Bachelor In Paradise - Season 3 - Potential Contestants - *Sleuthing - Spoilers* #2

sosleepy wrote:Hypothetically speaking, if there is a proposal (looking promising, kids!) does this put Josh in a special class of alums, like just Emily Maynard, with 2 proposals from this show??? Am I missing anyone else? Impressive, Josh, impressive.

Seriously though, these crazy kids play their cards right, and they'll be a bigger deal than Janner, fo sho!!

hmmm, yes. Are we speaking sucessful proposals or do we add failed ones also ? (Jason M, Ben F, Nick)

If so then Nick could be on track for 3 ? Maybe 3rd time lucky.

nd4reality wrote:Anyone know of Amandas girls are mexico bound ?

Idk but get them there ASAP to meet their new daddy!! I don't care if they have one already. That doesn't suit my ideas of what I want to see on the tv  

And bigger than Janner? No. Think major. Lifetime movie, here we come.

You all don't really think there could be a proposal at the end of BIP with JAM do you?  I hope not and that if there is really a true connection, they take a little time dating IRL first.  Amanda would definitely want to see how Josh is with her kids before she made any rash decisions, IMO.

Plus, what would Mamma Murray be there in Mexico with them, unless she can't help herself.  

Yea especially if any of her family have read andi's book...

nd4reality wrote:

sosleepy wrote:Hypothetically speaking, if there is a proposal (looking promising, kids!) does this put Josh in a special class of alums, like just Emily Maynard, with 2 proposals from this show??? Am I missing anyone else? Impressive, Josh, impressive.

Seriously though, these crazy kids play their cards right, and they'll be a bigger deal than Janner, fo sho!!

hmmm, yes. Are we speaking sucessful proposals or do we add failed ones also ?

If so then Nick could be on track for 3 ? Maybe 3rd time lucky.

LOL! I meant like engagements. Otherwise there have been plenty of also rans proposing more than once, or getting more than one proposal. Jason Mesnick, Ben Flapjack, Jen Schefft to name a few. Nick V. too, with the potential he goes into the TRIPLE club with Jen!!!

Legit double engagements - just Emily Maynard, and now maybe Josh. Baller!

MiniDiva wrote:You all don't really think there could be a proposal at the end of BIP with JAM do you?  I hope not and that if there is really a true connection, they take a little time dating IRL first.  Amanda would definitely want to see how Josh is with her kids before she made any rash decisions, IMO.

Plus, what would Mamma Murray be there in Mexico with them, unless she can't help herself.  

We are talking about Mama Murray, here. She can't help herself.

I can't believe there have been just 2 multiple engagements from this show. Technically Mesnic had 1 rejection, 1 on screen engagement and 1 on screen promise to date with Molly so he has already hit the trifecta.

Yeah so wonder if Nick will strike out again or if he will seal the deal this time.

MM is probably flying to Mexico to put a stop to this fast track romance.  

Speaking of Nick, RS hasn't said anything about him and I bet he is the surprise romance that no one knows about.  Just speculation.

I like the idea of Jared/Caila, my favorite contestants from each of their respective seasons (although I didn't love Jared as much on BiP) but still, just get him away from Ashley I so they can both move on with their lives, for the love of all that is holy (although not much in the Bachelor world is!).

Here is my take on Amanda.... I read alot about her last year and I did not think like she seemed right choice for Ben....but I think Josh would really be a great fit for her.  I think she really loved her Ex and was hoping for a HEA with him....but for reasons discussed last season it did not work out.  I think Amanda is a good mom and sweet gal IRL.  Josh with his strong but loyal personality would seem to suit her.  With two little kids....I bet she would love to find a nice stable love and a HEA.  I think the engagement process is part of Bach/Ette/BIP and if works great....if not the ring goes back to the bone pile at NL.  Really not much different than dating...but with a promise of a future.  I am super hopeful that Jam could end up being the real deal because I think both Amanda and Josh are ready to be married if they find the right one.  I would assume the Murrays would love Amanda because she is sweet, kind and the opposite of Andi in every way.

JMO

I think the only 'negative' I can think of Amanda would be that she might be a bit needy and clingy, but IMO that's exactly what Josh wants. I think he's a bit needy too, so they suit each other.

Fingersandtoes wrote:I think the only 'negative' I can think of Amanda would be that she might be a bit needy and clingy, but IMO that's exactly what Josh wants. I think he's a bit needy too, so they suit each other.

Negative??? I think this is exactly what Josh dreams of!! A woman completely, totally devoted to him/kids/family so he can be the protector and the kind of man he's always wanted to be. I screwed right up the first time I rooted for Josh in a couple but I have a feeling my judgement is going to redeem itself majorly