Josh Murray - Amanda Stanton - BIP 3 - Discussion - #2

Or maybe she just hired him to babysit.  The ex may have been busy or maybe Josh is cheaper.

JMO

The band aid needs to just be ripped off in one swift move, but these two seem determined to slowly, agonizingly start peeling it off, pause and try to put it back on, only to inevitably start peeling it slowly again. Wash, rinse, repeat.

If they post a bunch of we are a happy family Christmas pics, I might literally barf.

JMO

Haha. Josh is so predictable      He posted that IG story of Kins right after RS doubled down on Twitter saying that he stands by his sources and Josh posting a 4 day old pic of him and Amanda is irrelevant.

The earlier pic was from 2 days ago, not 4, but many were still questioning it, so not surprised Josh pulled out the big guns, err... kids.

Surprised this hasn't been posted.

US Weekly Story

So I guess for now they're going with the truth that there are issues but they're still working on it. Honestly, the most troubling part of this article is the source saying they broke up but it's still in the air and it's been that way since the beginning.

And we know that's true based on ET's story that they'd broken up a few times before BIP even aired. And all I'm thinking is how is this healthy? And if you two keep breaking up, maybe it's time to see this as a sign that this is just not a good idea. We are not talking about a decade plus relationship that I can understanding fighting for. A less than a year relationship should not be this much work and this hard. Like others, I would be fine if those two were a dysfunctional mess just the two of them. But the fact that two little girls are involved in this is troubling.

I almost feel like the shilling and money aside, Amanda and Josh refuse to just put the final nail on this ridiculous charade of a relationship, because of all the people who said it was a bad idea. So sort of a "we'll show them". I can definitely see that being the case with Josh who has gotten so much flack since Andi's book and BIP aired.

I think it or some similar article was posted a couple pages back.  It has no new quotes directly from either of them. Only sources and pals. Why am I envisions MM having them on speed dial?  So IMO, that article does not answer anything official either way.  JMO though.

IMO it makes everything make sense and answers what's going on pretty clearly. It's obvious something happened in the relationship. RS is adamant with his report of them breaking up, there was the whole unfollowing spree but now Josh is posting on social media with the daughters. So to me all this fits perfectly with the story US Weekly is reporting that they broke up but things are still up in the air because that's what they've been doing for most of the relationship.

Again, this isn't the first time we've heard this. ET reported their multiple breakups that they didn't deny, even before the season aired. Plus, not for nothing, US Weekly reports on A List celebrities. I don't think it'd be that hard for them to find some direct sources to know what's going on with those two who aren't even D List.

lleyki wrote:IMO it makes everything make sense and answers what's going on pretty clearly. It's obvious something happened in the relationship. RS is adamant with his report of them breaking up, there was the whole unfollowing spree but now Josh is posting on social media with the daughters. So to me all this fits perfectly with the story US Weekly is reporting that they broke up but things are still up in the air because that's what they've been doing for most of the relationship.

Again, this isn't the first time we've heard this. ET reported their multiple breakups that they didn't deny, even before the season aired. Plus, not for nothing, US Weekly reports on A List celebrities. I don't think it'd be that hard for them to find some direct sources to know what's going on with those two who aren't even D List.

RS did say he specifically asked his sources if this was another one of their short-term breakups where they would get back together again and they seemed pretty certain it was not. So, either they just underestimated
how ridiculous these two are or they are broken up, but are making it seem like they're together for appearances. I'm guessing josh is still trying to get her back if he's in a hotel in LA and hasn't gone back home yet. IMO.

She clearly knows everything is not all righ, if they keep breaking up all the time. He's manipulative and controlling. She knows this, if she breaks up with him. And he doesn't like her at all. Why are they doing this?

It's interesting that she hasn't posted a pic of them (together or with the kids), but rather she's promoting her hair vitamins. 

This is getting interesting to say the least.

Reminder no discussion about the Bachelor 21 season in any thread other than it's own threads titled Spoilers.