Episode 8 (HTD's) - 2/18 - Bachelor 17 - Discussion - Spoilers

julychild wrote:

Jeepers wrote:There are also flowers for Ashlee's parents .. Not sure about Dez And Lindsey

There is small gift bag in the car scene with Lindsay, I assume this is the gift he gave her mom. Meanwhile, did anyone else notice that Ashlee's mom left her flowers on the ground beside the table, while they were having lunch/dinner? I thought that was strange, maybe they never went inside the house during filming.

I sure don't think Lindsay could have gotten any closer to Sean in the car than she did. That would have been kinda invading my space. LOL

LoveDovez wrote:

julychild wrote:

Jeepers wrote:There are also flowers for Ashlee's parents .. Not sure about Dez And Lindsey

There is small gift bag in the car scene with Lindsay, I assume this is the gift he gave her mom. Meanwhile, did anyone else notice that Ashlee's mom left her flowers on the ground beside the table, while they were having lunch/dinner? I thought that was strange, maybe they never went inside the house during filming.

I sure don't think Lindsay could have gotten any closer to Sean in the car than she did. That would have been kinda invading my space. LOL

She's like a little kid or puppy who jumps all over daddy when he comes home from work.

Just curious - do we know the order in which the HTDs were filmed?

Bhaka wrote:Just curious - do we know the order in which the HTDs were filmed?

AshLee, Catherine, Lindsay and Desiree :)

If Sean had a problem with Lindsay or her depth, why didn't he send Lindsay on her way?

Personally, I don't see a vast divide between Lindsay's enthusiasm and Catherine's teen gal squealing and love notes except maybe some winner's syndrome going on. It appears it is ok for one but not the other. When it's pretty obvious that they both seem to have an innate sweetness and fun loving personalities, in common - which most likely led to them being the final 2. JMO.

NCGalBecca wrote:If Sean had a problem with Lindsay or her depth, why didn't he send Lindsay on her way?

Personally, I don't see a vast divide between Lindsay's enthusiasm and Catherine's teen gal squealing and love notes except maybe some winner's syndrome going on. It appears it is ok for one but not the other. When it's pretty obvious that they both seem to have an innate sweetness and fun loving personalities, in common.

I second all of this . I think Catherine and Lindsay are so similar and I can see why they're Seans F2. It's sad because a lot of people here are biased.

ThankMeLater wrote:

NCGalBecca wrote:If Sean had a problem with Lindsay or her depth, why didn't he send Lindsay on her way?

Personally, I don't see a vast divide between Lindsay's enthusiasm and Catherine's teen gal squealing and love notes except maybe some winner's syndrome going on. It appears it is ok for one but not the other. When it's pretty obvious that they both seem to have an innate sweetness and fun loving personalities, in common.

I second all of this . I think Catherine and Lindsay are so similar and I can see why they're Seans F2. It's sad because a lot of people here are biased.

I agree that Lindsay and Cat are the perfect F2 for Sean. Chris H at Ashley's wedding said that JP was "serious." and I think he is perfect for Ash because he balances out her bubbly nature. Sean likes to joke but at times he can be a bit stiff. He needs someone who's bubbly and fun like a Lindsay or Cat to balance him out. Likewise, Lindsay and Cat need someone who's steady, strong and reliable like Sean.

He has a connection with the both of them. The only difference I see is what Sean said, that Cat "gets him" at his basic, nerd level. I think that is where he and Cat connect just a bit more.

chicagoowl wrote:

LoveDovez wrote:

julychild wrote:

Jeepers wrote:There are also flowers for Ashlee's parents .. Not sure about Dez And Lindsey

There is small gift bag in the car scene with Lindsay, I assume this is the gift he gave her mom. Meanwhile, did anyone else notice that Ashlee's mom left her flowers on the ground beside the table, while they were having lunch/dinner? I thought that was strange, maybe they never went inside the house during filming.

I sure don't think Lindsay could have gotten any closer to Sean in the car than she did. That would have been kinda invading my space. LOL

She's like a little kid or puppy who jumps all over daddy when he comes home from work.

They also both need to be in the camera shot.... so they start close to begin with.

NCGalBecca wrote:If Sean had a problem with Lindsay or her depth, why didn't he send Lindsay on her way?

Personally, I don't see a vast divide between Lindsay's enthusiasm and Catherine's teen gal squealing and love notes except maybe some winner's syndrome going on. It appears it is ok for one but not the other. When it's pretty obvious that they both seem to have an innate sweetness and fun loving personalities, in common - which most likely led to them being the final 2. JMO.

I agree. I like Lindsay, and I think that this is just a byproduct of finding out who the F1 is before we even get to know any of the women. I actually like all four of the remaining women, but had I not known the spoiler, I don't think that I would have picked Catherine as Sean's F1 at this point in the season....based on what I have seen so far. I actually felt like Dez was the frontrunner - up until the hometown visits.

Longhornfan wrote:

NCGalBecca wrote:If Sean had a problem with Lindsay or her depth, why didn't he send Lindsay on her way?

Personally, I don't see a vast divide between Lindsay's enthusiasm and Catherine's teen gal squealing and love notes except maybe some winner's syndrome going on. It appears it is ok for one but not the other. When it's pretty obvious that they both seem to have an innate sweetness and fun loving personalities, in common - which most likely led to them being the final 2. JMO.

I agree. I like Lindsay, and I think that this is just a byproduct of finding out who the F1 is before we even get to know any of the women. I actually like all four of the remaining women, but had I not known the spoiler, I don't think that I would have picked Catherine as Sean's F1 at this point in the season....based on what I have seen so far. I actually felt like Dez was the frontrunner - up until the hometown visits.

I'm on board with this. I think Lindsay is just fun loving and goofy. TPTB have chosen not to show us her serious side. I don't doubt that she has one, it just doesn't fit the storyline.

NCGalBecca wrote:Not that it matters but I think AshLee's date may have been filmed at a friend of the family's home. I recall seeing tweets from her Dad thanking the person for use of it and the friend tweeting Team AshLee type of tweets about it back in Nov.

I think so too.

NCGalBecca wrote:If Sean had a problem with Lindsay or her depth, why didn't he send Lindsay on her way?

Personally, I don't see a vast divide between Lindsay's enthusiasm and Catherine's teen gal squealing and love notes except maybe some winner's syndrome going on. It appears it is ok for one but not the other. When it's pretty obvious that they both seem to have an innate sweetness and fun loving personalities, in common - which most likely led to them being the final 2. JMO.

Well, I disagree. The reason I'm not a fan of Lindsay is that she doesn't seem very smart. She has made some of the most ridiculous statements this season and just seems, overall, like a dumb blonde. I'm sure she's very sweet and the girls seem to like her, but that kind of girl just turns me off. Catherine & Lesley were good friends because they're both bright, accomplished women. They're both well spoken. Yes, Catherine can be silly, but she's clever silly, not dumb silly. I would have been happy with Catherine, Lesley or Desiree as the next B'ette for this reason. No "winner's syndrome" for me, just am tired of women like Lindsay on TV and especially on The Bachelor.