The Bachelorette 10 - *Final 1-F2* - Speculation * Sleuthing - Spoilers*

TY Chloe.. Just Hoping we can hear it from you before RS

   Sounds like sour grapes to me.   

Everyone needs to wait and see and watch the season unfold. We can judge for ourselves. The truth alsways reveals itself!!

I can totally see this scenario: Mama Murray notices Andi when JuanPa's season starts airing. Realizes Andi follows Aaron and thinks wow she'd be perfect for my son Josh. Gets in touch with Hy who also follows Aaron...and the two of them play matchmaker with Andi and Josh. Wouldn't surprise me in the least and it would certainly be doable given their physical proximity to each other!

tigertiz wrote:

atem wrote:

sanlee088 wrote:I'm going to guess maybe that Josh and Andi did know each other before the show? I don't know but the rumor has me intrigued. Lol

RS said that's not it as they didn't know each other.

It doesnt matter to me that RS says they didnt know one another.  He can say whatever he wants.  
If he's very sympathetic to/protective of  a contestant, it usually means they are a source of his spoilers.  

Yep. That's been RS's MO since Jason's season. He most definitely got his spoiler directly from someone close to Andi or her chosen one.

Thing is, as happened during Ali's season, if the spoiler came from Andi's camp, it is possible it's not the truth.

I don't recall ... how correct was RS's intel about Andi during Juan Pablo's season?

I came to the spoiler side late in the game and have been somewhat overwhelmed by all the information you guys have uncovered. I finally gave up trying to get caught up. It was just too much. As a consequence, I have formed no opinions to speak of regarding the F4. Hopefully, it will make me more objective sifting through the screen caps.

I ran hot and cold with Andi throughout JPG's season, but ended up liking her enough to want to root for her happy ending this season.

It really matters not to me whether there was a set up with Josh. If they truly are a couple and are willing to give it an honest go, I'll be happy for them. It sucks if Nick got hurt, but really, can you name one F2 that didn't walk away a little stung? It's the nature of the show.

Thanks, chloep, and the rest of you who found all this pre-show info. I'm eager to get to work on the screen caps to see if we can verify or disprove the spoilers. I have a feeling you guys are going to be much better at interpreting them since you can recognize the faces and know the locations. I may end up just posting the caps, but leaving the commenting to you guys in the know.

IrishGal wrote:I can totally see this scenario:  Mama Murray notices Andi when JuanPa's season starts airing.  Realizes Andi follows Aaron and thinks wow she'd be perfect for my son Josh. Gets in touch with Hy who also follows Aaron...and the two of them play matchmaker with Andi and Josh.  Wouldn't surprise me in the least and it would certainly be doable given their physical proximity to each other!

One of Emily's contestants had met her before at a party. No way TPTB didn't know this when casting him. The contestant didn't care for Emily, calling her a phony.   

FWIW Josh's cousin Signed him up 4 the show..i posted the Tweet from her on Josh's thread .

soccermom333 wrote:   Sounds like sour grapes to me.    

Everyone needs to wait and see and watch the season unfold.  We can judge for ourselves.   The truth alsways reveals itself!!  
     

  

Amberish wrote:

tigertiz wrote:

atem wrote:

sanlee088 wrote:I'm going to guess maybe that Josh and Andi did know each other before the show? I don't know but the rumor has me intrigued. Lol

RS said that's not it as they didn't know each other.

It doesnt matter to me that RS says they didnt know one another.  He can say whatever he wants.  
If he's very sympathetic to/protective of  a contestant, it usually means they are a source of his spoilers.  

Yep. That's been RS's MO since Jason's season. He most definitely got his spoiler directly from someone close to Andi or her chosen one.

Thing is, as happened during Ali's season, if the spoiler came from Andi's camp, it is possible it's not the truth.

I don't recall ... how correct was RS's intel about Andi during Juan Pablo's season?

This is certainly true and we saw it perfectly exemplified last season. RS swore up and down that Nikki was the bitch of the season which clearly wasn't true except from Clare's point of view. It was quite obvious his spoilers were coming from Clare's camp.

I don't know about sour grapes ... Travis had his backup in his backyard; Shayne was F1 at her first meeting with TPTB, etc.

Andi's tweet about Josh's brother before filming started, hmmmmm.

Andi never followed Aaron on twitter, Aaron only followed her. Really routing for Josh and Andi !!

If the rumor is true we maybe able to tell at least about the Nick part. The rumor reminds me of Emily with Sean. He was obviously not her F1, but she played like a good soldier and got the ILY out of him at the FS. She left his HTD so early. It was one of the many things I disliked about Emily.