The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers*

I don't believe that Nick is that good of an actor to pull this off.
Seems authentic to me...

Rolly wrote:
believe any of this is true. Can you imagine how thrilled TPTB would be if RS falls for this and puts it out there as proof of the spoilers only to have in the end none of it true. There are too many things about this that don't make sense. You wouldn't film the conversation unless you knew who he was and if someone knew him from the show most people would say something to him. At least I would. Something is very fishy about this whole thing :yellowsleptic:  I think it was set up.

He is in his glory, IMO!

I just listened to it after I posted. There are two vid's. The first one, at 18 seconds, he actually starts laughing, and forgets what he was going to say.



I don't think he's on the phone, I think he's talking to someone, you can hear a guy ask him questions in the first 15 seconds. At one minute you can hear a woman talking. Why would he be telling his family, It was the guy with the girl? They would know. He also says "The guy changed his mind."

When he says 'The guy changed his mind' He is talking about Jason Mesnick.

GuardianAngel wrote:

Rolly wrote:
believe any of this is true. Can you imagine how thrilled TPTB would be if RS falls for this and puts it out there as proof of the spoilers only to have in the end none of it true. There are too many things about this that don't make sense. You wouldn't film the conversation unless you knew who he was and if someone knew him from the show most people would say something to him. At least I would. Something is very fishy about this whole thing :yellowsleptic:  I think it was set up.

He is in his glory, IMO!

I just listened to it after I posted. There are two vid's. The first one, at 18 seconds, he actually starts laughing, and forgets what he was going to say.



I don't think he's on the phone, I think he's talking to someone, you can hear a guy ask him questions in the first 15 seconds. At one minute you can hear a woman talking. Why would he be telling his family, It was the guy with the girl? They would know. He also says "The guy changed his mind."

thanks. These are the same things I heard. Unless they were on speaker phone and we could hear them too? Too much.

Sarah_XV wrote:When he says 'The guy changed his mind' He is talking about Jason Mesnick.

How do we know this?

I don't believe it was fake. I agree with GA that it could have been anything and it did not prove Josh was F1. I also don't believe that Nick would put his integrity on the line for anybody.

GuardianAngel wrote:

Sarah_XV wrote:When he says 'The guy changed his mind' He is talking about Jason Mesnick.

How do we know this?

Exactly, GA! He never mentions any names in the second clip.

I don't know---to be it sounds like the woman and man are just voices in the background of a noise flight. I definitely agree though that it seems weird that the person sitting behind him would even know who he is (unless like somebody else pointed out, maybe he had been very clear what he was talking about before the videos started).

How soon do they get their phones back after they are eliminated? Do the handlers travel with them and give them back once the person is on their final flight home?

^^... He was talking about Jason - (the guy)...

He mentioned that Andi seemed to have changed her mind last minute.. Presumably, the person on the phone asked him whether there is still a chance that she would change her mind again and Nick then brought Jason up as an example... "they are still married"..etc..

I am sorry, but IMO, he was clearly on the phone. He was probably talking a bit louder than necessary because he had is phone out front/or in his lap, while having his earphones plugged in.

GuardianAngel wrote:

Sarah_XV wrote:When he says 'The guy changed his mind' He is talking about Jason Mesnick.

How do we know this?

He says it happened once, it was a guy/girl, he changed his mind and they are still married. Then he says it won't happen here, she's very stubborn.

I assume he's talking about Jason dumping his F1 Melissa and then marrying his F2 Molly.

GuardianAngel wrote:

Sarah_XV wrote:When he says 'The guy changed his mind' He is talking about Jason Mesnick.

How do we know this?

That's very clear IMO.. He goes on talking about how it turned out well and that they are still married...etc.

quietpal wrote:

GuardianAngel wrote:

Sarah_XV wrote:When he says 'The guy changed his mind' He is talking about Jason Mesnick.

How do we know this?

Exactly, GA! He never mentions any names in the second clip.

It's pretty obvious, no?

He says...
"I didn’t try to change her mind, I’m just like, ‘I disagree'.......But she won’t…it’s ok. …it’s actually happened once….ummmm, it was the guy with the girl. The guy changed his mind. They’re actually (inaudible) and now they’re still married."