I'll watch again and might change my mind. Right now, I'm leaning towards Andi knew who he was...perhaps even Hy/mom/sister tipped her off he was coming. Certainly, Josh knew who she was and knew a lot about her. I wouldn't call it a set up though.

Now where's my cake?

Ha!... Thanks for your thorough take, Litta!! Here is a special one 4 you !! :27:  

I seriously Wonder whether Andi was referring to Josh's MnG when she mentioned about totally believing love at the First sight  on media  . I mean..her itm... 'Pegged it...Nailed it!! ' can it be more obvious??? . I cant recall any of former lead saying that line in an ITM about a hypothetical F1 before... Not even Ali on Roberto who admittedly having an instant attraction . SCMIIW

Man!! If thats the case,  I feel for Nick .Poor guy. Plus the video fiasco..i just Hope he is doing alright

ETA. Btw thanks for y'all responses on my curio whether  JoDi have met before . Looks like the majority here think they seem havent met prior to this season

She looked pretty taken with Josh right off the bat. I can see the AFR special now where the Nick asks her "when did you know it wasn't me?", and Andi is going to say (as they usually do) "not until that day". Poor Nick.

Ditto, mustang..the F2 ATFR/grilling is always so cringeworthy for me. Tbh I'm glad Clare passed it last season. I for once dying to see a lead tell us the truth!!.

So.. I made up an imaginary horrible NickAndi ATFR (assuming he is the F2) in my wild imagination

Nick : when did you know it wasn't me??

Andi : the moment when Josh stepped out of the limo, of course!. He is my sport celebrity crush, ya know..:eyesigh: 
Hello??? He is a Murray for heaven's sake...:halo:  Not to mention handsome, has a killer smile, hawt, and sweet  among his other endless great qualities :Flirty: . For all the right reasons in the world I won't let Pops down  !!!  

Nick:        *his face turn to blue, red,purple,.. Basically to all of the colors in the world you can think of  *  

Btw, I would love Andi forever if she has the gut to do that..  

   Thank you for my laugh for the day! I would LOVE that scenario. I just don't even get why any rejectee asks that?!?!? IT'S PART OF THE SHOW, SOMEONE GETS DUMPED!

So what is Josh is the F2? Do you guys still see that same scenario. Josh is a little too over confident and self promoting for my taste levels! Seems there is a lot of confidence about the ending. I just don't know. Things aren't adding up for me.

Briitt..I agree we don't have all the puzzle pieces yet! For me I don't have the complete puzzle..