Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion - #2

mindless wrote:

Ladybug82 wrote:Maybe Sable can petition for custody of the girls.  And tell BOR to stuff it too.  

Though his love for Sabel Might be the only thing I actually like about him, these days.

Isn't it pretty telling though that the only woman Josh is able to love apart from his mom (who coddles him like no other) and sister (who probably looks up to him) is a dog? Loyal, obedient, always delighted to be around him. Where will he find a human female with those attributes?

Maybe he needs to just buy a large property and go rescue/save a lot of dogs.  There are plenty that need homes and would show him the love, locality and happiness to always see him he seems to crave.  And he'd never have to worry about them talking back or whispering dirty things in his ear.

peggy0221 wrote:

AllAboutLove wrote:Josh is the worst contestant ever, IMHO.

It is such a dramatic turn of things after all these years.
I remember majority of TB fans love him during Andi's season, believed he is the perfect all American Boy that if he was not F1, he's the next golden boy became the lead like Sean Lowe. And at least half of the viewer hated Nick and thought he's the evil stuck in Jodi's way to happiness.

I'm a little proud of myself that I always see through the real Josh behind his fake smile.

I am also proud to say that I NEVER liked him, and have posts from 2014 to show that.  

yana_bach wrote:'She wispered something nasty in my ear' has got to be the most ridiculous breakup reason ever! Unless it's two teenagers who've been dating for a week.
Please, please tell us the nasty thing!
'I like Nick' 'I'm a cat person', 'I got you It's not okay as a christmas present' 'Your mom is wierd' 'I don't believe you're god's gift to earth'...???

Hahaha, what a fun game!! thanks @yana_bach! Let's see:

"Your greasy sweat is making me nauseous."

"Slow down and chew between bites."

"I'd rather cut my hair off and never shill again than go home with you tonight."

(btw, I couldn't stand the sight of him from the first moment he walked onscreen. )

ET now reporting the break up too:
http://www.etonline.com/news/205446_bachelor_paradise_couple_josh_murray_and_amanda_stanton_split/

StacyNor wrote:

peggy0221 wrote:

AllAboutLove wrote:Josh is the worst contestant ever, IMHO.

It is such a dramatic turn of things after all these years.
I remember majority of TB fans love him during Andi's season, believed he is the perfect all American Boy that if he was not F1, he's the next golden boy became the lead like Sean Lowe. And at least half of the viewer hated Nick and thought he's the evil stuck in Jodi's way to happiness.

I'm a little proud of myself that I always see through the real Josh behind his fake smile.

I am also proud to say that I NEVER liked him, and have posts from 2014 to show that.  

I have also proudly never been a fan. Good to know my judge of character is right at least sometimes.

mindless wrote:

Ladybug82 wrote:Maybe Sable can petition for custody of the girls.  And tell BOR to stuff it too.  

Though his love for Sabel Might be the only thing I actually like about him, these days.

Isn't it pretty telling though that the only woman Josh is able to love apart from his mom (who coddles him like no other) and sister (who probably looks up to him) is a dog? Loyal, obedient, always delighted to be around him. Where will he find a human female with those attributes?

Maybe there's a submissive woman into pet play at the S & M clubs @KB_Mom suggested?

I have absolutely never been a Josh fan either. So every once in a while I call these people right!

Josh was a controlling, cartoonish BOR from Day 1. Total hot head. Kinda oily and like a used sales man too. And his mom is super strange and always has been. Oddest family involvement from any F1 OR lead ever. IMO. Honestly, of all the dudes who have been on this show... Josh is like at the total bottom of people I'd willingly want to date. How he managed to get engaged twice on this show, I'll never know.

And US magazine joins in:
http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/josh-murray-amanda-stanton-split-what-went-wrong-w456872

Has a few more details than TMZ article

mindless wrote:

Ladybug82 wrote:Maybe Sable can petition for custody of the girls.  And tell BOR to stuff it too.  

Though his love for Sabel Might be the only thing I actually like about him, these days.

Isn't it pretty telling though that the only woman Josh is able to love apart from his mom (who coddles him like no other) and sister (who probably looks up to him) is a dog? Loyal, obedient, always delighted to be around him. Where will he find a human female with those attributes?

To answer your question--one word: Comatose.
ETA: Being upset about her drinking in Tahoe can certainly only be the tip of that iceberg. There is much more to the story, IMO. Remember we had posted here photos of DUH in Tahoe on a jetski with a beer. Discussion took place as to the wisdom of such. So BOR had to have known there was liquor involved to a certain extent.

sosleepy wrote:I have absolutely never been a Josh fan either. So every once in a while I call these people right!

Josh was a controlling, cartoonish BOR from Day 1. Total hot head. Kinda oily and like a used sales man too. And his mom is super strange and always has been. Oddest family involvement from any F1 OR lead ever. IMO. Honestly, of all the dudes who have been on this show... Josh is like at the total bottom of people I'd willingly want to date. How he managed to get engaged twice on this show, I'll never know.

Count me into the Josh anti-fan club. He's more or less repulsed me from the moment I saw him. Well actually towards the end of Andi's season, when she kept doubting him and he still stuck around, I thought maybe he's not quite as bad as he seems, but that lasted a hot second. As soon as he made all those snide remarks about Nick after the finale while tweeting Bible quotes I was back to thinking he's nothing but a hypocritical jerk. Never in my wildest dreams (nightmares) did I think he'd manage to sink this low though. The description in that US article of his behaviour during the Tahoe trip is some seriously creepy stuff.

This is the thread until MBG show begins.

Josh is the WORST. On his IG story tonight he is having dinner with Steph...he shows her outfit (scrubs) and says your a working girl now, are you supporting yourself or are mommy and daddy still paying your bills? Steph nods her head yes that her parents pay her bills and takes Josh's crappy behavior in stride. IMO Josh is such a creep. I truly think he gets off on shading women....even his sister. Gross Gross Gross.                  
IMO