Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion - #2

I think the fact that Josh, Stephanie AND Aaron are all still single with failed engagements all of them says something.

That mom is weird. The whole Murray family dynamic is weird. There is being close, and then there are the Murrays. She sounds like the MIL from H-E-double hockey sticks to me.

As painful as it is for me to credit anything Andi has ever said, seems she had a point with the "cutting the cord" comment on Josh's HTD.

Sometimes I wonder if there was a mistake at the hospital with cutting the umbilical cord when Josh was born. A really unhealthy family dynamic IMO

I think the issue is solely with Josh and his mother. **edited**

Josh is a 30-something year old baby who runs to mommy any time there's an issue and she happily joins in. I don't know if it's because he left home at an early age for babseball and then he had failure of not making it to the big leagues, attending college later in life, etc. but the guy has issues he needs to work through and his mommy is just making it worse. JMO

Maybe it's a first born thing. So weird.

Sorry. I didn't follow the Josh/Andi cluster closely at all. Mostly because I found them both to be repulsive.

I just figured if MM treats one like she's a 3rd member of the relationship, she probably gets super unhealthily involved in the other two's business as well. We just don't know cause they aren't part of Bach family? Idk. But maybe it is with Joshy-Poo in particular. Either way, creepo freako!

^ Yeah, no worries. Steph is young. I think she graduated college within the past year or so and she's never been engaged, but that's not surprising for a 21-22 year old.

With Josh and MM I think the biggest part of it is public perception. She wants to control the narrative just as much as Josh likes to control the woman he's with. JMO

Kashathediva wrote:

iamreal2u wrote:

Kels0012 wrote:How was MM involved?

I wondered the same thing as well.  Did not see any sources here.

You didn't see any sources because I logged off fairly early. I have been under the weather this past month and am choosing to take a bit of time away.
I receive "news" as a mod. Many times from members who choose not to post. Then I will reach out and have those things verified. So as my post above indicated the dance involved MM and prior to that one Steph. Hope that answers the question.

Thanks Kashathediva. Feel better.

Please do not discuss Aaron's ex. TYIA

iamreal2u wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:

iamreal2u wrote:

I wondered the same thing as well.  Did not see any sources here.

You didn't see any sources because I logged off fairly early. I have been under the weather this past month and am choosing to take a bit of time away.
I receive "news" as a mod. Many times from members who choose not to post. Then I will reach out and have those things verified. So as my post above indicated the dance involved MM and prior to that one Steph. Hope that answers the question.

Thanks Kashathediva.  Feel better.

Ditto Kasha, hope you are feeling better soon.

Thanks everyone. Never fear, Kasha will be hanging around long after the lights have been turned off.

Hi all! I'm brand new and so happy to be here!

I have a question about Josh and Amanda. I've read the thread backwards a long ways, but couldn't find what "DUH" and "BOR" stand for. Can anyone let me know?

Thanks!

kleavs wrote:Hi all! I'm brand new and so happy to be here!

I have a question about Josh and Amanda. I've read the thread backwards a long ways, but couldn't find what "DUH" and "BOR" stand for. Can anyone let me know?

Thanks!

Aman-DUH and Box of Rocks.