Re: Sean & Catherine - The Bachelor 17 - Thread #2

by Ally Wed May 01, 2013 1:57 am

charriotoffire wrote:I have a nagging feeling that Howdie Doo will outlast Ingo and maybe Aly?

If that happens I will probably be the one who will kick a puppy. I think many puppies will be kicked.

I'd rather see Peanut campaign for his dad than Howdie Doo wiping his dirty hands off Catherine's clothes and pass it off

as sensual. Bachelor people should just need to stay within their obligatory 15 mins. Longer than that they develop

delusions of grandeur and IMsofamous-itis. I can't wait for him to get off my tv for good.

Everytime I see you post I want to cue the Vangelis music.

Love your posts

by cimcoe Wed May 01, 2013 2:39 am

charriotoffire wrote:I have a nagging feeling that Howdie Doo will outlast Ingo and maybe Aly?

If that happens I will probably be the one who will kick a puppy. I think many puppies will be kicked.

I'd rather see Peanut campaign for his dad than Howdie Doo wiping his dirty hands off Catherine's clothes and pass it off

as sensual. Bachelor people should just need to stay within their obligatory 15 mins. Longer than that they develop

delusions of grandeur and IMsofamous-itis. I can't wait for him to get off my tv for good.

If he beat both of them out that would be the weakest finalist I've ever seen, and that includes Bristol who while definitely weaker than some she beat out, I didn't think was so terrible as I've seen her described. Rob Kardashian got 2nd place in a season without strong competition and I was not happy with the gushing from the judges he got on his season either but looking back, he was a better dancer than Sean is too.

It really would be ridiculous for the finals to be anyone other than Kellie, Zendaya, Jacoby and Aly (since we are stuck with a 4 person one, which honestly I would rather it just be 3 of them). I love Ingo but I wouldn't want him beating out any of them for the finals either.

by umngirl Wed May 01, 2013 11:59 am

cimcoe wrote:
umngirl wrote:Quick change of subject, has the four person finale been confirmed or are we still getting a double elimination week at some point? TIA

I think it's a 4 person finale. Double elimination would have been week 8 (next week) and I think if they were having one they'd have announced it on tonight's ep.

Derek and Val were asked about their thoughts on a 4 couple finale and by their answers if sounds like there is one.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Personally I am not liking the idea at all. The winner wouldn't need as high of a percentage of the vote to win.

Thanks for answering. If that is their plan, they should just announce it. Like you, I'm not a fan.

by northernviewer Wed May 01, 2013 12:30 pm

I'm wondering if they're worried about Mark (judge fave due to his parents) and Ali not making F3 so that's why they're changing up the rules this year? Maybe they're worried about Jacoby taking that F3 spot away from him. Kelli and Zendaya are a given to make it to the end but it's a toss up between Ali and Jacoby and Jacoby prob has the bigger fan base.

by Ally Wed May 01, 2013 1:04 pm

Have most of the Olympians made the finals? Maybe thy want her in the finals to keep being a show that Olympians want to do. Plus the ratings are the lowest ever and she fits the young demographic they need. I know ppl always talk about the show being very manipulated but this season seems worse than ever.

by Guest Wed May 01, 2013 2:21 pm

One thing I have been observing is the over whelming support for Catherine. She seems to be liked everywhere she goes. Even in this thread it is all about Sean. Has there ever been a more positive response to the F1? If you read her twitter, there are few crazies there from time to time, but overall it seems like she is perhaps the most popular F1 in the history of the show. Can anyone remember another? Maybe Roberto?

by noobsleuth Wed May 01, 2013 2:35 pm

grace8136 wrote:One thing I have been observing is the over whelming support for Catherine. She seems to be liked everywhere she goes. Even in this thread it is all about Sean. Has there ever been a more positive response to the F1? If you read her twitter, there are few crazies there from time to time, but overall it seems like she is perhaps the most popular F1 in the history of the show. Can anyone remember another? Maybe Roberto?

I think Emily Maynard would be the most popular, with Jef Holm a close second. JMO

by Peppermom Wed May 01, 2013 2:39 pm

noobsleuth wrote:
grace8136 wrote:One thing I have been observing is the over whelming support for Catherine. She seems to be liked everywhere she goes. Even in this thread it is all about Sean. Has there ever been a more positive response to the F1? If you read her twitter, there are few crazies there from time to time, but overall it seems like she is perhaps the most popular F1 in the history of the show. Can anyone remember another? Maybe Roberto?

I think Emily Maynard would be the most popular, with Jef Holm a close second. JMO

I guess that would depend on how you actually "rate" their popularity. And whether you took into account how strong the dislike was for them as part of the equation.

by Guest Wed May 01, 2013 2:48 pm

noobsleuth wrote:
grace8136 wrote:One thing I have been observing is the over whelming support for Catherine. She seems to be liked everywhere she goes. Even in this thread it is all about Sean. Has there ever been a more positive response to the F1? If you read her twitter, there are few crazies there from time to time, but overall it seems like she is perhaps the most popular F1 in the history of the show. Can anyone remember another? Maybe Roberto?

I think Emily Maynard would be the most popular, with Jef Holm a close second. JMO

Emily and Jef were absolutely trashed by many on the ABC board. I won't list all the reasons that were discussed, but it was as bad as with Courtney and Vienna.

I see there was a new response: Yes, I am taking into account the negative response. To me, Cat seems to have the highest sum total.

by Kashathediva Wed May 01, 2013 4:25 pm

grace8136 wrote:
noobsleuth wrote:
grace8136 wrote:One thing I have been observing is the over whelming support for Catherine. She seems to be liked everywhere she goes. Even in this thread it is all about Sean. Has there ever been a more positive response to the F1? If you read her twitter, there are few crazies there from time to time, but overall it seems like she is perhaps the most popular F1 in the history of the show. Can anyone remember another? Maybe Roberto?

I think Emily Maynard would be the most popular, with Jef Holm a close second. JMO

Emily and Jef were absolutely trashed by many on the ABC board. I won't list all the reasons that were discussed, but it was as bad as with Courtney and Vienna.

I see there was a new response: Yes, I am taking into account the negative response. To me, Cat seems to have the highest sum total.

Deanna was such a popular F1 that Ellen Degeneres stood behind her and De eventually got her own 'ETTTE show the first of which was many, many seasons after it had primarily been done away with due to the Jen Scheft effect. (SWSNBN)
So, I would have to say De far outdid Cat as F1 fans. There were fan forums and clubs formed out of De Love. JMOAA.

by iamsam1008 Wed May 01, 2013 4:40 pm

gabriele wrote:i think sean has expired his 15 minutes of fame and the backlash has definitely started. that is how it works. build 'em up and tear 'em down. the entertainment industry is not for the faint of heart. if sean really said any of those things in that E! article then he isn't being very savvy. of course he'd never kick a puppy, and he has 2 dogs, but it's a tasteless expression and one that is foolish to use in hollywood. he's not in dallas anymore. as for expecting 9s--get real. maybe people from past seasons have had grossly inflated scores but who he needs to compare himself to are the other current contestants, not past ones. he has worked hard and he can be proud of that, but he needs to be realistic about his dancing ability. i did initially like sean but i will be glad when he is out of the limelight.

I find E! to be one of the most Unreliable sources of what some refer to as news. @ 1 point, they had proudly mentioned the Enquirer as their source..lol:) I believe his statement "kicking puppies" was about him, Val & the others kicking, beating up a puppy piñata on 1 DWTS clip they showed. Am glad I had seen that clip, but even if I didn't, Sean is an intelligent classy guy, I would still have given him the benefit of the doubt as opposed to quickly & unfairly judging him. He's got flaws, & so do we, but I appreciate the fact that he did express how he still sucks @ dancing even after long hours of practice. So how is he arrogant? His rumba w/ Peta was a huge improvement. I agree w/ Peta who was the one who expressed she had anticipated @ least one 9, not Sean but Peta said that OTRC interview. The judges on various seasons, did explain that their scoring is based on the dancing skills...i.e. Jennifer Grey's 8 was a 10 for Bristol when they were bashed for unfair scoring during that season. Having said that, I find him humbled by his no skills to dance & appreciates the hard work he's doing w/ Peta & the support he's getting from Cat. We all have our fav. If it's Ingo you believe is to be the better dancer, then vote for him but I see no need to bash @ Sean. Been supporting & rooting for Sean, I am happy he has improved, & if he continues to do that, I will be more than happy to keep voting for him.

by iamsam1008 Wed May 01, 2013 4:42 pm

I find E! to be one of the most Unreliable sources of what some refer to as news. @ 1 point, they had proudly mentioned the Enquirer as their source..lol:) I believe his statement "kicking puppies" was about him, Val & the others kicking, beating up a puppy piñata on 1 DWTS clip they showed. Am glad I had seen that clip, but even if I didn't, Sean is an intelligent classy guy, I would still have given him the benefit of the doubt as opposed to quickly & unfairly judging him. He's got flaws, & so do we, but I appreciate the fact that he did express how he still sucks @ dancing even after long hours of practice. So how is he arrogant? His rumba w/ Peta was a huge improvement. I agree w/ Peta who was the one who expressed she had anticipated @ least one 9, not Sean but Peta said that OTRC interview. The judges on various seasons, did explain that their scoring is based on the dancing skills...i.e. Jennifer Grey's 8 was a 10 for Bristol when they were bashed for unfair scoring during that season. Having said that, I find him humbled by his no skills to dance & appreciates the hard work he's doing w/ Peta & the support he's getting from Cat. We all have our fav. If it's Ingo you believe is to be the better dancer, then vote for him but I see no need to bash @ Sean. Been supporting & rooting for Sean, I am happy he has improved, & if he continues to do that, I will be more than happy to keep voting for him. .

iamsam1008
Posts: 17
Join date: 2013-04-23

View user profile Send private message

by Sponsored content