Episode 5 - 2/04 - Bachelor 17 - Discussion - Spoilers

chicagoowl wrote:

sgjsnow wrote:I think the letter might be from Catherine. She has been giving him notes throughout so far. I wonder if it isn't necessarily a "negative" letter from her but they are playing it off that way in the previews. The VO of "How can she do this to me." during the letter previews was probably something he said another time during the season. I think they are trying to shake things up and make it seem like something it isn't. JMO

I agree! It's probably just a positive love letter. TPTB haven't shown us much of Sean & Cat's conversations until recently but they have made a point to show her giving him these notes. The "How can she do this to me." VO is probably spliced in from something else.

Yeah they love to splice that stuff in - that's what I'm thinking too about the "how can she do this to me"

NCGalBecca wrote:I noticed that Lindsay is there when AshLee and Tierra have their row in St. Croix. I wonder if this might mean she gets another 1:1 date (like Tierra and AshLee) or if it's only unfortunate timing for her. She seems to avoid the drama and is more of a casual observer.

I thought we saw Lesley in there too? Or maybe I was seeing things? Either way, I think it will mainly be just a AshLee vs. Tierra thing.

sanlee088 wrote:Thank goodness we all have different opinions here and they are always welcome!! :Smiley:

Nodding......

Maybe .. The letter is from Cat telling him that if she is the last one that she doesn't want a proposal .. But wants to wait to see how things go in the real world for a bit

NCGalBecca wrote:I noticed that Lindsay is there when AshLee and Tierra have their row in St. Croix. I wonder if this might mean she gets another 1:1 date (like Tierra and AshLee) or if it's only unfortunate timing for her. She seems to avoid the drama and is more of a casual observer.

Good Catch

Either way, ultimately I don't see Sean going with the process, just as I didn't see Tebow doing it either. If he doesn't want drama... he doesn't want it and is on the wrong show. IMO..He thought he loved Emily and the process worked but deep down (my new found lurve for Sean coming out!) I think he went with what he thought was the easiest (in a dreama type way) ergo Lindsay and Cat.. the women who ignored Tierra's antics. Catherine is a wonderful girl, I just don't see Sean marrying her JMO.

Jeepers wrote:Maybe .. The letter is from Cat telling him that if she is the last one that she doesn't want a proposal .. But wants to wait to see how things go in the real world for a bit

But that's too real-world and realistic in the scope of this show More likely, it's a love note from Catherine like she seemingly has been doing all along - probably with a plea at the end to not make her come up to the FRC if she's not the one

Must say, I love that Sean and Catherine had their alone time away from all the rest just like last episode in the driveway.

yrkiemommy wrote:

chicagoowl wrote:

sgjsnow wrote:I think the letter might be from Catherine. She has been giving him notes throughout so far. I wonder if it isn't necessarily a "negative" letter from her but they are playing it off that way in the previews. The VO of "How can she do this to me." during the letter previews was probably something he said another time during the season. I think they are trying to shake things up and make it seem like something it isn't. JMO

I agree! It's probably just a positive love letter. TPTB haven't shown us much of Sean & Cat's conversations until recently but they have made a point to show her giving him these notes. The "How can she do this to me." VO is probably spliced in from something else.

Yeah they love to splice that stuff in - that's what I'm thinking too about the "how can she do this to me"

I think this might be right. I slow-moded that letter and paused in several spots on our 55" screen. It seems to be talking positively about the journey and I think I saw the word memorable. Honestly, though, unless someone has amazing abilities to clean up the screencap, I don't think we're going to make out what it says. That said, it seemed to me that the scenery had the darker shadows...so it came with the later arrival.

Also, I believe it was Catherine on the elephant. The arm of the girl had a darker complexion and the hair is almost waste length when sitting.

umngirl wrote:Must say, I love that Sean and Catherine had their alone time away from all the rest just like last episode in the driveway.

I dont see it can you point me to it please is it before Tierrable the year old. Okay found it Did you all hear he said Catherine is someone that all he wants to do is snuggle with her

umngirl wrote:Must say, I love that Sean and Catherine had their alone time away from all the rest just like last episode in the driveway.

Me too! That means something imo! Reminds me of Ali and Roberto's SQT...

This may have already been discussed. But I found it interesting that the girl he asked straight up about Tierra was Lesley. IMO he asked her because he trusts her and her opinion, which to me could also mean friend zone.

I am still surprised by the 6th episode date for Cat. He just seems so giddy and excited around her, I am becoming a big fan of these two!