Episode 5 - 2/04 - Bachelor 17 - Discussion - Spoilers

reason wrote:

happygirl77us wrote: I believe that Catherine was never F1 she was Sean second choice after Tierra left.

Funny I feel the opposite. I believe she was on his radar much more than Tierra and his prayers was answered.

Sean has a fantastic sense of humor, but I don't think he would be nearly as jokey and self-effacing about the Tierra situation as he's been on Twitter and in his interviews if she was always his first choice and she left. I think he'd be defending himself/rationalizing a lot more. I also don't think Shay would be publicly ragging on him about having kept her around for so long, if that were the case. As a big sister who adores my own brother, I know I wouldn't find any amusement or entertainment in knowing my brother had been genuinely hurt, and I doubt Shay would either.

In the deliberation room Sean made a coment that is exactly the same as what Cat said .. ANd I cant recall it now .. CRS is setting in LOL

reason wrote:

umngirl wrote:Must say, I love that Sean and Catherine had their alone time away from all the rest just like last episode in the driveway.

I dont see it can you point me to it please is it before Tierrable the year old

I believe it was after Tierra was shown at the group date to talk to Sean but I'm no entirely sure.

6th episode date for Cat .. TPTB driven .. As he said to Dez .. Cat wasn't going anywhere and she knew it :)

Archer23 wrote:

reason wrote:

happygirl77us wrote: I believe that Catherine was never F1 she was Sean second choice after Tierra left.

Funny I feel the opposite. I believe she was on his radar much more than Tierra and his prayers was answered.

Sean has a fantastic sense of humor, but I don't think he would be nearly as jokey and self-effacing about the Tiera situation as he's been on Twitter and in his interviews if she was always his first choice and she left. I think he'd be defending himself/rationalizing a lot more. I also don't think Shay would be publicly ragging on him about having kept her around for so long, if that were the case. As a big sister who adores my own brother, I know I wouldn't find any amusement or entertainment in knowing my brother had been genuinely hurt, and I doubt Shay would either.

Great post, Archer. : )

Jeepers wrote:6th episode date for Cat .. TPTB driven .. As he said to Dez .. Cat wasn't going anywhere and she knew it

It totally screams tptb

Archer23 wrote:

reason wrote:

happygirl77us wrote: I believe that Catherine was never F1 she was Sean second choice after Tierra left.

Funny I feel the opposite. I believe she was on his radar much more than Tierra and his prayers was answered.

Sean has a fantastic sense of humor, but I don't think he would be nearly as jokey and self-effacing about the Tiera situation as he's been on Twitter and in his interviews if she was always his first choice and she left. I think he'd be defending himself/rationalizing a lot more. I also don't think Shay would be publicly ragging on him about having kept her around for so long, if that were the case. As a big sister who adores my own brother, I know I wouldn't find any amusement or entertainment in knowing my brother had been genuinely hurt, and I doubt Shay would either.

I totally agree with you Archer. I haven't sensed any hurt from Sean over Tierra. From his tweets or interviews.

Archer23 wrote:

reason wrote:

happygirl77us wrote: I believe that Catherine was never F1 she was Sean second choice after Tierra left.

Funny I feel the opposite. I believe she was on his radar much more than Tierra and his prayers was answered.

Sean has a fantastic sense of humor, but I don't think he would be nearly as jokey and self-effacing about the Tiera situation as he's been on Twitter and in his interviews if she was always his first choice and she left. I think he'd be defending himself/rationalizing a lot more. I also don't think Shay would be publicly ragging on him about having kept her around for so long, if that were the case. As a big sister who adores my own brother, I know I wouldn't find any amusement or entertainment in knowing my brother had been genuinely hurt, and I doubt Shay would either.

That's a great point and I agree with you.

Litta123 wrote:
Also, I believe it was Catherine on the elephant. The arm of the girl had a darker complexion and the hair is almost waste length when sitting.

I'm with you!

Also, in Cat's bio for the show, she said that it was a dream to ride an elephant in Thailand. Dreams come true for her and Emily Maynard! Emily's bio also said something about elephants in Africa. Both F1s got their wish. It does make me wonder a bit about the producers' initial plans for Cat before Sean happened.

Sean and Cat aRe spending quality time together .. Whether we see it or ot

Well after tonight there is no doubt in my mind that Cat have this in the bag. He wants to snuggle with her and he is happy and lifting her like a baby man that guy has it bad that WEDDING is coming sooner rather than later.

chaslom4 wrote:

Archer23 wrote:

reason wrote:

happygirl77us wrote: I believe that Catherine was never F1 she was Sean second choice after Tierra left.

Funny I feel the opposite. I believe she was on his radar much more than Tierra and his prayers was answered.

Sean has a fantastic sense of humor, but I don't think he would be nearly as jokey and self-effacing about the Tiera situation as he's been on Twitter and in his interviews if she was always his first choice and she left. I think he'd be defending himself/rationalizing a lot more. I also don't think Shay would be publicly ragging on him about having kept her around for so long, if that were the case. As a big sister who adores my own brother, I know I wouldn't find any amusement or entertainment in knowing my brother had been genuinely hurt, and I doubt Shay would either.

I totally agree with you Archer. I haven't sensed any hurt from Sean over Tierra. From his tweets or interviews.

Chas and Archer, I absolutely agree with you!