Bachelor 19 - Chris Soules - Episode - 11 - LCD - FRC - *Spoilers - Sleuthing*- Discussion

Rolly wrote:

Diana wrote:Choosing Becca would go against everything he ever said about finding a wife IMO. Clearly she is not ready. Now I admire her but she never should have come on to this show.I love how realistic she is but it's not what Chris wants. IMO. He was never going to pick her no matter how "torn" they pretend he was. JMO.

Realistic people need not apply. Only wannabe Bachelorette's who will literally sleep for the next role. Got it.

atem wrote:

Rolly wrote:

Diana wrote:Choosing Becca would go against everything he ever said about finding a wife IMO. Clearly she is not ready. Now I admire her but she never should have come on to this show.I love how realistic she is but it's not what Chris wants. IMO. He was never going to pick her no matter how "torn" they pretend he was. JMO.

Realistic people need not apply.  Only wannabe Bachelorette's who will literally sleep for the next role.  Got it.

or come already in love.

atem wrote:

Rolly wrote:

Diana wrote:Choosing Becca would go against everything he ever said about finding a wife IMO. Clearly she is not ready. Now I admire her but she never should have come on to this show.I love how realistic she is but it's not what Chris wants. IMO. He was never going to pick her no matter how "torn" they pretend he was. JMO.

Realistic people need not apply.  Only wannabe Bachelorette's who will literally sleep for the next role.  Got it.

No not that. She is just too normal for this crazy stuff and was never going to be F1. That is JMO. Not bashing or anything but she is too good for this show.

Litta123 wrote:Here's a clearer shot of Whitney in the limo. I've been making caps this morning so I haven't paid a lot of attention to the discussion here. Has it been discussed that the telephone poles are on the left side of the road heading into Lamont? So Whitney is heading north in this shot, imo.

Good observation. I also agree - IMO she's either headed north or west based on where the sun light shines in the limo and where the sun was in the sky at that time of year at that latitude and longitude.

Diana wrote:

atem wrote:

Rolly wrote:

Realistic people need not apply.  Only wannabe Bachelorette's who will literally sleep for the next role.  Got it.

No not that. She is just too normal for this crazy stuff and was never going to be F1. That is JMO. Not bashing or anything but she is too good for this show.

This makes me laugh. I would think that the farmer who lives in the town of 400 would prefer realistic to someone who plays the game of the show. Only one out of 18 or 19 if you want to count Brad twice has managed to marry his F1, two out of 18 marrying one of the F2. So maybe, just maybe the stars in your eyes, in love before you even knew the person schtick really doesn't work. Sean went with his heart and his gut. Cat was the one he couldn't let go, when on paper and from everything else, Lindsey, AshLee or even Des would have been a better pick. And because both Cat and Sean were willing to give it the time it needed it worked.

I find it laughable that not playing to the shows ridiculous premise, which has been shown repeatedly not to work, is considered to be a bad thing.

And sorry, I would rather someone pick me because they love me and can't imagine being without me then because I met a checklist.

stuckinsc wrote:

Diana wrote:

atem wrote:

Realistic people need not apply.  Only wannabe Bachelorette's who will literally sleep for the next role.  Got it.

No not that. She is just too normal for this crazy stuff and was never going to be F1. That is JMO. Not bashing or anything but she is too good for this show.

This makes me laugh.  I would think that the farmer who lives in the town of 400 would prefer realistic to someone who plays the game of the show.  Only one out of 18 or 19 if you want to count Brad twice has managed to marry his F1, two out of 18 marrying one of the F2.  So maybe, just maybe the stars in your eyes, in love before you even knew the person schtick really doesn't work.  Sean went with his heart and his gut.  Cat was the one he couldn't let go, when on paper and from everything else, Lindsey, AshLee or even Des would have been a better pick.  And because both Cat and Sean were willing to give it the time it needed it worked.  

I find it laughable that not playing to the shows ridiculous premise, which has been shown repeatedly not to work, is considered to be a bad thing.

And sorry, I would rather someone pick me because they love me and can't imagine being without me then because I met a checklist.

Ditto StuckinSC.:Nod:

Pia1 wrote:

stuckinsc wrote:

Diana wrote:
No not that. She is just too normal for this crazy stuff and was never going to be F1. That is JMO. Not bashing or anything but she is too good for this show.

This makes me laugh.  I would think that the farmer who lives in the town of 400 would prefer realistic to someone who plays the game of the show.  Only one out of 18 or 19 if you want to count Brad twice has managed to marry his F1, two out of 18 marrying one of the F2.  So maybe, just maybe the stars in your eyes, in love before you even knew the person schtick really doesn't work.  Sean went with his heart and his gut.  Cat was the one he couldn't let go, when on paper and from everything else, Lindsey, AshLee or even Des would have been a better pick.  And because both Cat and Sean were willing to give it the time it needed it worked.  

I find it laughable that not playing to the shows ridiculous premise, which has been shown repeatedly not to work, is considered to be a bad thing.

And sorry, I would rather someone pick me because they love me and can't imagine being without me then because I met a checklist.

Ditto StuckinSC.:Nod:

stuckinsc wrote:

Diana wrote:

atem wrote:

Realistic people need not apply.  Only wannabe Bachelorette's who will literally sleep for the next role.  Got it.

No not that. She is just too normal for this crazy stuff and was never going to be F1. That is JMO. Not bashing or anything but she is too good for this show.

This makes me laugh.  I would think that the farmer who lives in the town of 400 would prefer realistic to someone who plays the game of the show.  Only one out of 18 or 19 if you want to count Brad twice has managed to marry his F1, two out of 18 marrying one of the F2.  So maybe, just maybe the stars in your eyes, in love before you even knew the person schtick really doesn't work.  Sean went with his heart and his gut.  Cat was the one he couldn't let go, when on paper and from everything else, Lindsey, AshLee or even Des would have been a better pick.  And because both Cat and Sean were willing to give it the time it needed it worked.  

I find it laughable that not playing to the shows ridiculous premise, which has been shown repeatedly not to work, is considered to be a bad thing.

And sorry, I would rather someone pick me because they love me and can't imagine being without me then because I met a checklist.

Well me too but we aren't Chris. My point was there was no way IMO CHRIS WOULD choose her. That is my opinion. I am not bashing Becca or saying she did a bad thing my point is that it doesn't really work for the premise of this show which is why no one ends up marrying who they choose.

Diana wrote:

stuckinsc wrote:

Diana wrote:
No not that. She is just too normal for this crazy stuff and was never going to be F1. That is JMO. Not bashing or anything but she is too good for this show.

This makes me laugh.  I would think that the farmer who lives in the town of 400 would prefer realistic to someone who plays the game of the show.  Only one out of 18 or 19 if you want to count Brad twice has managed to marry his F1, two out of 18 marrying one of the F2.  So maybe, just maybe the stars in your eyes, in love before you even knew the person schtick really doesn't work.  Sean went with his heart and his gut.  Cat was the one he couldn't let go, when on paper and from everything else, Lindsey, AshLee or even Des would have been a better pick.  And because both Cat and Sean were willing to give it the time it needed it worked.  

I find it laughable that not playing to the shows ridiculous premise, which has been shown repeatedly not to work, is considered to be a bad thing.

And sorry, I would rather someone pick me because they love me and can't imagine being without me then because I met a checklist.

Well me too but we aren't Chris. My point was there was no way IMO CHRIS WOULD choose her. That is my opinion. I am not bashing Becca or saying she did a bad thing my point is that it doesn't really work for the premise of this show which is why no one ends up marrying who they choose.

Is it possible that in the end Chris does pick the person he loves and can't imagine living without?

This is a pointless debate. Forget I even said anything. I wasn't trying to start a war. I am just saying Becca is too good for this show.

Rolly, I think he did.

Do we know what Whitney did for her LCD?

More like Chris S. has to pick and makes his pick. Doesn't make her the 'love of his life'.