Josh Murray - Bachelorette 10 - Discussion - #8

reason wrote:I think Josh found out about her sleeping with Nick like the rest of us at the after.

But he chose to stay with her after that. His choice, so get over it.

Eskimo brothers. Uggh.

I disagree with him not knowing. I found it very very obvious that he repeatedly said in interviews how Andi was very open and honest with what happened on the show. Maybe he was lying but something tells me there is no way he would have been able to get over that.

bleuberry wrote:What a dumb dumb. Spit it out Josh.  He doesn't even subtweet well .

Is he implying that had he known about Nick that he would've made different decisions? Andi could've catfished him and he was still proposing. Who is he kidding.

He defined himself as winner of Ette 10 until 1 whole day ago, so yeah, as long as she was the Ette, she could have been a one armed, one legged, albino elf catfishing him online and he still would have proposed to be the big winnah here. He's not even a tool, he's an entire Ace Hardware store.

Alanna wrote:

bleuberry wrote:What a dumb dumb. Spit it out Josh.  He doesn't even subtweet well .

Is he implying that had he known about Nick that he would've made different decisions? Andi could've catfished him and he was still proposing. Who is he kidding.

He defined himself as winner of Ette 10 until 1 whole day ago, so yeah, as long as she was the Ette, she could have been a one armed, one legged, albino elf catfishing him online and he still would have proposed to be the big winnah here. He's not even a tool, he's an entire Ace Hardware store.

 Don't hold back, Alanna!   
The question remains, is he a full box? source

Kashathediva wrote:

Alanna wrote:

bleuberry wrote:What a dumb dumb. Spit it out Josh.  He doesn't even subtweet well .

Is he implying that had he known about Nick that he would've made different decisions? Andi could've catfished him and he was still proposing. Who is he kidding.

He defined himself as winner of Ette 10 until 1 whole day ago, so yeah, as long as she was the Ette, she could have been a one armed, one legged, albino elf catfishing him online and he still would have proposed to be the big winnah here. He's not even a tool, he's an entire Ace Hardware store.

 Don't hold back, Alanna!   
The question remains, is he a full box? source

He is definitely full of something. Can we start calling him Ace, kind of like Chris Manson for Harrison?

Stop insulting rocks, Kasha!! They don't deserve this comparison

Ace--I like it. Good nickname. Ha.

Just had to clear out that Josh knew about the Nick thing before ATFR. Chris Harrison said that Andi's reaction to Nick's speaking out, during the commercials was "thank God I was 100% honest with Josh". So he knew, and he also said that in a radio interview once.

reason wrote:I think Josh found out about her sleeping with Nick like the rest of us at the after.

No she told him on the FS date. Andi told CH that she was so glad that she was 100% honest with Josh because of Nick blabbing on ATFR. In all their interviews Josh says he knew everything so what he is trying to say I have no idea. Also that is why Andi kept saying it could all blow up in her face after she told Josh because he could have walked away.

It's actually AdvoCrap, not Advocare Crap, that's the whole joke. Man, I need to work on my delivery, is this thing on?!

Just guessing but I believe Andi probably told him before the ATFR, which makes her statement to CH true but after he actually had proposed. I don't think there is any evidence that she told him during their FSD. That is just personal opinion and speculation by posters and probably like me, some wishful thinking too at the time.